{
  "updated": "2026-10-30",
  "timezone": "America/Chicago",
  "reviewStatus": "Page-Ladson Tables S3/S4/S10 and Figure S12 inspected in the original PDF; Ohalo II and Paisley rows remain provisional indexed-text transcriptions. Original laboratory certificates have not been inspected",
  "groups": [
    {
      "id": "ohalo",
      "site": "ohalo-ii",
      "title": "Ohalo II · charcoal and hut floors",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S194"
      ],
      "summary": "The 1995 paper reports 26 determinations. Eight selected rows begin the context register; they are not the complete series. The authors infer brief repeated occupations from archaeology, not from the spread of radiocarbon values.",
      "method": "Conventional radiocarbon BP only. This paper did not calibrate the dates; the published ± values are retained without introducing new calendar intervals. Floor-to-sample joins remain incomplete.",
      "samples": [
        {
          "id": "OH-RT-1625",
          "lab": "RT-1625",
          "material": "Charcoal",
          "context": "Locus 1 · D81c",
          "level": "212.35 / 212.33 m below sea level",
          "ageBP": 21050,
          "sigmaBP": 330,
          "calibrated": null,
          "relationship": "Elevation differs in indexed Tables 2/3; hold for image check.",
          "sourceId": "S194",
          "locator": "Tables 2–3, pp. 818–819; Figs. 9–10, p. 816",
          "reviewStatus": "provisional-indexed-text"
        },
        {
          "id": "OH-RT-1616",
          "lab": "RT-1616",
          "material": "Pistacia atlantica charcoal",
          "context": "Locus 1 · E80b",
          "level": "212.40–212.45 m below sea level",
          "ageBP": 19590,
          "sigmaBP": 150,
          "calibrated": null,
          "relationship": "Fig. 9 locates the square, not an individual floor assignment.",
          "sourceId": "S194",
          "locator": "Tables 2–3, pp. 818–819; Figs. 9–10, p. 816",
          "reviewStatus": "provisional-indexed-text"
        },
        {
          "id": "OH-RT-1617",
          "lab": "RT-1617",
          "material": "Populus euphratica charcoal",
          "context": "Locus 1 · E80b",
          "level": "212.50–212.55 m below sea level",
          "ageBP": 18700,
          "sigmaBP": 180,
          "calibrated": null,
          "relationship": "Same square as RT-1616; lower collection is radiocarbon-younger.",
          "sourceId": "S194",
          "locator": "Tables 2–3, pp. 818–819; Figs. 9–10, p. 816",
          "reviewStatus": "provisional-indexed-text"
        },
        {
          "id": "OH-RT-1623",
          "lab": "RT-1623",
          "material": "Tamarix charcoal",
          "context": "Locus 1 · G80c",
          "level": "212.41–212.43 m below sea level",
          "ageBP": 18210,
          "sigmaBP": 240,
          "calibrated": null,
          "relationship": "Hut context; precise floor unlinked.",
          "sourceId": "S194",
          "locator": "Tables 2–3, pp. 818–819; Figs. 9–10, p. 816",
          "reviewStatus": "provisional-indexed-text"
        },
        {
          "id": "OH-RT-1619",
          "lab": "RT-1619",
          "material": "Tamarix charcoal",
          "context": "Locus 2 · E85d",
          "level": "212.25–212.32 m below sea level",
          "ageBP": 19860,
          "sigmaBP": 190,
          "calibrated": null,
          "relationship": "Fig. 10: middle of the exposed section.",
          "sourceId": "S194",
          "locator": "Tables 2–3, pp. 818–819; Figs. 9–10, p. 816",
          "reviewStatus": "provisional-indexed-text"
        },
        {
          "id": "OH-RT-1297",
          "lab": "RT-1297",
          "material": "Charcoal",
          "context": "Locus 2 · E86b",
          "level": "212.38–212.43 m below sea level",
          "ageBP": 17500,
          "sigmaBP": 200,
          "calibrated": null,
          "relationship": "Authors question pretreatment; omitted from their 24-date mean.",
          "sourceId": "S194",
          "locator": "Tables 2–3, pp. 818–819; Figs. 9–10, p. 816",
          "reviewStatus": "provisional-indexed-text"
        },
        {
          "id": "OH-RT-1618",
          "lab": "RT-1618",
          "material": "Tamarix charcoal",
          "context": "Locus 2 · F86b",
          "level": "212.32–212.36 m below sea level",
          "ageBP": 19220,
          "sigmaBP": 180,
          "calibrated": null,
          "relationship": "Hut context; precise floor unlinked.",
          "sourceId": "S194",
          "locator": "Tables 2–3, pp. 818–819; Figs. 9–10, p. 816",
          "reviewStatus": "provisional-indexed-text"
        },
        {
          "id": "OH-RT-1246",
          "lab": "RT-1246",
          "material": "Charcoal",
          "context": "Locus 4 · AB87",
          "level": "Surface",
          "ageBP": 15550,
          "sigmaBP": 130,
          "calibrated": null,
          "relationship": "Authors discuss later material, contamination or pretreatment; omitted from mean.",
          "sourceId": "S194",
          "locator": "Tables 2–3, pp. 818–819; Figs. 9–10, p. 816",
          "reviewStatus": "provisional-indexed-text"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "page-ladson",
      "site": "page-ladson",
      "title": "Page-Ladson · wood beside stone",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S27",
        "S195"
      ],
      "summary": "Biface 12080-1 was found in situ at 10.84 m below datum, but its northing differs: §1.3 gives N50.23, Table S10 N50.32 (both E23.22). Flake 12242-1 was screen-recovered; its Table S10 position N49.03/E23.05, depth 10.78 is an inferred collection context, not an observed in-situ point. Wood dates constrain these contexts, not stone manufacture.",
      "method": "Tables S3/S4 are now image-checked: 42 measurements, including all 37 inputs named by the 50N/23E figure. Their 1σ calendar intervals are separate from the OxCal 4.2.4 / IntCal13 model. Figure S12 marks eight exclusions, while §2.4 reports nine. The model has not been rerun.",
      "samples": [
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-153343",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-153343",
          "material": "Unidentified hardwood twig",
          "context": "Unit 4b/4c interface · 50N/22E",
          "level": "9.75 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12260,
          "sigmaBP": 35,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14220,
            "younger": 14088,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "relationship": "Organic lamina; separate unit. Absence from Fig. S12 does not identify a ninth excluded outlier.",
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF p. 27",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "outside-model",
          "modelLabel": "Different excavation unit; not in Fig. S12"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141928",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141928",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Unidentified diffuse-porous hardwood twig",
          "context": "Unit 4b · 50N/23E",
          "level": "9.80 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12335,
          "sigmaBP": 35,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14399,
            "younger": 14151,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "combined-retained",
          "modelLabel": "Combine UCIAMS-141928/141929"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141929",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141929",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Unidentified ring-porous hardwood twig",
          "context": "Unit 4b · 50N/23E",
          "level": "9.80 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12270,
          "sigmaBP": 30,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14228,
            "younger": 14100,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "combined-retained",
          "modelLabel": "Combine UCIAMS-141928/141929"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141930",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141930",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Water hickory (Carya cf. aquatic, as printed) wood",
          "context": "Unit 4b · 50N/23E",
          "level": "9.90 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12370,
          "sigmaBP": 30,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14499,
            "younger": 14209,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "retained",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141930"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141931",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141931",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "American beech wood",
          "context": "Unit 4b · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.00 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12275,
          "sigmaBP": 30,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14236,
            "younger": 14104,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "retained",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141931"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141932",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141932",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Hickory twig",
          "context": "Unit 4b · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.10 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12310,
          "sigmaBP": 30,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14303,
            "younger": 14127,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "retained",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141932"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141933",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141933",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Bald cypress wood",
          "context": "Unit 4b · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.20 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12295,
          "sigmaBP": 35,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14279,
            "younger": 14113,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "retained",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141933"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141934",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141934",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "American beech wood",
          "context": "Unit 4b · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.30 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12365,
          "sigmaBP": 30,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14482,
            "younger": 14199,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "combined-retained",
          "modelLabel": "Combine UCIAMS-141934/141935"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141935",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141935",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Unidentified hardwood twig",
          "context": "Unit 4b · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.30 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12250,
          "sigmaBP": 35,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14206,
            "younger": 14079,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "combined-retained",
          "modelLabel": "Combine UCIAMS-141934/141935"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141937",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141937",
          "relationship": "Table S3: below shell; broader sequence above the biface.",
          "material": "Red mulberry wood",
          "context": "Unit 4b · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.40 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12380,
          "sigmaBP": 35,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14544,
            "younger": 14226,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "retained",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141937"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141938",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141938",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Unidentified hardwood",
          "context": "Unit 4a · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.50 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12440,
          "sigmaBP": 30,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14720,
            "younger": 14385,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "retained",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141938"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141939",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141939",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Unidentified hardwood twig",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.55 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12430,
          "sigmaBP": 35,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14693,
            "younger": 14350,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "combined-retained",
          "modelLabel": "Combine UCIAMS-141939/141940/141941"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141940",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141940",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Ash twig",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.55 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12430,
          "sigmaBP": 30,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14690,
            "younger": 14360,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "combined-retained",
          "modelLabel": "Combine UCIAMS-141939/141940/141941"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141941",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141941",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Unidentified hardwood, mostly central pith twig",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.55 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12365,
          "sigmaBP": 30,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14482,
            "younger": 14199,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "combined-retained",
          "modelLabel": "Combine UCIAMS-141939/141940/141941"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141942",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141942",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Unidentified hardwood twig",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.60 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12440,
          "sigmaBP": 30,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14720,
            "younger": 14385,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "combined-retained",
          "modelLabel": "Combine UCIAMS-141942/141943"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141943",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141943",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Oak twig",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.60 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12410,
          "sigmaBP": 30,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14641,
            "younger": 14317,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "combined-retained",
          "modelLabel": "Combine UCIAMS-141942/141943"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141944",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141944",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Bald cypress twig",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.65 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12410,
          "sigmaBP": 35,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14646,
            "younger": 14312,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "combined-retained",
          "modelLabel": "Combine UCIAMS-141944/141945"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141945",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141945",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Bald cypress twig",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.65 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12400,
          "sigmaBP": 35,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14615,
            "younger": 14283,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "combined-retained",
          "modelLabel": "Combine UCIAMS-141944/141945"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141946",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141946",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Ash twig",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.70 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12400,
          "sigmaBP": 35,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14615,
            "younger": 14283,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "retained",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141946"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141947",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141947",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Bald cypress wood",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.70 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 13440,
          "sigmaBP": 40,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 16254,
            "younger": 16092,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "marked-excluded",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141947?"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141948",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141948",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Ash wood",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.75 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12430,
          "sigmaBP": 30,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14690,
            "younger": 14360,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "retained",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141948"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141949",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141949",
          "material": "Oak twig",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.80 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12385,
          "sigmaBP": 35,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14560,
            "younger": 14238,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "relationship": "At biface level",
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "retained",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141949"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-127302",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-127302",
          "material": "Maple / box elder wood",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.84 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12425,
          "sigmaBP": 30,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14676,
            "younger": 14348,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "relationship": "Wall above biface",
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "combined-retained",
          "modelLabel": "Combine UCIAMS-127302/127304"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-127304",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-127304",
          "material": "Fir wood",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.84 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12420,
          "sigmaBP": 30,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14664,
            "younger": 14338,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "relationship": "Beside biface",
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "combined-retained",
          "modelLabel": "Combine UCIAMS-127302/127304"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-127305",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-127305",
          "material": "Unknown periderm bark",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.84 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 13015,
          "sigmaBP": 30,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 15699,
            "younger": 15483,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "relationship": "Beside biface; older result preserved in this ledger; marked excluded in Fig. S12",
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "marked-excluded",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-127305?"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-127303",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-127303",
          "material": "Ash wood",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.85 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12495,
          "sigmaBP": 30,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14929,
            "younger": 14586,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "relationship": "Below biface",
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "combined-retained",
          "modelLabel": "Combine UCIAMS-127303/141951"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141950",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141950",
          "material": "Bald cypress wood",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.85 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 13830,
          "sigmaBP": 35,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 16861,
            "younger": 16623,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "relationship": "At biface level; older result preserved in this ledger; marked excluded in Fig. S12",
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "marked-excluded",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141950?"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141951",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141951",
          "material": "White-oak group wood",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.85 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12415,
          "sigmaBP": 30,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14652,
            "younger": 14328,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "relationship": "At biface level",
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "combined-retained",
          "modelLabel": "Combine UCIAMS-127303/141951"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141952",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141952",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "White-oak group wood",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.90 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12385,
          "sigmaBP": 35,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14560,
            "younger": 14238,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "retained",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141952"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141953",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141953",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Bald cypress wood",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "10.95 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 14510,
          "sigmaBP": 40,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 17776,
            "younger": 17589,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "marked-excluded",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141953?"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141954",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141954",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Bald cypress wood",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "11.00 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 13005,
          "sigmaBP": 35,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 15683,
            "younger": 15455,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "marked-excluded",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141954?"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141955",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141955",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Bald cypress wood",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "11.05 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 13585,
          "sigmaBP": 35,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 16450,
            "younger": 16264,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "marked-excluded",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141955?"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141956",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141956",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Bald cypress twig",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "11.10 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12395,
          "sigmaBP": 30,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14585,
            "younger": 14266,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "retained",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141956"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141957",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141957",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Oak twig",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 50N/23E",
          "level": "11.15 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12420,
          "sigmaBP": 30,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14664,
            "younger": 14338,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "retained",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141957"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141958",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141958",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Bald cypress twig",
          "context": "Unit 3a · 50N/23E",
          "level": "11.20 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12495,
          "sigmaBP": 35,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14931,
            "younger": 14569,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "retained",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141958"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141959",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141959",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Bald cypress twig",
          "context": "Unit 3a · 50N/23E",
          "level": "11.25 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12615,
          "sigmaBP": 35,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 15120,
            "younger": 14910,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "retained",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141959"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141960",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141960",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Bald cypress wood",
          "context": "Unit 3a · 50N/23E",
          "level": "11.35 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 13945,
          "sigmaBP": 50,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 17040,
            "younger": 16806,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "marked-excluded",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141960?"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-141961",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-141961",
          "relationship": "Stratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.",
          "material": "Bald cypress wood",
          "context": "Unit 3a · 50N/23E",
          "level": "11.48 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 13080,
          "sigmaBP": 40,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 15792,
            "younger": 15598,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "marked-excluded",
          "modelLabel": "UCIAMS-141961?"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-143535",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-143535",
          "material": "Unidentified hardwood",
          "context": "Unit 4b · 49N/24E",
          "level": "10.13 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12420,
          "sigmaBP": 30,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14664,
            "younger": 14338,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "relationship": "Table S4: near flake; relates to later Unit 4 finds, not the Unit 3c biface. Section 1.4 inconsistently calls these flakes 4b and 4a.",
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S4, PDF p. 30; §1.4",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "outside-model",
          "modelLabel": "Different excavation unit; not in Fig. S12"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-143536",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-143536",
          "material": "Unidentified hardwood root",
          "context": "Unit 4b · 49N/24E",
          "level": "10.17 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12360,
          "sigmaBP": 35,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14477,
            "younger": 14188,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "relationship": "Table S4: near flake; relates to later Unit 4 finds, not the Unit 3c biface. Section 1.4 inconsistently calls these flakes 4b and 4a.",
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S4, PDF p. 30; §1.4",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "outside-model",
          "modelLabel": "Different excavation unit; not in Fig. S12"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-143537",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-143537",
          "material": "Unidentified wood",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 49N/23E",
          "level": "10.78 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12560,
          "sigmaBP": 35,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 15038,
            "younger": 14787,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "relationship": "Assigned to the flake collection context through unit/depth and Table S10. Section 1.4 describes samples from the top/bottom of the excavated corner, not direct contact with a piece-plotted flake.",
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S4, PDF p. 30; Table S10, p. 63; §1.4, pp. 12–13",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "outside-model",
          "modelLabel": "Different excavation unit; not in Fig. S12"
        },
        {
          "id": "PL-UCIAMS-143538",
          "lab": "UCIAMS-143538",
          "material": "Unidentified hardwood root",
          "context": "Unit 3c · 49N/23E",
          "level": "10.78 m below datum",
          "ageBP": 12430,
          "sigmaBP": 35,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 14693,
            "younger": 14350,
            "confidence": "1σ, as reported",
            "method": "Published table interval; not recalculated"
          },
          "relationship": "Assigned to the flake collection context through unit/depth and Table S10. Section 1.4 describes samples from the top/bottom of the excavated corner, not direct contact with a piece-plotted flake.",
          "sourceId": "S195",
          "locator": "Table S4, PDF p. 30; Table S10, p. 63; §1.4, pp. 12–13",
          "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
          "modelStatus": "outside-model",
          "modelLabel": "Different excavation unit; not in Fig. S12"
        }
      ],
      "reviewLabel": "Original publication images checked · model not reproduced"
    },
    {
      "id": "paisley",
      "site": "paisley-caves",
      "title": "Paisley Caves · three later dietary specimens",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S191"
      ],
      "summary": "These three measurements date specimens in the later dietary study. They do not inherit the early weft age. Human origin is the authors’ interpretation from multiple observations; these three are not individually confirmed by the early lipid study.",
      "method": "Published conventional radiocarbon BP and 2σ calibrated intervals remain separate. Table 2 specifies IntCal13 and OxCal 4.3. No recalibration was performed.",
      "samples": [
        {
          "id": "PC-OxA-38445",
          "lab": "OxA-38445",
          "specimen": "98",
          "catalog": "1896-PC-2/6D-51-12",
          "material": "Uncharred unidentified plant fiber",
          "context": "Cave 2 · unit 6 · D · LU 3",
          "level": "1365.75 m above sea level",
          "ageBP": 10407,
          "sigmaBP": 37,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 12515,
            "younger": 12087,
            "confidence": "2σ, as reported",
            "method": "IntCal13 · OxCal 4.3"
          },
          "relationship": "Bulk plant material recovered from this coprolite; direct specimen association, not an assay on every dietary constituent.",
          "sourceId": "S191",
          "locator": "Tables 1–2, article pp. 7–10",
          "reviewStatus": "provisional-indexed-text"
        },
        {
          "id": "PC-OxA-38674",
          "lab": "OxA-38674",
          "specimen": "55",
          "catalog": "1961-PC-2/7C-16-136",
          "material": "Charcoal and uncharred unidentified plant fiber",
          "context": "Cave 2 · unit 7 · C · LU 3",
          "level": "1365.85 m above sea level",
          "ageBP": 10262,
          "sigmaBP": 57,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 12376,
            "younger": 11767,
            "confidence": "2σ, as reported",
            "method": "IntCal13 · OxCal 4.3"
          },
          "relationship": "Bulk plant material recovered from this coprolite; direct specimen association, not an assay on every dietary constituent.",
          "sourceId": "S191",
          "locator": "Tables 1–2, article pp. 7–10",
          "reviewStatus": "provisional-indexed-text"
        },
        {
          "id": "PC-OxA-38415",
          "lab": "OxA-38415",
          "specimen": "242",
          "catalog": "1895-PC-5/16A-21-1",
          "material": "Charcoal and uncharred unidentified plant fiber",
          "context": "Cave 5 · unit 16 · A · LU 2",
          "level": "1366.11 m above sea level",
          "ageBP": 9663,
          "sigmaBP": 29,
          "calibrated": {
            "older": 11196,
            "younger": 10823,
            "confidence": "2σ, as reported",
            "method": "IntCal13 · OxCal 4.3"
          },
          "relationship": "Bulk plant material recovered from this coprolite; direct specimen association, not an assay on every dietary constituent.",
          "sourceId": "S191",
          "locator": "Tables 1–2, article pp. 7–10",
          "reviewStatus": "provisional-indexed-text"
        }
      ]
    }
  ],
  "issues": [
    {
      "id": "OH-ELEVATION",
      "title": "Ohalo: resolve a table discrepancy",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S194"
      ],
      "text": "RT-1625 has indexed elevations −212.35 and −212.33 in Tables 2 and 3. Neither is silently preferred; OCR versus a printed discrepancy remains unresolved."
    },
    {
      "id": "PL-JOINS",
      "title": "Page-Ladson: eight marked, nine reported",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S195"
      ],
      "text": "The original Figure S12 is now inspected and all 37 50N/23E inputs joined. Eight IDs bear exclusion marks; §2.4 says nine. UCIAMS-141936 appears in neither Table S3 nor the figure and cannot be invented as the missing date. UCIAMS-153343 is from another unit, not an identified ninth outlier. Original model code/output remains needed."
    },
    {
      "id": "PL-FIELD",
      "title": "Page-Ladson: field precision and printed discrepancies",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S195"
      ],
      "text": "Biface northing is N50.23 in §1.3 but N50.32 in Table S10. Flake 12242-1 was screen-recovered from a restricted excavated corner; its coordinates are inferred context. Section 1.4 describes top/bottom samples but Table S4 gives both near-flake rows depth 10.78, leaving individual upper/lower assignments unlinked. Section 2.4 also prints a 41,100 cal BP endpoint inconsistent with the figure; retain it as a flagged publication error, not an early human date."
    },
    {
      "id": "PC-195",
      "title": "Paisley: retain both discordant measurements",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S188",
        "S191"
      ],
      "text": "Specimen 195 is listed as Beta-213423: 10,050 ± 50 and OxA-16376: 10,965 ± 50 radiocarbon BP. The published combined age is held from plotting until its inputs and agreement test are checked. Mixed human/carnivore signals are a separate identity issue."
    },
    {
      "id": "PC-EARLY",
      "title": "Paisley: early weft and coprolite identity",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S188",
        "S193"
      ],
      "text": "Original supplementary Tables S1/S3 and weft calibration remain unread. Specimen 194’s shared catalog number still prevents a secure DNA-to-lipid subsample join."
    },
    {
      "id": "MV-ALGAE",
      "title": "Monte Verde: original algae documentation",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S9"
      ],
      "text": "The 2008 Dillehay.som.pdf endpoint was located but could not be retrieved. Beta-238355 and Beta-239650 retain their existing values and unresolved calibration/reservoir metadata. Certificates and original feature records remain open targets."
    }
  ],
  "access": [
    {
      "sourceId": "S194",
      "status": "Indexed author-uploaded article read",
      "detail": "Tables 2/3 and figure captions accessible as text; PDF retrieval failed. No image verification or original certificate inspection."
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S195",
      "status": "Original PDF and figure images inspected",
      "detail": "Europe PMC supplementary archive retrieved. Figure S12, Tables S3/S4/S10, §2.4 and field text checked. All 42 S3/S4 measurements transcribed; core Table S2 is outside this register. Publication images do not replace original lab certificates, field sheets or OxCal output."
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S191",
      "status": "Indexed primary article tables read",
      "detail": "Tables 1/2 available in author and institutional copies; PDF screenshot retrieval failed. Three new assay rows transcribed provisionally."
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S188",
      "status": "Supplement located, not read",
      "detail": "Publisher and PMC supplement routes did not deliver a readable PDF in this pass. No missing fields inferred."
    },
    {
      "sourceId": "S9",
      "status": "2008 supplement located, not read",
      "detail": "Publisher endpoint returned 403. Later papers are not substitutes for the original calibration output."
    }
  ],
  "coverage": "Atlas/globe coverage checked. Page-Ladson retains the approximately 14,550 cal BP contextual estimate with the model discrepancy and screen-recovery caveat attached. Older excluded wood does not create earlier human markers. Later Unit 4 context samples do not inherit the Unit 3c date. Other sites and chronology remain unchanged.",
  "modelAudit": {
    "id": "PL-S12",
    "title": "Page-Ladson · what the model includes",
    "sourceIds": [
      "S195"
    ],
    "locator": "§2.4, PDF pp. 31–34; Table S3, pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, p. 34",
    "reviewStatus": "publication-image-checked",
    "reportedInputCount": 37,
    "reportedExcludedCount": 9,
    "figureExcludedIds": [
      "PL-UCIAMS-141947",
      "PL-UCIAMS-127305",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141950",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141953",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141954",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141955",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141960",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141961"
    ],
    "figureRetainedIds": [
      "PL-UCIAMS-141928",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141929",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141930",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141931",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141932",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141933",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141934",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141935",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141937",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141938",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141939",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141940",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141941",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141942",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141943",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141944",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141945",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141946",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141948",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141949",
      "PL-UCIAMS-127302",
      "PL-UCIAMS-127304",
      "PL-UCIAMS-127303",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141951",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141952",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141956",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141957",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141958",
      "PL-UCIAMS-141959"
    ],
    "combinedGroups": [
      [
        "PL-UCIAMS-141928",
        "PL-UCIAMS-141929"
      ],
      [
        "PL-UCIAMS-141934",
        "PL-UCIAMS-141935"
      ],
      [
        "PL-UCIAMS-141939",
        "PL-UCIAMS-141940",
        "PL-UCIAMS-141941"
      ],
      [
        "PL-UCIAMS-141942",
        "PL-UCIAMS-141943"
      ],
      [
        "PL-UCIAMS-141944",
        "PL-UCIAMS-141945"
      ],
      [
        "PL-UCIAMS-127302",
        "PL-UCIAMS-127304"
      ],
      [
        "PL-UCIAMS-127303",
        "PL-UCIAMS-141951"
      ]
    ],
    "summary": "Eight question-marked samples can be matched to the table: seven bald-cypress wood samples and one bark sample. The figure accounts for all 37 samples from 50N/23E: eight marked excluded and 29 retained individually or in combinations. Section 2.4 instead says nine were removed. This is a publication-level mismatch; no ninth ID is invented.",
    "biface": "Of the seven biface-related assays, five enter the displayed model: 141949 individually, 127302/127304 combined, and 127303/141951 combined. Bark 127305 and cypress 141950 are marked excluded. These are associated plant remains, not seven independent direct dates on a human action.",
    "retainedPair": "UCIAMS-141934 (12,365 ± 30) and 141935 (12,250 ± 35 radiocarbon BP) remain combined. The authors report a failed chi-square test but retain the combination with agreement 89.6. Their reported model/overall agreement values are 123.3/126.1; these are not percentages of certainty.",
    "interpretation": "The visual audit clarifies the published approximately 14,550 cal BP interpretation; it does not independently reproduce it or supply a replacement age. Larger, older wood may predate deposition or have been redeposited. Several bald-cypress twigs remain in the model, so exclusion was not simply a rule against that species.",
    "next": "Recover the original OxCal command file and output to reconcile eight marked exclusions versus nine reported, then test the retained 141934/141935 combination and exclusion choices. Any sensitivity result must specify its assumptions and be kept separate from the published chronology.",
    "archiveUrl": "https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC4928949/supplementaryFiles",
    "pdfFile": "1600375_SM.pdf",
    "sha256": "f168d8ad2ea243d75ab003d4b3b84ee92874a350252bf308981758498c140267"
  }
}