PUBLIC RESEARCH PREVIEW Research in progress · uncertainties and source access are recorded throughout.

Giza · Evidence ledger · Working edition

Khufu's pyramid.
Follow the evidence.

A shipment, an inscription and a piece of charcoal answer different questions. Follow each from its recorded context to the claim it can support.

Published evidence, with the missing links visible.

Published-source audit; original specimens, field records and laboratory certificates not inspected. The ledger preserves the published measurements; it does not introduce a new chronology.

Attribution · Activity · Material age

What each line establishes.

KH-DOC-01 · Documentary activity

Merer's stone shipments

Tura-to-Akhet-Khufu cargo journeys, with overnight stops and return trips. Found at Wadi el-Jarf; describes work serving the Giza royal project.

Supports: Contemporary transport organization and a named destination.

Limit: Does not identify where each block was placed or describe every lifting operation.

S167 · Annex I, pp.149–151; Papyrus B I, days 26–28; B II, days 2–7

KH-DOC-02 · Editorial chronology and interpretation

Census year and finishing work

Tallet assigns the journals to the year after census 13 and interprets the shipments as probably involving casing work. Dating synthesis of the papyrus corpus; not an absolute laboratory date.

Supports: Late-reign activity under Khufu.

Limit: “Year 26” is the publication’s conversion. Original dating-fragment facsimile and its join to this corpus remain to audit; no exact BCE conversion adopted.

S167 · Annex I, conclusion, p.160

KH-INS-01 · Epigraphic attribution

Names on relieving-chamber blocks

Roth identifies crew names formed from Horus Medjedu, Khnum-Khufu and Khufu, distributed across the chamber walls. Her spatial analysis draws on Perring and Vyse's published copies; these are not Merer's papyri.

Supports: Royal attribution and a proposed division of construction work.

Limit: No absolute date from the pigment. Original plates and modern block-by-block photographs remain to compare; the reconstruction is not a fresh in-person inscription survey.

S171 · Roth 1991, pp.125–127, Fig.7.2 and notes 26–29

KH-RC-01 · Laboratory determinations

Organic material from the pyramid

46 results: 45 charcoal measurements and one reed measurement. Course/location descriptions are transcribed below. The project sought construction-associated organics, including material in mortar.

Supports: Measured carbon ages; construction relevance depends on each collection context.

Limit: The published row does not supply a full mortar joint or repair history. The surface entry stays visibly flagged; organic age is not stone emplacement.

S168 · Appendix 1, p.1305; methods pp.1297–1299

KH-MOD-01 · Reuse of the radiocarbon dataset

Completion-boundary reanalysis

40 inputs after combining explicit same-sample repeats; the estimated event is construction completion. Reanalysis of S168, not new excavation or independent dating evidence.

Supports: A conditional calendar estimate to compare with historical chronology.

Limit: Assumes monument assignments, king order and a model for the distribution of material ages.

S169 · Table 2, Fig.4 and online model appendix

Different targets · Keep their dates separate

Reign, carbon and completion.

The Ministry attribution remains our historical reference. The completion model estimates a different event from the same carbon dataset. These intervals are not combined into one “possible age” band.

SourceEvent or targetCalendar BCEMeaning of the interval
Ministry reign attributionKhufu’s reign2589–2566Approximate historical chronology; not a measured construction interval
Dee et al. 2009Modelled completion of construction2620–2484 · 95%Published conditional model interval, Table 2
Dee et al. 2009Same completion estimate2559–2518 · 68%Nested probability summary of the same model; not another event

The 2009 model uses king order, phase boundaries and a 5% initial outlier probability. It combines explicit repeat measurements, adds 8 radiocarbon years of uncertainty to combined results, and estimates phase ends. Its 68% completion interval is later than the displayed reign window; agreement is not exact. This is a published result, not a model rerun here. S169

Our next test is context: could older fuel, stored material or a later intervention explain a particular result? A calendar estimate alone cannot decide which. Secure short-lived construction material and independently verified phase relationships would make revisions more informative.

Original-records search · 2026-10-28 · America/Chicago

The reed and the surface sample.

Public-source search completed; target originals not retrieved

No original collection sheet, sample-specific collection photograph or laboratory certificate was retrieved for either target. Published methods and a later database clarify the trail without completing it.

KH-FIELD-0313 · Sample row ↓

ETH-0313

Published record: ARCE 11; reed; surviving summit, south side; 4330 ±125 conventional radiocarbon BP (1σ).

Laboratory route: Campaign-level account: SMU pretreatment, then ETH AMS measurement. This is not a recovered specimen-specific chain of custody.

The later database repeats the measurement but its context ends at “Top platform southwes”. Preserve this truncated wording as an unresolved derivative description; do not replace the original south-side entry.

The published 2009 code includes R_Date("ETH-0313", 4330, 125) with Outlier(0.05). No posterior outlier probability is established here.

Why it matters: A short-lived plant can reduce growth-age uncertainty, but the reed label alone does not establish contemporaneous emplacement. Taxonomic identification, matrix, reuse and treatment remain to check.

Original documents still needed

1984 ARCE 11 provenience sheet, associated photograph numbers and package label; SMU pretreatment record and ETH-0313 AMS result sheet.

  • Original sheet and collection sketch
  • Collection photograph linked by sample/photo number
  • SMU pretreatment and transfer documentation
  • ETH laboratory certificate and analytical output

KH-FIELD-13791 · Sample row ↓

ETH-13791

Published record: Field 391; charcoal; course 86, 1 m north of SE corner, surface; 3810 ±60 conventional radiocarbon BP (1σ); published * flag.

Laboratory route: Campaign-level account: ETH pretreatment and AMS measurement. The individual preparation record has not been inspected.

The database retains age and error but supplies only a generic pyramid context and an empty qualifier. Its omission of the surface wording and * flag cannot clear those cautions.

The published 2009 code includes R_Date("ETH-13791", 3810, 60) with Outlier(0.05). Initial inclusion does not reveal its final influence on the completion estimate.

Why it matters: “Surface” is a published collection description, not proof of contamination or later repair. Determine what was sampled and whether a matrix or masonry joint was documented before interpreting its construction relevance.

Original documents still needed

1995 field-book entry 391, corresponding photograph index and package label; ETH-13791 preparation and AMS result sheets.

  • Original field-book entry and sketch
  • Sample-linked collection photograph
  • ETH pretreatment record
  • ETH laboratory certificate and analytical output

What the search actually recovered

Original field documentation · Existence reported; target records not retrieved

The 2001 paper describes a sheet per 1984 sample, a 1995 field book and photographs of most collection locations. The 1999 project account identifies matrix, feature, collectors, photo numbers and sketches among recorded fields.

Limit: “Most locations” does not guarantee a photograph for either target. No sheet, book page or photo accession has been assigned.

Later access to field notes · Use acknowledged; current custody unconfirmed

Dee et al. 2009, p.1070 thanks Mark Lehner and John Nolan for access to field notes. AERA is therefore a documented research lead.

Limit: This acknowledgement neither publishes those notes nor identifies an archival box or proves where they are held now.

Published collection photograph · Located; different monument

The online caption identifies Wenke, Nolan and Amran sampling at Menkaure; photograph credited to Mark Lehner.

Limit: It illustrates field practice. It cannot be linked to ARCE 11 or field 391.

Earlier provenance publication · Bibliography verified; full text restricted

The 2001 paper directs readers to Haas et al. 1987 for 1984 provenance. The chapter appears in the Fulcrum contents, pp.585–606 by the verified citation.

Limit: Its sample descriptions and illustrations remain unread; no reconstruction of its contents from later summaries.

Later database cross-check · Two derivative entries inspected

EDB_411 and EDB_430 match the target laboratory identifiers, ages and errors.

Limit: The reed location is truncated and the surface caution is absent. A database export is not a laboratory certificate.

Laboratory records · Historical route traced; certificates not retrieved

The published methods distinguish the SMU-to-ETH route in 1984 from ETH processing in 1995. ETH’s current institutional page identifies a recovery lead.

Limit: Current methods and precision are not historical specimen metadata. No certificate accession, treatment yield, measurement run date or surviving-residue inventory verified.

Seek a lawful library copy of Haas et al. 1987, pp.585–606, before deciding whether an archival inquiry is needed. Keep outreach on hold under the established project preference. No records request has been sent. A failed public search does not establish that records were lost or never made.

Bonani et al. 2001 · Appendix 1 · p.1305

46 determinations. 40 sample groups.

Conventional radiocarbon BP is relative to 1950; ± is the published 1σ measurement error. It is not BCE. ETH measurements used AMS; SMU used liquid scintillation counting. Course numbers locate collection, not separate dated building phases. Original report & access note ↗

Five explicit repeat groups account for six extra measurements. Sharing a location—or even a field number—does not by itself establish a repeat: ETH-0312 and ETH-0334 share ARCE 10B but are described only as sharing context, so they remain separate. No individual calibrated interval is supplied in the source table.

Laboratory / field IDMaterial & courseReported location / relationshipRadiocarbon BP ±1σδ¹³C · ‰Dependence / review
ETH-0302ARCE 1 · 1984 campaigncharcoalCourse 2N face; about 26 m west of NE corner4260 ± 80-24.3Group: KH-ARCE-1Field-record audit pending
ETH-0303ARCE 2 · 1984 campaigncharcoalCourse 2N face; about 44 m east of NW corner4300 ± 90-25.4Group: KH-ARCE-2Field-record audit pending
ETH-0304ARCE 3 · 1984 campaigncharcoalCourse 2N face; about 60 m east of NW corner4245 ± 85-24.2Group: KH-ARCE-3Field-record audit pending
ETH-0305ARCE 4 · 1984 campaigncharcoalCourse 2N face; about 60 m east of NW corner4355 ± 90-23.5Group: KH-ARCE-4Field-record audit pending
ETH-4226ARCE 4 · 1984 campaigncharcoalCourse 2Repeat of ETH-03054195 ± 105-28.5Group: KH-ARCE-4Field-record audit pending
ETH-0306ARCE 5 · 1984 campaigncharcoalCourse 2N face; about 20 m east of NW corner4320 ± 85-25.0Group: KH-ARCE-5Field-record audit pending
ETH-0226ARCE 13 · 1984 campaigncharcoalCourse 5Near SE corner4350 ± 125-24.8Group: KH-ARCE-13Field-record audit pending
SMU-1418ARCE 13 · 1984 campaigncharcoalCourse 5Repeat of ETH-02264258 ± 273-26.7Group: KH-ARCE-13Field-record audit pending
ETH-4229ARCE 13 · 1984 campaigncharcoalCourse 5Repeat of ETH-02264195 ± 105-26.0Group: KH-ARCE-13Field-record audit pending
SMU-1417ARCE 14 · 1984 campaigncharcoalCourse 5S face; about five blocks east of SW corner4359 ± 241-25.8Group: KH-ARCE-14Field-record audit pending
ETH-0227ARCE 14 · 1984 campaigncharcoalCourse 5Repeat of SMU-14174360 ± 125-26.6Group: KH-ARCE-14Field-record audit pending
ETH-13762362 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 9About 10 m south of NW corner3927 ± 58-24.5Group: KH-362Field-record audit pending
ETH-13754354 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 10Near NW corner3980 ± 57-22.3Group: KH-354Field-record audit pending
ETH-13756356 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 10About 30 m south of NW corner4143 ± 61-23.9Group: KH-356Field-record audit pending
ETH-13757357 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 10About 35 m south of NW corner4225 ± 79-26.5Group: KH-357Field-record audit pending
ETH-13761361 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 10About 200 m south of NW corner3928 ± 54-30.8Group: KH-361Field-record audit pending
ETH-13763363 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 10Above ETH-13762 on course 93937 ± 61-29.2Group: KH-363Field-record audit pending
ETH-0307ARCE 6 · 1984 campaigncharcoalCourse 25–26Between courses; about 4 m south of NW corner4440 ± 90-21.4Group: KH-ARCE-6Field-record audit pending
ETH-4227ARCE 6 · 1984 campaigncharcoalCourse 25–26Repeat of ETH-03074215 ± 105-24.8Group: KH-ARCE-6Field-record audit pending
ETH-13770370 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 49About 4 m south of NE corner4087 ± 53-26.3Group: KH-370Field-record audit pending
ETH-13771371 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 49Location shared with field 370; separate field number4187 ± 60-25.0Group: KH-371Field-record audit pending
ETH-13775375 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 49Location shared with field 370; separate field number4190 ± 52-28.7Group: KH-375Field-record audit pending
ETH-13777377 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 51About 3 m south of NE corner4313 ± 57-23.0Group: KH-377Field-record audit pending
ETH-13778378 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 52Near NE corner4156 ± 58-24.6Group: KH-378Field-record audit pending
ETH-13779379 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 52Near NE corner4062 ± 61-22.7Group: KH-379Field-record audit pending
ETH-0308ARCE 7 · 1984 campaigncharcoalCourse 65Near NW corner4300 ± 85-24.1Group: KH-ARCE-7Field-record audit pending
ETH-4228ARCE 7 · 1984 campaigncharcoalCourse 65Repeat of ETH-03084390 ± 110-27.9Group: KH-ARCE-7Field-record audit pending
ETH-13783383 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 761.5 m north of SE corner4237 ± 62-19.6Group: KH-383Field-record audit pending
ETH-13784384 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 76Context shared with field 383; separate field number4068 ± 54-24.8Group: KH-384Field-record audit pending
ETH-13785385 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 76Context shared with field 383; separate field number4083 ± 53-27.7Group: KH-385Field-record audit pending
ETH-13782382 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 77About 2 m north of SE corner3984 ± 55-25.2Group: KH-382Field-record audit pending
ETH-13787387 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 81One block north of SE corner4197 ± 49-26.4Group: KH-387Field-record audit pending
ETH-13791391 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 86Surface; 1 m north of SE corner3810 ± 60-22.2Group: KH-391Published flag *Records search & limits ↗
ETH-0309ARCE 8 · 1984 campaigncharcoalCourse 108Near NW corner4420 ± 100-23.9Group: KH-ARCE-8Field-record audit pending
ETH-13800400 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 141SW corner4195 ± 55-31.1Group: KH-400Field-record audit pending
ETH-13799399 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 143About 3 m east of SW corner4128 ± 58-26.5Group: KH-399Field-record audit pending
ETH-13801401 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 143Context shared with field 399; separate field number4189 ± 60-21.2Group: KH-401Field-record audit pending
ETH-13802402 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 145About 3 m east of SW corner4174 ± 61-27.3Group: KH-402Field-record audit pending
ETH-13803403 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 145Context shared with field 402; separate field number4062 ± 60-25.6Group: KH-403Field-record audit pending
ETH-13804404 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 145Context shared with field 402; separate field number4254 ± 59-27.1Group: KH-404Field-record audit pending
ETH-13805405 · 1995 campaigncharcoalCourse 1461 m east of SW corner4267 ± 57-25.5Group: KH-405Field-record audit pending
ETH-0311ARCE 10A · 1984 campaigncharcoalCourse 198Near SW corner of surviving summit4395 ± 85-24.5Group: KH-ARCE-10AField-record audit pending
ETH-0312ARCE 10B · 1984 campaigncharcoalCourse 198Near SW corner of surviving summit5020 ± 130-22.6Group: KH-ARCE-10B-ETH-0312Published flag +Field-record audit pending
ETH-0334ARCE 10B · 1984 campaigncharcoalCourse 198Context shared with ETH-0312; not explicitly called the same sample4440 ± 320-19.7Group: KH-ARCE-10B-ETH-0334Field-record audit pending
ETH-0313ARCE 11 · 1984 campaignreedSurviving summitSouth side4330 ± 125-24.7Group: KH-ARCE-11Records search & limits ↗
ETH-13900500 · 1995 campaigncharcoalSurviving summitEast side4068 ± 60-21.4Group: KH-500Field-record audit pending

The + mark identifies ETH-0312, omitted from the reported 45-result mean. The * marks ETH-13791, explicitly described as a surface collection. An additional summary excludes both; neither value has been deleted from this ledger.

A historical calculation · Not 46 individual calibrations

Keep the original result reproducible.

Appendix 2 (p.1315) calibrates a weighted mean of 4147 ±10 BP from 45 results. Its calibration error is 21 years, the larger reported dispersion value. The alternative p.1305 summary excluding + and * is 4157 ±10 BP, with dispersion 20. Do not substitute that alternative mean into the published calibration below.

CalibETH; Stuiver et al. 1998 tree-ring data. Disjoint intervals remain separate. Relative weights are normalized within each reported sigma set and rounded; they are not probabilities that the pyramid was built in a particular interval. S168

Published setCalibrated BCERelative interval weight
1σ2862–283719.7%
1σ2818–28088.1%
1σ2776–27741.8%
1σ2758–271932.1%
1σ2704–266432.0%
1σ2647–26386.3%
2σ2871–282819.2%
2σ2823–28018.8%
2σ2783–265860.0%
2σ2653–262311.4%
2σ2606–26040.5%
Inspect the five combined inputs in the 2009 code

Labels and values checked in the published code. Explicit component-by-label mapping not printed there; not inferred as a verified join. These are derived inputs, not additional laboratory results.

  • Khufu Combine 1: 4360 ± 112 radiocarbon BP
  • Khufu Combine 2: 4288 ± 69 radiocarbon BP
  • Khufu Combine 3: 4334 ± 68 radiocarbon BP
  • Khufu Combine 4: 4347 ± 69 radiocarbon BP
  • Khufu Combine 5: 4260 ± 78 radiocarbon BP

Published model appendix ↗

Next research pass

From published location to original field record.

  1. Original records search completed without retrieving target sheets/photos/certificates. Obtain Haas et al. 1987 pp.585–606 through lawful library access; then resolve the ARCE 11 and field 391 recovery leads. Outreach remains on hold.
  2. Check laboratory certificates and pretreatment logs, including the single reed result ETH-0313 and flagged ETH-0312 / ETH-13791.
  3. Resolve the five Combine labels to their component determinations from original model files; preserve any disagreement before attempting a modern-curve sensitivity run.
  4. Compare Roth’s chamber reconstruction with the original Perring/Vyse plates and modern photographs, retaining block faces, overlaps and inaccessible surfaces.
  5. Audit the original papyrus dating fragment and its corpus association; do not derive an exact BCE shipment date from census counts alone.

Atlas/globe coverage checked: the reign band is retained, with a separate 95% completion-model record linked to this ledger. Neither the carbon dates nor Merer's Red Sea findspot become additional independent Giza construction events.

Updated 2026-10-29. Editorial status: draft. Source checks and software validation do not replace an independent archaeological review.