PUBLIC RESEARCH PREVIEW Research in progress · uncertainties and source access are recorded throughout.

Göbekli Tepe · source and context audit

The register is here.
The phase key is missing.

141 published determinations. Thirteen match our Building D ledger; none establishes a new link to a numbered D phase.

A published compilation, not the excavation archive

Published site-wide compilation, not original laboratory certificates or a phase-keyed excavation archive. Context links are added only where an examined source identifies them. The source spreadsheet supplies laboratory IDs, conventional ages, materials, exclusions and references. Contexts below come from separately cited publications.

13Existing D-related matches
24Other context matches
104Contexts unresolved here
0New verified D phase links

01 · Which architectural sequence?

Compare events before assigning dates.

Kinzel & Clare 2020 · eight-phase southeast-area framework. A versioned area-wide architectural framework, not Building D’s local phase numbering. Links below compare event types; they do not assert numbered-phase equivalence or create dated events.

2020 phaseArchitectural readingSample connection
Phase 1First constructionInitial special buildings and adjacent round-oval structures.No radiocarbon date assigned by the 2020 account; no new D link recovered.
Phase 2RebuildingInner walls reduce building interiors; pillars incorporated into walls.Architectural assignment only; no identified D assay tied to this numbered phase.
Phases 3–5Modification, damage and repairSuccessive modifications; slope damage followed by Phase 5 repair/stabilisation.KIA-44149 remains a repair-context candidate, but no secure numbered-phase join is established.
Phase 6Inundation / abandonmentA further slope slide is proposed to end D’s use.No laboratory ID securely dates this event; later reports describe a more complex fill history.
Phase 7Later stabilisationTerrace wall traverses the northern parts of B and D.No recovered assay securely attached to this terrace-wall episode.
Phase 8Final occupationSmall structures among settlement ruins.Clare 2026 reports no absolute radiocarbon dates for the final settlement phase.

KIA-44149 dates carbon in plaster. Its association with a later repair does not by itself establish “Phase 5.” Matching ages, grid squares or phase numbers are insufficient to join records.

Field-context key · checked 2026-10-28

What the follow-up search established.

No additional laboratory-to-field-context or numbered Building D phase link recovered. This is a bounded public-source search, not proof that the excavation key does not exist.

Seventy rows labelled This study

No context key recovered. The workbook gives no sample numbers, loci, architectural phases or excavation years. Exact-ID searches in representative batches did not retrieve a field table. The status of the remaining rows cannot be established from search non-results.

Missing link: A sample register or appendix explicitly pairing these lab IDs with field sample numbers and loci.

Kinzel 2024 · Table 1 and §7

Table type resolved. Table 1 inventories damage to buildings; it is not a laboratory register. Section 7 discusses an eastern-D repair-date cluster without identifying its assays in the examined passage.

Missing link: The lab IDs and wall contexts underlying that repair cluster; do not reverse-match calibrated ages.

Schönicke 2025 · five cited determinations

Thesis identified; full text inaccessible. The 2026 register attributes Poz-130450, Poz-130451, Poz-131050, Poz-131108 and Poz-131109 to this thesis. Its official repository lists a 207.7 MB PDF, but the text could not be retrieved. No field contexts are assigned from the abstract.

Missing link: Read the thesis radiocarbon tables and appendices, then verify each of these five IDs against a locus and architectural relationship.

Uzdurum et al. 2023 · Table 1 / §7

Context information, no lab-ID join. The table describes geochemical sampling in DR-2 and Room 16/L9-80. Floor locus L9-80-122 and pit-fill loci 130, 132 and 134 occur in the associated Room 16 text. None is explicitly paired there with a radiocarbon laboratory ID.

Missing link: Use these as field-context leads only; do not attach the five thesis-referenced Poz samples or transfer Room 16 dates to D.

Pöllath study · two title variants

Final publication not located. Breuers 2022 and Built on Rock cite Dissecting a Layer Cake as in preparation; Kinzel 2024 cites Layer by layer in press. A final identifiable text, DOI or supplement was not located. The title relationship is a bibliographic lead, not proof of identical contents.

Missing link: A final publication or accessible manuscript containing the D sediment-section and chronology tables.

KIA-44149 · locus 782.3

Location confirmed; numbered phase unresolved. The existing publications locate the charcoal-bearing plaster in L9-68, between Pillars 41 and 42. No recovered field record connects locus 782.3 securely to a numbered revised construction or repair phase.

Missing link: A locus sheet or architectural concordance tying 782.3 to a specific wall face, plaster application and versioned phase.

Search scope and the fields needed to complete a link

Exact laboratory-ID searches, a UGAMS-210 family search, both Pöllath title variants, official publisher/repository records, and indexed primary-source passages. Two search engines used. The 70 This study rows were not individually assigned from age similarity or numbering proximity.

Exact IDs searched: UGAMS-21055, UGAMS-21048, UGAMS-17901, UGAMS-21051, UGAMS-17888, Poz-72859, Poz-63914, Beta-340437, Poz-131109, Poz-130450, Poz-131050, Poz-131108. Search non-results do not establish that a record is absent from an unindexed document.

  • Laboratory ID
  • Field sample / find number
  • Trench, square and locus / stratigraphic unit
  • Material and sampled fraction
  • Position relative to wall, floor, repair or fill
  • Architectural phase and scheme version
  • Drawing, section or locus-sheet reference

No author, laboratory or excavation-team contact made. Earlier outreach remains deferred.

02 · Published data, explicit context links

Find a determination.

All ages below are conventional radiocarbon BP, before 1950—not calibrated calendar dates. “Retained” and “excluded” refer to Clare’s regional Figure 2: 89 retained, 52 excluded. They are separate from our assessment of a sample’s archaeological relationship.

141 of 141 determinations

Laboratory / source rowAge ± error BPMaterial / source filterRecovered field relationship
KIA-26273Tabelle1 · B59:F59Source reference: [163]3,735 ± 30pedogenic carbonateExcluded: too young; pedogenic carbonate dates unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-23388Tabelle1 · B60:F60Source reference: [163]4,045 ± 35pedogenic carbonateExcluded: too young; pedogenic carbonate dates unreliableBuilding B · fill / carbonateBuilding B attribution; no Building D phase transfer.Table 3.2, p.39
KIA-26274Tabelle1 · B61:F61Source reference: [163]4,640 ± 30pedogenic carbonateExcluded: too young; pedogenic carbonate dates unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-23389Tabelle1 · B62:F62Source reference: [163]5,450 ± 35pedogenic carbonateExcluded: too young; pedogenic carbonate dates unreliableBuilding B · fill / carbonateBuilding B attribution; no Building D phase transfer.Table 3.2, p.39
UGAMS-17909cTabelle1 · B63:F63Source reference: This study5,660 ± 30animal tooth (collagen)Excluded: too young; bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-42209Tabelle1 · B64:F64Source reference: [120]5,775 ± 25bone apatiteExcluded: too young; bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Ua-21416Tabelle1 · B65:F65Source reference: [164]6,405 ± 70pedogenic carbonateExcluded: too young; pedogenic carbonate dates unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-38007BTabelle1 · B66:F66Source reference: [120]6,475 ± 37animal bone (apatite)Excluded: too young; bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableBuilding B · fill / carbonateBuilding B attribution; no Building D phase transfer.Table 3.2, p.39
KIA-28407BTabelle1 · B67:F67Source reference: [120]6,515 ± 45humic acidsExcluded: too young; humic acids unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-38006Tabelle1 · B68:F68Source reference: [120]6,620 ± 32animal bone (apatite)Excluded: too young; bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-42206Tabelle1 · B69:F69Source reference: [120]6,745 ± 30animal bone (apatite)Excluded: too young; bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Beta-340437Tabelle1 · B70:F70Source reference: This study6,810 ± 30mortarExcluded: too youngField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-28033Tabelle1 · B71:F71Source reference: [163]7,180 ± 40pedogenic carbonateExcluded: too young; pedogenic carbonate dates unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Ua-21415Tabelle1 · B72:F72Source reference: [164]7,450 ± 85pedogenic carbonateExcluded: too young; pedogenic carbonate dates unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-29564Tabelle1 · B73:F73Source reference: [120]7,525 ± 45pedogenic carbonateExcluded: too young; pedogenic carbonate dates unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17910Tabelle1 · B74:F74Source reference: This study7,580 ± 25animal tooth (biopatite)Excluded: too young; bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-28406Tabelle1 · B75:F75Source reference: [120]7,600 ± 60pedogenic carbonateExcluded: too young; pedogenic carbonate dates unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-42216 ↗Tabelle1 · B76:F76Source reference: [120]7,735 ± 40animal bone (apatite)Excluded: too young; bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableExisting D / adjacent / overlying recordL9-68 · locus 19.2Registry associates bone with D; individual wall/floor relationship and profile-unit crosswalk not supplied.S126, legacy date table; cites Dietrich (2011)
KIA-42207Tabelle1 · B77:F77Source reference: [120]7,830 ± 35animal bone (apatite)Excluded: too young; bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17912Tabelle1 · B78:F78Source reference: This study7,860 ± 25animal tooth (biopatite)Excluded: too young; bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-42211Tabelle1 · B79:F79Source reference: [120]7,985 ± 45animal bone (apatite)Excluded: too young; bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17907Tabelle1 · B80:F80Source reference: This study8,020 ± 25animal tooth (biopatite)Excluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-42214Tabelle1 · B81:F81Source reference: [120]8,115 ± 60animal bone (apatite)Excluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17911Tabelle1 · B82:F82Source reference: This study8,160 ± 25animal tooth (biopatite)Excluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17908cTabelle1 · B83:F83Source reference: [14]8,250 ± 30animal tooth (collagen)Excluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableBuilding B · fill / carbonateBuilding B attribution; no Building D phase transfer.Table 3.2, p.39
KIA-42210 ↗Tabelle1 · B84:F84Source reference: [120]8,370 ± 35animal bone (apatite)Excluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableExisting D / adjacent / overlying recordL9-68 · locus 18.2Registry associates bone with D; individual wall/floor relationship and profile-unit crosswalk not supplied.S126, legacy date table; cites Dietrich (2011)
KIA-42208Tabelle1 · B85:F85Source reference: [120]8,380 ± 40animal bone (apatite)Excluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Ua-19561Tabelle1 · B86:F86Source reference: [164]8,430 ± 80pedogenic carbonateExcluded: pedogenic carbonate dates unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-26169Tabelle1 · B87:F87Source reference: [163]8,440 ± 40pedogenic carbonateExcluded: pedogenic carbonate dates unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-42204Tabelle1 · B88:F88Source reference: [120]8,475 ± 60animal bone (apatite)Excluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableBuilding B · fill / carbonateBuilding B attribution; no Building D phase transfer.Table 3.2, p.39
KIA-28965 ↗Tabelle1 · B89:F89Source reference: [120]8,485 ± 40pedogenic carbonateExcluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableExisting D / adjacent / overlying recordL9-78 · locus not reportedCarbonate growth associated with buried architecture; registry does not identify a specific sampled stone or wall face.S126, legacy date table; cites Dietrich (2011)
UGAMS-17905Tabelle1 · B90:F90Source reference: This study8,490 ± 25animal tooth (biopatite)Excluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17908Tabelle1 · B91:F91Source reference: [14]8,520 ± 25animal tooth (biopatite)Excluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableBuilding B · fill / carbonateBuilding B attribution; no Building D phase transfer.Table 3.2, p.39
UGAMS-17909Tabelle1 · B92:F92Source reference: This study8,610 ± 30animal tooth (biopatite)Excluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-26168Tabelle1 · B93:F93Source reference: [163]8,625 ± 45pedogenic carbonateExcluded: pedogenic carbonate dates unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-42212Tabelle1 · B94:F94Source reference: [120]8,665 ± 45animal bone (apatite)Excluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-42213Tabelle1 · B95:F95Source reference: [120]8,860 ± 80animal bone (apatite)Excluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-42217Tabelle1 · B96:F96Source reference: [120]8,860 ± 50animal bone (apatite)Excluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
IGAS-2658 ↗Tabelle1 · B97:F97Source reference: [165]8,880 ± 60humic acidsExcluded: humic acids unreliableExisting D / adjacent / overlying recordL9-68 · locus not reportedOverlying humus formation, not mortar, a hearth or a primary floor deposit. Exact field locus not reported in the transcribed table.S125, Table 1 p.37; Fig.3 p.40
KIA-25373Tabelle1 · B98:F98Source reference: [163]8,895 ± 55pedogenic carbonateExcluded: pedogenic carbonate dates unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-38008 ↗Tabelle1 · B99:F99Source reference: [120]8,930 ± 45animal bone (apatite)Excluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableExisting D / adjacent / overlying recordL9-68 · locus 25.4Registry associates bone with D; individual wall/floor relationship and profile-unit crosswalk not supplied.S126, legacy date table; cites Dietrich (2011)
KIA-42218 ↗Tabelle1 · B100:F100Source reference: [120]8,950 ± 65animal bone (apatite)Excluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableExisting D / adjacent / overlying recordL9-68 · locus 25.2Registry associates bone with D; individual wall/floor relationship and profile-unit crosswalk not supplied.S126, legacy date table; cites Dietrich (2011)
Ua-19562Tabelle1 · B101:F101Source reference: [164]8,960 ± 85pedogenic carbonateExcluded: pedogenic carbonate dates unreliableBuilding B · fill / carbonateBuilding B attribution; no Building D phase transfer.Table 3.2, p.39
KIA-42205Tabelle1 · B102:F102Source reference: [120]9,000 ± 65animal bone (apatite)Excluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableBuilding B · fill / carbonateBuilding B attribution; no Building D phase transfer.Table 3.2, p.39
KIA-26021Tabelle1 · B103:F103Source reference: [163]9,020 ± 30pedogenic carbonateExcluded: pedogenic carbonate dates unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17906Tabelle1 · B104:F104Source reference: This study9,050 ± 30tooth (biopatite)Excluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-38007ATabelle1 · B105:F105Source reference: [120]9,065 ± 35animal bone (collagen)Excluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableBuilding B · fill / carbonateBuilding B attribution; no Building D phase transfer.Table 3.2, p.39
KIA-42219 ↗Tabelle1 · B106:F106Source reference: [120]9,120 ± 50animal bone (apatite)Excluded: bone (apatite, collagen) and tooth unreliableExisting D / adjacent / overlying recordL9-68 · locus 21.7Registry associates bone with D; individual wall/floor relationship and profile-unit crosswalk not supplied.S126, legacy date table; cites Dietrich (2011)
UGAMS-21051Tabelle1 · B107:F107Source reference: This study9,130 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-21050Tabelle1 · B108:F108Source reference: This study9,140 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-131109Tabelle1 · B109:F109Source reference: [166]9,150 ± 50charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-21061Tabelle1 · B110:F110Source reference: This study9,170 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-21057Tabelle1 · B111:F111Source reference: This study9,190 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-42221Tabelle1 · B112:F112Source reference: [120]9,230 ± 130animal bone (apatite)Excluded: high standard deviation (> 99 ¹⁴C-years)Building B · fill / carbonateBuilding B attribution; no Building D phase transfer.Table 3.2, p.39
Poz-72864Tabelle1 · B113:F113Source reference: This study9,230 ± 50charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-72861Tabelle1 · B114:F114Source reference: This study9,240 ± 50charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-21053Tabelle1 · B115:F115Source reference: This study9,240 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-28407ATabelle1 · B116:F116Source reference: [120]9,250 ± 55charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-72860Tabelle1 · B117:F117Source reference: This study9,250 ± 60seed/charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-131108Tabelle1 · B118:F118Source reference: [166]9,250 ± 50charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-21058Tabelle1 · B119:F119Source reference: This study9,260 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-21060Tabelle1 · B120:F120Source reference: This study9,280 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-21056Tabelle1 · B121:F121Source reference: This study9,280 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-25467Tabelle1 · B122:F122Source reference: [120]9,290 ± 70pedogenic carbonateExcluded: pedogenic carbonate dates unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-72856Tabelle1 · B123:F123Source reference: [14]9,310 ± 50charcoalRetained in Figure 2Building B · fill / carbonateBuilding B attribution; no Building D phase transfer.Table 3.2, p.39
UGAMS-21055Tabelle1 · B124:F124Source reference: This study9,330 ± 30Not reported (source: ‒)Retained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-72866Tabelle1 · B125:F125Source reference: This study9,340 ± 60charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-72862Tabelle1 · B126:F126Source reference: This study9,340 ± 50seed/charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-21046Tabelle1 · B127:F127Source reference: [14]9,350 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Building B · fill / carbonateBuilding B attribution; no Building D phase transfer.Table 3.2, p.39
UGAMS-21052Tabelle1 · B128:F128Source reference: This study9,360 ± 30seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-63904Tabelle1 · B129:F129Source reference: This study9,360 ± 60seed/charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-21059Tabelle1 · B130:F130Source reference: This study9,370 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-72870Tabelle1 · B131:F131Source reference: This study9,400 ± 60charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-72863Tabelle1 · B132:F132Source reference: This study9,440 ± 50charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Hd-20025Tabelle1 · B133:F133Source reference: [120]9,452 ± 73charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-63905Tabelle1 · B134:F134Source reference: This study9,480 ± 40seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-21047Tabelle1 · B135:F135Source reference: [14]9,480 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Building B · wall mortarBuilding B attribution; no Building D phase transfer.Table 3.1, p.38
Poz-63906Tabelle1 · B136:F136Source reference: This study9,500 ± 40charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17895Tabelle1 · B137:F137Source reference: This study9,510 ± 30seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-72867Tabelle1 · B138:F138Source reference: This study9,510 ± 60charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-63911Tabelle1 · B139:F139Source reference: This study9,510 ± 40seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-21066Tabelle1 · B140:F140Source reference: [167]9,510 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2K10-13/23 deep soundingK10-13/23 · locus 2.18Sample above Locus 166; not a direct sample of Locus 166 or Building D.Table 6 and §3.1.3, p.44
Poz-63913Tabelle1 · B141:F141Source reference: This study9,530 ± 40seed/fruit/charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-21049Tabelle1 · B142:F142Source reference: This study9,530 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17902Tabelle1 · B143:F143Source reference: This study9,530 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-10798 ↗Tabelle1 · B144:F144Source reference: [126]9,540 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Existing D / adjacent / overlying recordL9-69 · locus 123.3Table 1 specifies north of D; accompanying prose discusses the sample as fill. Exact interior-fill correlation has not been verified.S125, Table 1 p.37; Fig.3 p.40
UGAMS-21054Tabelle1 · B145:F145Source reference: This study9,540 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-21063Tabelle1 · B146:F146Source reference: This study9,540 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-130451Tabelle1 · B147:F147Source reference: [166]9,540 ± 50charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17888Tabelle1 · B148:F148Source reference: This study9,550 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-130450Tabelle1 · B149:F149Source reference: [166]9,550 ± 50charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Hd-20036Tabelle1 · B150:F150Source reference: [120]9,559 ± 53charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-21048Tabelle1 · B151:F151Source reference: This study9,560 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-63914Tabelle1 · B152:F152Source reference: This study9,560 ± 40seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-63974Tabelle1 · B153:F153Source reference: This study9,560 ± 35seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-72872Tabelle1 · B154:F154Source reference: This study9,570 ± 60charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17889Tabelle1 · B155:F155Source reference: This study9,570 ± 30seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-63909Tabelle1 · B156:F156Source reference: This study9,580 ± 40charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-63898Tabelle1 · B157:F157Source reference: This study9,580 ± 60charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-131050Tabelle1 · B158:F158Source reference: [166]9,580 ± 50charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17894Tabelle1 · B159:F159Source reference: This study9,590 ± 30seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-63900Tabelle1 · B160:F160Source reference: [167]9,600 ± 40seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2K10-13/23 deep soundingK10-13/23 · locus 25.1Sample above Locus 166; not a direct sample of Locus 166 or Building D.Table 6 and §3.1.3, p.44
Poz-63912Tabelle1 · B161:F161Source reference: This study9,610 ± 40seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-72868Tabelle1 · B162:F162Source reference: This study9,630 ± 60seed/charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17898Tabelle1 · B163:F163Source reference: This study9,660 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17899Tabelle1 · B164:F164Source reference: This study9,660 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-72869Tabelle1 · B165:F165Source reference: This study9,680 ± 90charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-10797Tabelle1 · B166:F166Source reference: [126]9,700 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17891Tabelle1 · B167:F167Source reference: [167]9,720 ± 30seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2K10-13/23 deep soundingK10-13/23 · locus 19.2Sample above Locus 166; not a direct sample of Locus 166 or Building D.Table 6 and §3.1.3, p.44
Poz-63910Tabelle1 · B168:F168Source reference: This study9,730 ± 40seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-72857Tabelle1 · B169:F169Source reference: [14]9,730 ± 60charcoalRetained in Figure 2Building B · wall mortarBuilding B attribution; no Building D phase transfer.Table 3.1, p.38
UGAMS-21065Tabelle1 · B170:F170Source reference: [167]9,740 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2K10-13/23 deep soundingK10-13/23 · locus not reportedSample above Locus 166; not a direct sample of Locus 166 or Building D.Table 6 and §3.1.3, p.44
UGAMS-17896Tabelle1 · B171:F171Source reference: This study9,770 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-21064Tabelle1 · B172:F172Source reference: This study9,770 ± 30seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17903Tabelle1 · B173:F173Source reference: This study9,780 ± 30seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17904Tabelle1 · B174:F174Source reference: This study9,790 ± 30seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-44701 ↗Tabelle1 · B175:F175Source reference: [126]9,800 ± 120animal tooth (collagen)Excluded: high standard deviation (> 99 ¹⁴C-years)Existing D / adjacent / overlying recordL9-67 · locus 65.2North of Pillar 33 (2013 Table 1); assigned to deepest fill, Fig.5 unit 1 above floor, in 2019. Section drawing is L9-78; retain the sample’s separately reported grid.S125, Table 1 p.37; Fig.3 p.40
Poz-72859Tabelle1 · B176:F176Source reference: This study9,810 ± 60charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17900Tabelle1 · B177:F177Source reference: This study9,810 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-72873Tabelle1 · B178:F178Source reference: This study9,830 ± 60seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17892Tabelle1 · B179:F179Source reference: [167]9,840 ± 30seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2K10-13/23 deep soundingK10-13/23 · locus 24.1Sample above Locus 166; not a direct sample of Locus 166 or Building D.Table 6 and §3.1.3, p.44
Poz-63915Tabelle1 · B180:F180Source reference: This study9,850 ± 40seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-72876Tabelle1 · B181:F181Source reference: [167]9,870 ± 60charcoalRetained in Figure 2K10-13/23 deep soundingK10-13/23 · locus not reportedSample above Locus 166; not a direct sample of Locus 166 or Building D.Table 6 and §3.1.3, p.44
Poz-63902Tabelle1 · B182:F182Source reference: [167]9,870 ± 60seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2K10-13/23 deep soundingK10-13/23 · locus 36.1Sample above Locus 166; not a direct sample of Locus 166 or Building D.Table 6 and §3.1.3, p.44
Poz-72871Tabelle1 · B183:F183Source reference: This study9,900 ± 60charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-63908Tabelle1 · B184:F184Source reference: This study9,900 ± 40charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-72858Tabelle1 · B185:F185Source reference: This study9,910 ± 60charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17893Tabelle1 · B186:F186Source reference: [167]9,910 ± 30seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2K10-13/23 deep soundingK10-13/23 · locus 36.3Sample above Locus 166; not a direct sample of Locus 166 or Building D.Table 6 and §3.1.3, p.44
UGAMS-17897Tabelle1 · B187:F187Source reference: This study9,920 ± 30seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
Poz-63899Tabelle1 · B188:F188Source reference: This study9,920 ± 40charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-17890Tabelle1 · B189:F189Source reference: This study9,930 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-21062Tabelle1 · B190:F190Source reference: This study9,940 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
UGAMS-10799 ↗Tabelle1 · B191:F191Source reference: [126]9,960 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Existing D / adjacent / overlying recordL9-78 · locus 129.10Deep foundation test pit near bedrock, in space adjacent to ring walls. Not demonstrated to seal or underlie D’s floor.S125, Table 1 p.37; Fig.3 p.40
Poz-63901Tabelle1 · B192:F192Source reference: [167]9,960 ± 50seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2K10-13/23 deep soundingK10-13/23 · locus 30.1Sample above Locus 166; not a direct sample of Locus 166 or Building D.Table 6 and §3.1.3, p.44
Poz-72877Tabelle1 · B193:F193Source reference: [167]9,960 ± 60charcoalRetained in Figure 2K10-13/23 deep soundingK10-13/23 · locus 88.3Sample above Locus 166; not a direct sample of Locus 166 or Building D.Table 6 and §3.1.3, p.44
UGAMS-10795 ↗Tabelle1 · B194:F194Source reference: [126]9,970 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Existing D / adjacent / overlying recordL9-78 · locus 129.12Deep foundation test pit near bedrock, in space adjacent to ring walls. Not demonstrated to seal or underlie D’s floor.S125, Table 1 p.37; Fig.3 p.40
UGAMS-17901Tabelle1 · B195:F195Source reference: This study9,970 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-44149 ↗Tabelle1 · B196:F196Source reference: [117]9,984 ± 42wall plasterRetained in Figure 2Existing D / adjacent / overlying recordL9-68 · locus 782.3Inner ring wall between Pillars 41 and 42; sampled 29 October 2010. Not bedrock or a pillar date.S125, Table 1 p.37; Fig.3 p.40
UGAMS-10796 ↗Tabelle1 · B197:F197Source reference: [126]9,990 ± 30charcoalRetained in Figure 2Existing D / adjacent / overlying recordL9-78 · locus 129.11Deep foundation test pit near bedrock, in space adjacent to ring walls. Not demonstrated to seal or underlie D’s floor.S125, Table 1 p.37; Fig.3 p.40
Poz-72874Tabelle1 · B198:F198Source reference: This study9,990 ± 50seed/fruitRetained in Figure 2Field context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.
KIA-28405Tabelle1 · B199:F199Source reference: [163]10,210 ± 50pedogenic carbonateExcluded: pedogenic carbonate dates unreliableField context not established in this auditThe workbook has no field-location or phase columns.

03 · Preserve differences

What needs reconciliation?

Material and exclusion category disagree

The workbook lists pedogenic carbonate but gives a bone/tooth exclusion reason. Both cells are retained; the category mismatch is unresolved.

An incomplete reference trail

Seventy rows give only This study in the reference column. This identifies the present compilation but does not establish excavation year, field context or a match to the earlier announced sampling campaign.

Material not supplied

The material cell is a dash. Inclusion in Figure 2 does not supply the missing material or excavation context.

One object can yield two laboratory records

Table 3.2 identifies the UGAMS pair as fractions of one tooth, and the KIA pair as fractions of one bone. Four determinations do not mean four independent contexts.

A regional plotting filter is not a phase assignment

The workbook excludes this determination with a 120-year error from Figure 2. Its basal-fill relationship remains in the D ledger; the regional filter is kept separate from archaeological association.

04 · Audit boundary

What was recovered.

Clare 2026 · S131, Table S1. Workbook Clare_Supplementary_radiocarbon.xlsx, worksheet Tabelle1, cells B59:F199; retrieved 2026-10-28. The downloadable register preserves exact cell text and the workbook’s SHA-256 checksum.

Resolve the workbook’s reference labels

These numbers refer to the main article’s bibliography. The companion bibliography PDF uses different numbering.

This study
Clare 2026; no earlier item specified in this cell.
[117]
Dietrich, O.; Schmidt, K. A Radiocarbon Date from the Wall Plaster of Enclosure D of Göbekli Tepe. Neo-Lithics 2010, 2/10, 82–83.
[120]
Dietrich, O. Radiocarbon dating the first temples of Mankind. Comments of 14-C Dates from Göbekli Tepe. Z. Orient-Archäol. 2011, 4, 12–25.
[126]
Dietrich, O.; Köksal-Schmidt, Ç.; Notroff, J.; Schmidt, K. Establishing a radiocarbon sequence for Göbekli Tepe. State of research and new data. Neo-Lithics 2013, 1/13, 36–41.
[14]
Kinzel, M.; Clare, L. Monumental—Compared to what? A perspective from Göbekli Tepe. In Monumentalising Life in the Neolithic. Narratives of Change and Continuity; Gebauer, A.B., Sørensen, L., Teather, A., Valera, A.C., Eds.; Oxbow Books: Oxford, UK; Philadelphia, PA, USA, 2020; pp. 29–48.
[163]
Pustovoytov, K.; Schmidt, K.; Taubald, H. Evidence for Holocene environmental changes in the northern Fertile Crescent provided by pedogenic carbonate coatings. Quat. Res. 2007, 67, 315–327.
[164]
Pustovoytov, K. 14C Dating of Pedogenic Carbonate Coatings on Wall Stones at Göbekli Tepe (Southeastern Turkey). Neo-Lithics 2002, 2, 3–4.
[165]
Pustovoytov, K. Soils and Soil Sediments at Göbekli Tepe, Southeastern Turkey: A Preliminary Report. Geoarchaeol. Int. J. 2006, 21, 699–719.
[166]
Schönicke, J. All Places Are Temporary Places—Wiederverwendung, Auflassung und Ruineninteraktion im Neolithikum und Anthropozän am Beispiel der Siedlung Göbekli Tepe. Ph.D. Thesis, Freie Universität Berlin, Berlin, Germany, 2025.
[167]
Breuers, J. Diachrone Studien zur Lithik des Göbekli Tepe: Locus 166, Raum 16 und die Sedimentsäule aus Gebäude D. Ph.D. Thesis, Universität zu Köln, Cologne, Germany, 2022.

Context cross-checks: Breuers 2022, Table 6 and Kinzel & Clare 2020, Tables 3.1–3.2. The latter was available as a partial third-party reproduction; full-chapter access remains a gap. The ten sounding dates and fourteen B dates are not transferred to D.

Next evidence needed: a field-context key.

Connect laboratory IDs to sample numbers, loci, stratigraphic units and versioned architectural phases—especially locus 782.3 and the rows labelled “This study.” No excavation-team request has been sent.

Atlas/globe coverage checked: existing plotted ranges remain unchanged. No conventional BP age from this register has been used as a calendar date or a new building-use interval. View the existing wall-carbon marker ↗