{
  "site": "gobekli-tepe",
  "title": "Building D · sample-to-building ledger",
  "updated": "2026-10-28",
  "publicationStatus": "draft",
  "scope": "Published measurements, field relationships and changing interpretations for Building D at Göbekli Tepe. A documented inventory of identified records, with explicit gaps in the later sample archive.",
  "samples": [
    {
      "lab": "KIA-44149",
      "ageBP": 9984,
      "errorBP": 42,
      "unit": "conventional radiocarbon BP",
      "errorConvention": "Published ± error; not a calibrated interval",
      "delta13C": "−26.31 ± 0.57‰",
      "material": "Charcoal / organic remains in loam wall plaster",
      "method": "AMS radiocarbon, Kiel (S130)",
      "grid": "L9-68",
      "locus": "782.3",
      "legacyLayer": "III; Building D",
      "relationship": "Inner ring wall between Pillars 41 and 42; sampled 29 October 2010. Not bedrock or a pillar date.",
      "event": "Wall application / repair",
      "phaseAssignment": "Unresolved: no verified link to a numbered architectural phase",
      "quality": "context-sensitive",
      "limit": "Dates the carbon, not necessarily plaster application. Original report treated it as construction evidence; 2022 architecture associates this plaster with a late repair. Exact phase and inherited-carbon contribution remain unresolved.",
      "calibration": {
        "status": "published",
        "unit": "cal BCE",
        "probability": 95.4,
        "curve": "IntCal09 (Reimer et al. 2009)",
        "software": "OxCal 4.1.7",
        "segments": [
          {
            "older": 9745,
            "younger": 9727,
            "probability": 1.5
          },
          {
            "older": 9675,
            "younger": 9314,
            "probability": 93.9
          }
        ],
        "note": "Published unmodelled segments; no recalibration. Gaps are preserved; endpoints are not activity boundaries."
      },
      "sourceIds": [
        "S125",
        "S130",
        "S128",
        "S131"
      ],
      "locator": "S125, Table 1 p.37; Fig.3 p.40",
      "variants": [
        {
          "sourceIds": [
            "S130"
          ],
          "kind": "calibration-reporting",
          "text": "Body/caption emphasize 9675–9314 cal BCE (93.9%); Fig.1 also includes 9745–9727 (1.5%), totaling 95.4%. These are parts of one determination, not competing assays."
        }
      ],
      "register2026": {
        "cells": "B196:F196",
        "retainedInFigure2": true,
        "sourceIds": [
          "S131"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "lab": "UGAMS-10795",
      "ageBP": 9970,
      "errorBP": 30,
      "unit": "conventional radiocarbon BP",
      "errorConvention": "Published ± error; not a calibrated interval",
      "delta13C": "−24.8‰",
      "material": "Charcoal: Pistacia atlantica, Prunus amygdalus and undetermined",
      "method": "Radiocarbon; laboratory protocol not verified",
      "grid": "L9-78",
      "locus": "129.12",
      "legacyLayer": "III; adjacent to Building D",
      "relationship": "Deep foundation test pit near bedrock, in space adjacent to ring walls. Not demonstrated to seal or underlie D’s floor.",
      "event": "Adjacent deposit",
      "phaseAssignment": "Unresolved: no verified link to a numbered architectural phase",
      "quality": "context-sensitive",
      "limit": "The 2013 authors require further stratigraphic correlation. Similar ages do not establish contemporaneity with a particular wall or three independent construction events.",
      "calibration": {
        "status": "published",
        "unit": "cal BCE",
        "probability": 95.4,
        "curve": "IntCal09 (Reimer et al. 2009)",
        "software": "OxCal 4.1.7",
        "segments": [
          {
            "older": 9656,
            "younger": 9577,
            "probability": 16.6
          },
          {
            "older": 9551,
            "younger": 9317,
            "probability": 78.8
          }
        ],
        "note": "Published unmodelled segments; no recalibration. Gaps are preserved; endpoints are not activity boundaries."
      },
      "sourceIds": [
        "S125",
        "S131"
      ],
      "locator": "S125, Table 1 p.37; Fig.3 p.40",
      "variants": [],
      "register2026": {
        "cells": "B194:F194",
        "retainedInFigure2": true,
        "sourceIds": [
          "S131"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "lab": "UGAMS-10796",
      "ageBP": 9990,
      "errorBP": 30,
      "unit": "conventional radiocarbon BP",
      "errorConvention": "Published ± error; not a calibrated interval",
      "delta13C": "−25.6‰",
      "material": "Charcoal: Pistacia atlantica, Prunus amygdalus and undetermined",
      "method": "Radiocarbon; laboratory protocol not verified",
      "grid": "L9-78",
      "locus": "129.11",
      "legacyLayer": "III; adjacent to Building D",
      "relationship": "Deep foundation test pit near bedrock, in space adjacent to ring walls. Not demonstrated to seal or underlie D’s floor.",
      "event": "Adjacent deposit",
      "phaseAssignment": "Unresolved: no verified link to a numbered architectural phase",
      "quality": "context-sensitive",
      "limit": "The 2013 authors require further stratigraphic correlation. Similar ages do not establish contemporaneity with a particular wall or three independent construction events.",
      "calibration": {
        "status": "published",
        "unit": "cal BCE",
        "probability": 95.4,
        "curve": "IntCal09 (Reimer et al. 2009)",
        "software": "OxCal 4.1.7",
        "segments": [
          {
            "older": 9664,
            "younger": 9334,
            "probability": 95.4
          }
        ],
        "note": "Published unmodelled segments; no recalibration. Gaps are preserved; endpoints are not activity boundaries."
      },
      "sourceIds": [
        "S125",
        "S131"
      ],
      "locator": "S125, Table 1 p.37; Fig.3 p.40",
      "variants": [],
      "register2026": {
        "cells": "B197:F197",
        "retainedInFigure2": true,
        "sourceIds": [
          "S131"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "lab": "UGAMS-10799",
      "ageBP": 9960,
      "errorBP": 30,
      "unit": "conventional radiocarbon BP",
      "errorConvention": "Published ± error; not a calibrated interval",
      "delta13C": "−25.7‰",
      "material": "Charcoal: Pistacia atlantica, Prunus amygdalus, Prunus, Rhamnus sp. and undetermined; mainly branch fragments",
      "method": "Radiocarbon; laboratory protocol not verified",
      "grid": "L9-78",
      "locus": "129.10",
      "legacyLayer": "III; adjacent to Building D",
      "relationship": "Deep foundation test pit near bedrock, in space adjacent to ring walls. Not demonstrated to seal or underlie D’s floor.",
      "event": "Adjacent deposit",
      "phaseAssignment": "Unresolved: no verified link to a numbered architectural phase",
      "quality": "context-sensitive",
      "limit": "The 2013 authors require further stratigraphic correlation. Similar ages do not establish contemporaneity with a particular wall or three independent construction events.",
      "calibration": {
        "status": "published",
        "unit": "cal BCE",
        "probability": 95.4,
        "curve": "IntCal09 (Reimer et al. 2009)",
        "software": "OxCal 4.1.7",
        "segments": [
          {
            "older": 9654,
            "younger": 9593,
            "probability": 10.5
          },
          {
            "older": 9587,
            "younger": 9581,
            "probability": 0.6
          },
          {
            "older": 9546,
            "younger": 9480,
            "probability": 9.4
          },
          {
            "older": 9464,
            "younger": 9311,
            "probability": 74.9
          }
        ],
        "note": "Published unmodelled segments; no recalibration. Gaps are preserved; endpoints are not activity boundaries."
      },
      "sourceIds": [
        "S125",
        "S131"
      ],
      "locator": "S125, Table 1 p.37; Fig.3 p.40",
      "variants": [],
      "register2026": {
        "cells": "B191:F191",
        "retainedInFigure2": true,
        "sourceIds": [
          "S131"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "lab": "KIA-44701",
      "ageBP": 9800,
      "errorBP": 120,
      "unit": "conventional radiocarbon BP",
      "errorConvention": "Published ± error; not a calibrated interval",
      "delta13C": "−20.57 ± 0.13‰",
      "material": "Collagen from a cattle tooth",
      "method": "Radiocarbon; laboratory protocol not verified",
      "grid": "L9-67",
      "locus": "65.2",
      "legacyLayer": "III; Building D",
      "relationship": "North of Pillar 33 (2013 Table 1); assigned to deepest fill, Fig.5 unit 1 above floor, in 2019. Section drawing is L9-78; retain the sample’s separately reported grid.",
      "event": "Basal fill",
      "phaseAssignment": "Unresolved: no verified link to a numbered architectural phase",
      "quality": "context-sensitive",
      "limit": "Animal carbon can predate redeposition. Being in the lowest fill does not make the tooth a primary floor-use deposit or directly date abandonment.",
      "calibration": {
        "status": "published",
        "unit": "cal BCE",
        "probability": 95.4,
        "curve": "IntCal09 (Reimer et al. 2009)",
        "software": "OxCal 4.1.7",
        "segments": [
          {
            "older": 9746,
            "younger": 9726,
            "probability": 0.7
          },
          {
            "older": 9676,
            "younger": 8818,
            "probability": 94.7
          }
        ],
        "note": "Published unmodelled segments; no recalibration. Gaps are preserved; endpoints are not activity boundaries."
      },
      "sourceIds": [
        "S125",
        "S121",
        "S131"
      ],
      "locator": "S125, Table 1 p.37; Fig.3 p.40",
      "variants": [],
      "register2026": {
        "cells": "B175:F175",
        "retainedInFigure2": false,
        "sourceIds": [
          "S131"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "lab": "UGAMS-10798",
      "ageBP": 9540,
      "errorBP": 30,
      "unit": "conventional radiocarbon BP",
      "errorConvention": "Published ± error; not a calibrated interval",
      "delta13C": "−25.4‰",
      "material": "Charcoal: Pistacia atlantica, Populus/Salix and undetermined",
      "method": "Radiocarbon; laboratory protocol not verified",
      "grid": "L9-69",
      "locus": "123.3",
      "legacyLayer": "III; north of Building D",
      "relationship": "Table 1 specifies north of D; accompanying prose discusses the sample as fill. Exact interior-fill correlation has not been verified.",
      "event": "Northern deposit / fill association uncertain",
      "phaseAssignment": "Unresolved: no verified link to a numbered architectural phase",
      "quality": "context-sensitive",
      "limit": "Do not silently relocate this sample inside D or assign it to the 2019 profile units. Material age is not the date of deposition.",
      "calibration": {
        "status": "published",
        "unit": "cal BCE",
        "probability": 95.4,
        "curve": "IntCal09 (Reimer et al. 2009)",
        "software": "OxCal 4.1.7",
        "segments": [
          {
            "older": 9127,
            "younger": 8995,
            "probability": 48.8
          },
          {
            "older": 8927,
            "younger": 8763,
            "probability": 46.6
          }
        ],
        "note": "Published unmodelled segments; no recalibration. Gaps are preserved; endpoints are not activity boundaries."
      },
      "sourceIds": [
        "S125",
        "S131"
      ],
      "locator": "S125, Table 1 p.37; Fig.3 p.40",
      "variants": [
        {
          "sourceIds": [
            "S125",
            "S122"
          ],
          "kind": "context",
          "text": "The 2013 table’s north-of-D location is more specific than the fill narrative repeated in 2016. Preserve both descriptions pending a locus/section link."
        }
      ],
      "register2026": {
        "cells": "B144:F144",
        "retainedInFigure2": true,
        "sourceIds": [
          "S131"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "lab": "IGAS-2658",
      "ageBP": 8880,
      "errorBP": 60,
      "unit": "conventional radiocarbon BP",
      "errorConvention": "Published ± error; not a calibrated interval",
      "delta13C": null,
      "material": "Humic acid from soil",
      "method": "Radiocarbon; laboratory protocol not verified",
      "grid": "L9-68",
      "locus": null,
      "legacyLayer": "II / soil over Building D fill",
      "relationship": "Overlying humus formation, not mortar, a hearth or a primary floor deposit. Exact field locus not reported in the transcribed table.",
      "event": "Overlying soil formation",
      "phaseAssignment": "Unresolved: no verified link to a numbered architectural phase",
      "quality": "context-sensitive",
      "limit": "Soil carbon formation/mobility limits a precise abandonment endpoint. The 2019 soil determination is unnamed and cannot be conclusively equated with this lab ID.",
      "calibration": {
        "status": "published",
        "unit": "cal BCE",
        "probability": 95.4,
        "curve": "IntCal09 (Reimer et al. 2009)",
        "software": "OxCal 4.1.7",
        "segments": [
          {
            "older": 8241,
            "younger": 7813,
            "probability": 94.6
          },
          {
            "older": 7805,
            "younger": 7795,
            "probability": 0.8
          }
        ],
        "note": "Published unmodelled segments; no recalibration. Gaps are preserved; endpoints are not activity boundaries."
      },
      "sourceIds": [
        "S125",
        "S126",
        "S121",
        "S131"
      ],
      "locator": "S125, Table 1 p.37; Fig.3 p.40",
      "variants": [
        {
          "sourceIds": [
            "S121"
          ],
          "kind": "unresolved-possible-match",
          "ageBP": 8860,
          "errorBP": 60,
          "reportedCalBCE": {
            "older": 8240,
            "younger": 7780,
            "probability": 95.4
          },
          "text": "2019 reports 8860 ± 60 BP and 8240–7780 cal BCE for soil over D, without a lab ID. Possible match to IGAS-2658, not an established correction or a confirmed second assay. Retain the 2013/registry 8880 ± 60 value."
        }
      ],
      "register2026": {
        "cells": "B97:F97",
        "retainedInFigure2": false,
        "sourceIds": [
          "S131"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "lab": "KIA-38008",
      "ageBP": 8930,
      "errorBP": 45,
      "unit": "conventional radiocarbon BP",
      "errorConvention": "Published ± error; not a calibrated interval",
      "delta13C": "−13.85 ± 0.21‰",
      "material": "Bone apatite",
      "method": "Radiocarbon; laboratory protocol not verified",
      "grid": "L9-68",
      "locus": "25.4",
      "legacyLayer": "III; Enclosure D",
      "relationship": "Registry associates bone with D; individual wall/floor relationship and profile-unit crosswalk not supplied.",
      "event": "D context; event unresolved",
      "phaseAssignment": "Unresolved: no verified link to a numbered architectural phase",
      "quality": "quarantined",
      "limit": "Retained for audit, excluded from phase dating: bone apatite can exchange carbon after burial. These apparent ages are not evidence for successive building phases.",
      "calibration": {
        "status": "not-transcribed",
        "unit": "cal BCE",
        "probability": null,
        "curve": null,
        "software": null,
        "segments": [],
        "note": "Original calibrated output and settings not verified. No calendar range inferred from conventional BP."
      },
      "sourceIds": [
        "S126",
        "S130",
        "S131"
      ],
      "locator": "S126, legacy date table; cites Dietrich (2011)",
      "variants": [],
      "register2026": {
        "cells": "B99:F99",
        "retainedInFigure2": false,
        "sourceIds": [
          "S131"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "lab": "KIA-42210",
      "ageBP": 8370,
      "errorBP": 35,
      "unit": "conventional radiocarbon BP",
      "errorConvention": "Published ± error; not a calibrated interval",
      "delta13C": "−13.86 ± 0.23‰",
      "material": "Bone apatite",
      "method": "Radiocarbon; laboratory protocol not verified",
      "grid": "L9-68",
      "locus": "18.2",
      "legacyLayer": "III; Enclosure D",
      "relationship": "Registry associates bone with D; individual wall/floor relationship and profile-unit crosswalk not supplied.",
      "event": "D context; event unresolved",
      "phaseAssignment": "Unresolved: no verified link to a numbered architectural phase",
      "quality": "quarantined",
      "limit": "Retained for audit, excluded from phase dating: bone apatite can exchange carbon after burial. These apparent ages are not evidence for successive building phases.",
      "calibration": {
        "status": "not-transcribed",
        "unit": "cal BCE",
        "probability": null,
        "curve": null,
        "software": null,
        "segments": [],
        "note": "Original calibrated output and settings not verified. No calendar range inferred from conventional BP."
      },
      "sourceIds": [
        "S126",
        "S130",
        "S131"
      ],
      "locator": "S126, legacy date table; cites Dietrich (2011)",
      "variants": [],
      "register2026": {
        "cells": "B84:F84",
        "retainedInFigure2": false,
        "sourceIds": [
          "S131"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "lab": "KIA-42216",
      "ageBP": 7735,
      "errorBP": 40,
      "unit": "conventional radiocarbon BP",
      "errorConvention": "Published ± error; not a calibrated interval",
      "delta13C": "−9.35 ± 0.26‰",
      "material": "Bone apatite",
      "method": "Radiocarbon; laboratory protocol not verified",
      "grid": "L9-68",
      "locus": "19.2",
      "legacyLayer": "III; Enclosure D",
      "relationship": "Registry associates bone with D; individual wall/floor relationship and profile-unit crosswalk not supplied.",
      "event": "D context; event unresolved",
      "phaseAssignment": "Unresolved: no verified link to a numbered architectural phase",
      "quality": "quarantined",
      "limit": "Retained for audit, excluded from phase dating: bone apatite can exchange carbon after burial. These apparent ages are not evidence for successive building phases.",
      "calibration": {
        "status": "not-transcribed",
        "unit": "cal BCE",
        "probability": null,
        "curve": null,
        "software": null,
        "segments": [],
        "note": "Original calibrated output and settings not verified. No calendar range inferred from conventional BP."
      },
      "sourceIds": [
        "S126",
        "S130",
        "S131"
      ],
      "locator": "S126, legacy date table; cites Dietrich (2011)",
      "variants": [],
      "register2026": {
        "cells": "B76:F76",
        "retainedInFigure2": false,
        "sourceIds": [
          "S131"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "lab": "KIA-42218",
      "ageBP": 8950,
      "errorBP": 65,
      "unit": "conventional radiocarbon BP",
      "errorConvention": "Published ± error; not a calibrated interval",
      "delta13C": "−12.34 ± 0.16‰",
      "material": "Bone apatite",
      "method": "Radiocarbon; laboratory protocol not verified",
      "grid": "L9-68",
      "locus": "25.2",
      "legacyLayer": "III; Enclosure D",
      "relationship": "Registry associates bone with D; individual wall/floor relationship and profile-unit crosswalk not supplied.",
      "event": "D context; event unresolved",
      "phaseAssignment": "Unresolved: no verified link to a numbered architectural phase",
      "quality": "quarantined",
      "limit": "Retained for audit, excluded from phase dating: bone apatite can exchange carbon after burial. These apparent ages are not evidence for successive building phases.",
      "calibration": {
        "status": "not-transcribed",
        "unit": "cal BCE",
        "probability": null,
        "curve": null,
        "software": null,
        "segments": [],
        "note": "Original calibrated output and settings not verified. No calendar range inferred from conventional BP."
      },
      "sourceIds": [
        "S126",
        "S130",
        "S131"
      ],
      "locator": "S126, legacy date table; cites Dietrich (2011)",
      "variants": [],
      "register2026": {
        "cells": "B100:F100",
        "retainedInFigure2": false,
        "sourceIds": [
          "S131"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "lab": "KIA-42219",
      "ageBP": 9120,
      "errorBP": 50,
      "unit": "conventional radiocarbon BP",
      "errorConvention": "Published ± error; not a calibrated interval",
      "delta13C": "−8.53 ± 0.24‰",
      "material": "Bone apatite",
      "method": "Radiocarbon; laboratory protocol not verified",
      "grid": "L9-68",
      "locus": "21.7",
      "legacyLayer": "III; Enclosure D",
      "relationship": "Registry associates bone with D; individual wall/floor relationship and profile-unit crosswalk not supplied.",
      "event": "D context; event unresolved",
      "phaseAssignment": "Unresolved: no verified link to a numbered architectural phase",
      "quality": "quarantined",
      "limit": "Retained for audit, excluded from phase dating: bone apatite can exchange carbon after burial. These apparent ages are not evidence for successive building phases.",
      "calibration": {
        "status": "not-transcribed",
        "unit": "cal BCE",
        "probability": null,
        "curve": null,
        "software": null,
        "segments": [],
        "note": "Original calibrated output and settings not verified. No calendar range inferred from conventional BP."
      },
      "sourceIds": [
        "S126",
        "S130",
        "S131"
      ],
      "locator": "S126, legacy date table; cites Dietrich (2011)",
      "variants": [],
      "register2026": {
        "cells": "B106:F106",
        "retainedInFigure2": false,
        "sourceIds": [
          "S131"
        ]
      }
    },
    {
      "lab": "KIA-28965",
      "ageBP": 8485,
      "errorBP": 40,
      "unit": "conventional radiocarbon BP",
      "errorConvention": "Published ± error; not a calibrated interval",
      "delta13C": "−13.18 ± 0.19‰",
      "material": "Pedogenic carbonate",
      "method": "Radiocarbon; laboratory protocol not verified",
      "grid": "L9-78",
      "locus": null,
      "legacyLayer": "III; Enclosure D",
      "relationship": "Carbonate growth associated with buried architecture; registry does not identify a specific sampled stone or wall face.",
      "event": "Post-burial carbonate formation",
      "phaseAssignment": "Unresolved: no verified link to a numbered architectural phase",
      "quality": "indirect",
      "limit": "Carbonate formation follows burial under the authors’ model. It does not date stone cutting, construction or a particular infill pulse; no calendar bound is adopted without the original output.",
      "calibration": {
        "status": "not-transcribed",
        "unit": "cal BCE",
        "probability": null,
        "curve": null,
        "software": null,
        "segments": [],
        "note": "Original calibrated output and settings not verified. No calendar range inferred from conventional BP."
      },
      "sourceIds": [
        "S126",
        "S130",
        "S131"
      ],
      "locator": "S126, legacy date table; cites Dietrich (2011)",
      "variants": [],
      "register2026": {
        "cells": "B89:F89",
        "retainedInFigure2": false,
        "sourceIds": [
          "S131"
        ]
      }
    }
  ],
  "phases": [
    {
      "id": "D-INITIAL",
      "title": "Original construction",
      "evidence": "Architectural sequence precedes later enclosing walls. Earliest presence of T-pillars is unresolved.",
      "date": "No laboratory determination securely assigned here to initial construction.",
      "laboratoryIds": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "S128"
      ],
      "limit": "Do not substitute the wall-plaster carbon age for the first building phase."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-REBUILD",
      "title": "Major rebuilding",
      "evidence": "New enclosing walls and incorporated T-pillars, followed by further inner-wall and bench modifications.",
      "date": "2022 architectural account: late 10th / early 9th millennium cal BCE; a later modification around the middle 9th millennium.",
      "laboratoryIds": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "S128"
      ],
      "limit": "Approximate published phase estimates cite a study then in preparation. Laboratory IDs and calibration inputs have not been recovered; these are not new ledger determinations."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-PLASTER",
      "title": "Plaster application / repair",
      "evidence": "Charcoal-bearing wall plaster connects one dated material to a wall; association with first construction versus a later repair has changed.",
      "date": "KIA-44149: carbon ranges in the sample record below. Application itself is not independently dated.",
      "laboratoryIds": [
        "KIA-44149"
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "S130",
        "S128"
      ],
      "limit": "2022 places the plaster shortly before a major slope-slide episode. This late architectural attribution cannot be reconciled merely by averaging the dates."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-USE",
      "title": "Use during partial infilling",
      "evidence": "2024 report describes hardened horizontal walking surfaces within rubble fill, as well as displaced roof material and structural damage.",
      "date": "No directly associated laboratory ID established in the examined report.",
      "laboratoryIds": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "S127"
      ],
      "limit": "These observations support interruptions between inundations; they do not date each walking surface or prove continuous ritual use."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-FILL",
      "title": "Filling: intentional deposition and slope movement",
      "evidence": "2019 profile: basal unit 1, lower units 3–8 interpreted as probably intentional fill, then sloping units 9–19. Later reports favor a more complex sequence.",
      "date": "KIA-44701 dates tooth carbon in basal fill; UGAMS-10798 has an unresolved north-of-D / fill association.",
      "laboratoryIds": [
        "KIA-44701",
        "UGAMS-10798"
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "S121",
        "S125",
        "S127",
        "S128"
      ],
      "limit": "Deliberate disposal remains possible, but the entire fill cannot be assigned to a single ritual burial. Older objects can occur in younger deposits."
    },
    {
      "id": "D-LATER",
      "title": "Later slope deposits and soil formation",
      "evidence": "2019 units 9–13 reach surviving wall tops; 14–19 cover them. Soil and carbonate formation provide different, later relationships.",
      "date": "IGAS-2658 and KIA-28965 concern soil/carbonate processes. A 2022 sediment-block estimate is typological, not a radiocarbon assay.",
      "laboratoryIds": [
        "IGAS-2658",
        "KIA-28965"
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "S121",
        "S126",
        "S128"
      ],
      "limit": "The L09-68 square-metre 91 block is attributed to early/middle 8th millennium cal BCE from chipped-stone comparisons. It does not establish that all of D remained in use that late."
    }
  ],
  "reviews": [
    {
      "id": "GT-R01",
      "title": "2010–2016: a short construction-to-burial story",
      "text": "The 2010 wall report, 2013 radiocarbon synthesis and 2016 summary connected early wall carbon with building age and later charcoal with filling. Preserve those measurements while revisiting their event assignments.",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S130",
        "S125",
        "S122"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "GT-R02",
      "title": "2019: material can be older than its deposit",
      "text": "The tooth and mortar ages were read as evidence that older material entered repairs and fill. The section already distinguished lower probable backfill from later sloping deposits. A matching age alone is not a matching depositional event.",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S121"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "GT-R03",
      "title": "2022: architectural phases and mixed sediment",
      "text": "Multiple rebuilding stages and a late plaster attribution complicate the early construction reading. A separate sediment block has an early/middle 8th-millennium typological estimate; it must not be merged with conventional radiocarbon ages.",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S128"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "GT-R04",
      "title": "2024: further excavation revises the fill interpretation",
      "text": "Damage, voids, roof remnants and walking surfaces in rubble support repeated slope inundation. Objects could have stood in place or moved with debris; their presence is not sufficient evidence of deliberate ritual deposition. Causes and exact event dates remain open.",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S127"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "GT-R05",
      "title": "Seismic proposals need their own sample links",
      "text": "Kinzel’s 2024 Table 1, now examined through publisher-indexed text, is a structural-damage inventory, not a radiocarbon register. The dating section mentions repair clusters without assay IDs in the examined passage. No earthquake date or new sample-to-phase join follows.",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S129"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "GT-R06",
      "title": "Two unresolved reporting issues",
      "text": "The wall plot has a small additional calibration segment omitted from its 2010 caption. Soil above D is reported as 8880 ± 60 BP in the legacy table but 8860 ± 60 BP without a lab ID in 2019. Both source versions remain visible; neither is silently corrected.",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S130",
        "S125",
        "S121"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "GT-R07",
      "title": "2026: a larger list, not a phase model",
      "text": "A site-wide register is now available, with source-specific exclusions retained. It repeats the 13 legacy D-related measurements but supplies no new verified sample-to-phase join. The next missing evidence is the link from laboratory ID to locus, stratigraphic unit and architectural phase.",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S131"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "coverage": [
    {
      "title": "Included",
      "text": "13 distinct laboratory IDs explicitly attached to Building D, adjacent deposits, or overlying soil in the checked 2013 table and PPND registry. Repeated publication is not a new sample.",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S125",
        "S126"
      ]
    },
    {
      "title": "Calibrations",
      "text": "Seven published calibration plots transcribed with disjoint intervals and their probabilities. Six legacy apatite/carbonate outputs remain unverified; no modern calibration is silently substituted. No Bayesian model was fitted.",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S125",
        "S126",
        "S130"
      ]
    },
    {
      "title": "Excluded from the D ledger",
      "text": "Building A/C assays and same-grid records lacking explicit D attribution are excluded. Examples: KIA-42207 (Layer II, L9-68/28.1) and KIA-42217 (Layer I, L9-68/10.1). A shared square does not establish a D phase.",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S125",
        "S126"
      ]
    },
    {
      "title": "Later register recovered; field key still absent",
      "text": "Clare 2026 Table S1 supplies 141 site-wide determinations. All 13 existing D/adjacent/overlying IDs match in age and error. The workbook has no locus or phase columns. No new D phase assignment follows; laboratory certificates and field notebooks remain unavailable.",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S131",
        "S125",
        "S126"
      ]
    },
    {
      "title": "Original tables still needed",
      "text": "The 2011 ZORA original tables and full Built on Rock chapter remain inaccessible. The 2024 seismic Table 1 is now identified as a damage inventory. Schönicke’s 2025 thesis is a specific remaining access gap for five Poz IDs cited in the 2026 register; its abstract cannot supply their field contexts.",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S126",
        "S129",
        "S134",
        "S136"
      ]
    },
    {
      "title": "Atlas / globe coverage checked",
      "text": "A separate marker plots the published wall-carbon uncertainty envelope, explicitly not a construction event. Existing broad monument/burial records remain. Unresolved building phases and unreliable apatite ages are recorded as unplotted instead of generating false activity dates.",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S125",
        "S126",
        "S128"
      ]
    },
    {
      "title": "Later publications checked against the register",
      "text": "Breuers 2022 Table 6 identifies ten dates from K10-13/23, not Building D. Kinzel & Clare 2020 Tables 3.1–3.2 identify fourteen Building B records. These context matches are kept separate; 104 register rows remain unlinked to field contexts in this audit.",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S131",
        "S132",
        "S133"
      ]
    },
    {
      "title": "Field-context key search recorded",
      "text": "Public-source follow-up recovered no additional lab-to-locus or numbered-phase joins. A geochemical context table for DR-2 and Room 16 supplies useful field leads but no radiocarbon-ID crosswalk. The register page records sources checked, access limits and the exact missing fields.",
      "sourceIds": [
        "S131",
        "S129",
        "S134",
        "S135",
        "S136"
      ]
    }
  ]
}
