PUBLIC RESEARCH PREVIEW Research in progress · uncertainties and source access are recorded throughout.

Southern Chile · Sample-to-context ledger · Working edition

Monte Verde II.
Follow the context.

An old sample and an old settlement are different claims. Trace the dated objects, the surrounding deposits and the connections still under debate.

Approximately 14,500 cal BP · Long-standing interpretation, disputed in 2026.

Retain the long-standing approximately 14,500 cal BP interpretation, explicitly disputed in 2026. The younger proposal depends on geological correlations that remain contested. No new consensus, recalibration or probability for either interpretation is asserted here.

3Occupation-associated algae dates
29Landscape rows · 23 carbon + 6 luminescence
34Core summary rows · 43 underlying measurements

Monte Verde II only. Three occupation-associated algae determinations, 23 landscape radiocarbon rows, six luminescence rows and 34 published core summary rows. This is not the complete historical MV-II collection register. Conventional radiocarbon BP uses 1950 as its reference; calibrated BP is shown separately. Luminescence ages are in ka (thousand years). No dates have been recalibrated here.

From specimen to feature

Begin with the algae.

Two 2008 measurements and one reported in the 2026 defense. Their short lives make them useful tests of a wood-age explanation, but the feature association and marine carbon treatment still matter.

Beta-238355

Gigartina sp.

Recorded context: Floor of the wishbone-shaped hut.

Conventional radiocarbon BP · ±1σ12,290 ± 60
Published calibrated BP14,190–13,990

Published interval; probability convention not verified in this pass. Published result retained; original curve, marine reservoir treatment and laboratory certificate still to verify.

Date of sampled carbon. The human association depends on the recorded feature and its integrity; no field-number-to-layer inference.

S9 · p.785, main-text dates

Beta-239650

Mazzaella sp.

Recorded context: Brazier on a tent floor.

Conventional radiocarbon BP · ±1σ12,310 ± 40
Published calibrated BP14,220–13,980

Published interval; probability convention not verified in this pass. Published result retained; original curve, marine reservoir treatment and laboratory certificate still to verify.

Date of sampled carbon. The human association depends on the recorded feature and its integrity; no field-number-to-layer inference.

S9 · p.785, main-text dates

D-AMS 044324 · Field MV-II-7-9

Porphyra sp.

Recorded context: Burned algae; exact hearth/grid relationship not recovered from the cited passage.

Conventional radiocarbon BP · ±1σ12,251 ± 44
Published calibrated BP14,520–14,230

95.4%, as reported. Published result retained; original curve, marine reservoir treatment and laboratory certificate still to verify.

Date of sampled carbon. The human association depends on the recorded feature and its integrity; no field-number-to-layer inference.

S12 · Online article p.7; also S182, DI Figure 6

Proposal · Response · Unresolved test

Where the interpretations diverge.

The proposed Middle Holocene placement (8,200–4,200 BP) is a period assignment, not a laboratory confidence interval. It remains separate from the approximately 14,500 cal BP occupation interpretation.

Does the ash date the occupation’s land surface?

Claim / audit question

The 2026 model places occupation in SU2, an inset fill formed after incision through older deposits capped by proposed Lepué tephra.

Response

Dillehay’s team disputes ash identification and the correlations across sections; Waters and colleagues challenge the resulting landform chronology.

Further reply / limit: Méndez and colleagues defend the glass correlation using Zr/Th and Zr/Nb ratios and distinguish deposition from erosion across the terrace surfaces.

Our assessment: A cross-valley interpretation is not a same-column ash bracket beneath an excavated hearth. A valid regional ash identification still requires a demonstrated link to the occupation surface.

What would help resolve it: Match glass analyses to exact sampled beds, section photographs and surveyed contacts; compare proposed alternative ash identities.

S11 Figures 1–3 and supplement S3; S179 reply; S181 stratigraphic critique

Which side of the contact was dated?

Claim / audit question

Younger IR50 results 0673 and 0675 are assigned to SU2; older results 0674 and 0676 to underlying SU1a.

Response

Waters and colleagues consider the older ages relevant to an earlier river/incision history.

Further reply / limit: Surovell’s reply argues the older samples date preserved substrate below the erosional contact, not the younger fill.

Our assessment: The measurements alone cannot arbitrate a disagreement about the contact. Corrected and uncorrected ages are distinct outputs from the same samples.

What would help resolve it: Audit the sample tubes against section drawings, the 0676 depth conflict, dose distributions, incomplete bleaching and fading assumptions.

S11 Tables 2/S4–S5; S180 pp.1–3; S181 luminescence discussion

How do the adjacent cores connect to MV-II?

Claim / audit question

The challenge places the nearby core sequence on an older terrace, questioning its equivalence with the archaeological deposit.

Response

Pino and Dillehay use the core chronology and sediment descriptions to support continuity with the older site interpretation.

Further reply / limit: Méndez’s reply disputes the mapped terrace assignment and emphasizes the need to locate the cores correctly.

Our assessment: The 2023 supplement explicitly describes non-cultural sediment. Similar ages do not turn these samples into dated occupation objects.

What would help resolve it: Recover original core coordinates, elevation datum, excavation boundaries and the field crosswalk between each unit scheme.

S177 supplement pp.1–6; S179 core-location discussion; S182 sections 9–10

Can reworking explain the archaeological associations?

Claim / audit question

Older organic deposits provide a possible source of old carbon in younger sediment.

Response

The defense emphasizes patterned occupation features, delicate chewed plant remains and preserved wood associations as obstacles to wholesale reworking.

Further reply / limit: The June reply describes bank slumping and redeposition of organics; it does not require one catastrophic flood transporting every artifact.

Our assessment: A plausible source of old carbon is not an item-by-item transport demonstration. Conversely, preserved patterning does not independently date every material incorporated into a feature.

What would help resolve it: Pair each dated object with original photographs, excavation records, breakage/abrasion observations and the exact feature relationship.

S11 discussion; S12 archaeological-context discussion; S179 redeposition reply; S182 sections 3–7

What do the short-lived algae dates resolve?

Claim / audit question

The occupation-associated algae are a useful test because a wood-age explanation does not automatically apply to them. This is our audit question.

Response

The 2008 paper reports two dated taxa; the 2026 defense adds the Porphyra result. These are not nine independent dates simply because nine taxa were identified.

Further reply / limit: The broader reworking proposal still requires these specimen contexts and carbon sources to be explained; no specimen-level resolution is established in this pass.

Our assessment: Short life reduces one source of age offset. It does not itself remove marine reservoir effects, mixed material or uncertain association.

What would help resolve it: Original algae supplement, laboratory certificates, taxonomic identifications, pretreatment and sample-specific calibration/reservoir rationale; exact feature for MV-II-7-9.

S9 p.785; S12 online p.7; S182 DI Figure 6

Keep the original · Attach the conflict

Corrections belong beside the evidence.

Excluded from MV-II occupation evidence

Beta-7824 belongs in a correction register

Dillehay’s 2023 correction identifies a La Moderna, Argentina date misattributed to Monte Verde. Indexed acknowledgements name Beta-7824. Earlier summaries give 6550 ±100 BP; the 2026 challenge’s Table S7 retains 6550 ±160 BP. Neither is adopted as a repaired Monte Verde measurement.

Full correction text and original laboratory certificate remain unretrieved. The June 2026 defense archive also associates this ID with MV-4; resolve the cross-publication ID trail before reuse. This error alone does not decide the geological model.

Unresolved publication inconsistencies

Core table: counts and confidence labels

Table S1 displays 34 rows representing 43 measurements, but its caption says 29 + 4 rows. It labels intervals 94.5% (2σ). Both printed conventions are retained; no silent substitution of 95.4%.

The final depth is printed 0.93–0.94.5 m. Core identity uses a colour key not yet visually checked. These are reporting issues, not proof that an age is wrong.

110 cm / 220 cm unresolved

VLL-0676-L has two published depths

Main Table 2 gives 110 cm; supplementary Table S4 gives 220 cm. The ledger stores both, retaining Table 2 as its primary transcription.

Original pages, sampling log and section drawing should be reconciled before using this depth to establish a contact relationship.

Table / prose relationship unresolved

Young carbon and the SU1d label

D-AMS 050099 and 050105 are assigned SU1d in Table 1, although the main text describes their material as modern soil. Elsewhere SU1d names the tephra.

Keep the table labels and the textual qualification together; these carbon results do not directly date the ash eruption.

All 63 landscape and core rows shown.

Surovell et al. 2026 · Table 1 · p.1286

23 carbon dates from the landscape.

Unit labels follow the challenged study. Ages do not establish that separated exposures belong to the same occupation horizon. The old Haynes wood sample has a recorded contact relationship but no numerical depth. Source and access note · S11 ↗

Published Bchron 4.7.6 / SHCal20 calibration. Conventional errors are 1σ; calibrated intervals are labelled 2σ. Blank results stay blank. Transcription checked against author-posted text; original table-page inspection remains pending.

Lab / sectionUnit / depthMaterial / relationshipRadiocarbon BP ±1σMedian cal BPPublished cal BP · 2σ
D-AMS 050109Section 8SU1a60 cmwoodLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.13,655 ± 5716,45016,660–16,250
D-AMS 050108Section 8SU1a60 cmwoodLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.13,615 ± 4216,39016,570–16,230
D-AMS 050107Section 8SU1a60 cmwoodLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.13,464 ± 7316,17016,410–15,910
UCIAMS-292331Section 5SU1b55 cmwoodLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.12,525 ± 2514,70015,000–14,430
UCIAMS-292332Section 5SU1b58 cmwoodLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.12,310 ± 2514,19014,780–14,080
UCIAMS-292333Section 5SU1b42 cmwoodLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.12,275 ± 3014,14014,320–14,050
D-AMS 050106Section 1SU1b40 cmcharcoalLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.12,207 ± 5914,08014,310–13,810
UCIAMS-292335Section 5SU1b42 cmwoodLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.11,720 ± 6013,54013,750–13,410
UCIAMS-292330Section 5SU1b46 cmwoodLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.11,715 ± 2513,54013,600–13,470
UCIAMS-292334Section 5SU1b33 cmwoodLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.11,615 ± 2513,45013,510–13,350
D-AMS 050849Section 2SU1b45 cmwoodLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.11,596 ± 4813,42013,570–13,320
D-AMS 045773Section CVHSU2Depth not suppliedwoodCollected by C. V. Haynes on 9 January 1997 slightly above the erosive contact; interpreted as SU2. No numerical depth supplied. Old carbon in this context is interpreted as reworked by Surovell et al.11,275 ± 3613,15013,240–13,100
D-AMS 050103Section 3SU1c45 cmbulk organic matterLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.10,874 ± 4712,77012,890–12,730
D-AMS 050100Section 1SU1c27 cmgyttjaLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.9,955 ± 4711,31011,620–11,210
D-AMS 050850Section 2SU1c35 cmgyttjaLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.9,666 ± 3710,95011,180–10,770
UCIAMS-292329Section 5SU1c28 cmgyttjaLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.8,920 ± 2510,02010,180–9,890
UCIAMS-292339Section 7SU1c40 cmgyttjaLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.8,785 ± 259,7209,890–9,560
UCIAMS-292336Section 6SU244 cmbrown peatLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.6,330 ± 257,2107,310–7,160
UCIAMS-292337Section 6SU233 cmwoodLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.5,925 ± 206,7106,790–6,650
D-AMS 050104Section 4SU250 cmwoodLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.4,506 ± 355,1405,300–4,890
UCIAMS-292338Section 6SU234 cmwoodLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study.3,805 ± 204,1304,240–3,990
D-AMS 050099Section 1SU1d15 cmbulk organic matterLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study. Table labels SU1d; main text calls these modern-soil samples. Preserve the unit-label conflict; this is not a direct ash eruption date.3,096 ± 273,2703,360–3,170
D-AMS 050105Section 1SU1d20 cmwoodLandscape sample; no direct hearth or artifact association in Table 1. Unit assignment follows the challenged study. Table labels SU1d; main text calls these modern-soil samples. Preserve the unit-label conflict; this is not a direct ash eruption date.117 ± 29Not reportedNot supplied

Surovell et al. 2026 · Table 2 · p.1286

Six sediment ages. Two sides of a contact.

K-feldspar IR50 measurements, with MAM-3 dose estimation and fading correction. Corrected and uncorrected estimates are alternatives for the same sample, not independent dates. The geological unit assignment is itself part of the dispute. S11 ↗

The published ± errors are preserved. Their Table 2 sigma convention still needs explicit verification; Figure 2 separately labels its plotted ranges 2σ. Full dose-rate inputs and bleaching/fading replication are outside this first ledger.

Lab / sectionUnit / depthMethod / accepted nUncorrected ka ±Fading-corrected ka ±Context / limit
VLL-0671-LSection 1SU1a205 cmK-feldspar IR50; single grainsn = 13116.9 ± 1.323.3 ± 1.8Authors’ sediment-unit assignment, not an independently linked occupation surface.MAM-3 and fading correction affect the age estimate. No recalculation or new calendar conversion here.
VLL-0672-LSection 1SU1a345 cmK-feldspar IR50; single grainsn = 11016.8 ± 1.223.4 ± 1.7Authors’ sediment-unit assignment, not an independently linked occupation surface.MAM-3 and fading correction affect the age estimate. No recalculation or new calendar conversion here.
VLL-0673-LSection 4SU250 cmK-feldspar IR50; multi-grain aliquotsn = 472 ± 0.22.8 ± 0.2Authors’ sediment-unit assignment, not an independently linked occupation surface.MAM-3 and fading correction affect the age estimate. No recalculation or new calendar conversion here.
VLL-0674-LSection 4SU1a65 cmK-feldspar IR50; single grainsn = 19512.4 ± 118.1 ± 1.4Authors’ sediment-unit assignment, not an independently linked occupation surface.MAM-3 and fading correction affect the age estimate. No recalculation or new calendar conversion here.
VLL-0675-LSection 9SU265 cmK-feldspar IR50; single grainsn = 896.4 ± 0.48.6 ± 0.6Authors’ sediment-unit assignment, not an independently linked occupation surface.MAM-3 and fading correction affect the age estimate. No recalculation or new calendar conversion here.
VLL-0676-LSection 9SU1a110 cm / 220 cm in S4K-feldspar IR50; single grainsn = 1159.8 ± 0.814.3 ± 1.2Authors’ sediment-unit assignment, not an independently linked occupation surface.MAM-3 and fading correction affect the age estimate. No recalculation or new calendar conversion here. Table S4 gives depth 220 cm, versus 110 cm in Table 2; unresolved.

Pino & Dillehay 2023 · Supplement Table S1 · pp.3–4

Adjacent cores are not occupation objects.

These non-cultural sediments were sampled beside the site. The table summarizes selected plant, wood and charcoal fragments; it does not identify a material for every row. The colour key assigning each row to a core awaits visual verification. Original supplement · S177 ↗

34 displayed rows · 43 underlying measurements · 5 combined groups.

Five combined groups account for nine additional measurements. The displayed 34 rows and the caption count disagree. Raw member assays have not been invented. The caption instead gives 29 Taylor + 4 MV-86b = 33. Preserve that discrepancy.

Final calibration: CALIB 8.2 / SHCal20. Earlier Taylor results used CALIB 7.1 / SHCal13. The printed confidence label is 94.5% (2σ); its inconsistency is unresolved. Interval weights, δ¹³C values and member IDs are retained in the JSON download.

Lab / groupDepth · m as printedRadiocarbon BP ± published errorMedian cal BPPublished cal BPMembers / limits
UCIAMS-120984Single row · non-cultural core0.13–0.1495 ± 120Not reportedNot suppliedNo dated occupation featureModern, as reported
UCIAMS-120985Single row · non-cultural core0.14–0.154,385 ± 1254,9705,310–4,610No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-120986Single row · non-cultural core0.20–0.219,185 ± 12510,34010,610–10,110No dated occupation feature
D-AMS 030320Single row · non-cultural core0.27–0.309,468 ± 4410,66010,780–10,510No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-120987Single row · non-cultural core0.29–0.3010,520 ± 14012,35012,730–11,930No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-120988Single row · non-cultural core0.49–0.5012,140 ± 13014,00014,440–13,730No dated occupation feature
D-AMS 030321Single row · non-cultural core0.5612,094 ± 5413,92014,060–13,800No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-120989Single row · non-cultural core0.59–0.6012,620 ± 14014,87015,330–14,210No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-165611Single row · non-cultural core0.61–0.6412,430 ± 10014,53014,960–14,110No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-119553Combined result · non-cultural core0.69–0.7012,650 ± 18714,72315,347–14,069UCIAMS-119553, UCIAMS-120990Published combined mean; raw member results not reconstructed
UCIAMS-119552Single row · non-cultural core0.70–0.7112,650 ± 13514,95015,400–14,270No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-119551Single row · non-cultural core0.71–0.7212,625 ± 13514,97015,420–14,290No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-119555Single row · non-cultural core0.72–0.7312,785 ± 13515,20015,660–14,810No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-119550Single row · non-cultural core0.73–0.7412,680 ± 13515,01015,470–14,760No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-119549Single row · non-cultural core0.74–0.7513,900 ± 13516,81417,140–16,370No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-119548Single row · non-cultural core0.75–0.7613,980 ± 13516,93017,340–16,530No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-119547Single row · non-cultural core0.76–0.7712,965 ± 13515,46015,860–15,080No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-119546Single row · non-cultural core0.77–0.7812,630 ± 13514,90015,340–14,240No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-119545Single row · non-cultural core0.78–0.7912,600 ± 13514,84015,290–14,210No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-117676Single row · non-cultural core0.79–0.8012,580 ± 13014,78715,250–14,210No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-165612Single row · non-cultural core0.80–0.8112,635 ± 4515,01015,190–14,820No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-117675Single row · non-cultural core0.80–0.8113,330 ± 13515,98016,380–15,590No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-117674Single row · non-cultural core0.81–0.8212,625 ± 13014,89015,320–14,260No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-117673Single row · non-cultural core0.82–0.8312,655 ± 13014,96015,390–14,290No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-117672Single row · non-cultural core0.83–0.8412,680 ± 13015,01015,460–14,770No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-117671Single row · non-cultural core0.84–0.8512,610 ± 13014,86015,300–14,240No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-117670Single row · non-cultural core0.85–0.8612,560 ± 13014,83015,280–14,240No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-118281Single row · non-cultural core0.86–0.8712,585 ± 13014,80015,260–14,220No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-117669Single row · non-cultural core0.87–0.8812,530 ± 13514,67515,180–14,150No dated occupation feature
UCIAMS-117668Combined result · non-cultural core0.89–0.9012,600 ± 18414,81015,411–14,098UCIAMS-117668, UCIAMS-116359, UCIAMS-116358Published combined mean; raw member results not reconstructed
UCIAMS-116355Combined result · non-cultural core0.90–0.9112,442 ± 7514,53614,945–14,170UCIAMS-116355, UCIAMS-116356, UCIAMS-116357Published combined mean; raw member results not reconstructed
UCIAMS-116352Combined result · non-cultural core0.91–0.9212,403 ± 7514,46114,874–14,104UCIAMS-116352, UCIAMS-116353, UCIAMS-116354Published combined mean; raw member results not reconstructed
UCIAMS-116349Combined result · non-cultural core0.92–0.9312,602 ± 7514,90715,198–14,782UCIAMS-116349, UCIAMS-116350, UCIAMS-116351Published combined mean; raw member results not reconstructed
UCIAMS-112450Single row · non-cultural core0.93–0.94.512,435 ± 12514,54015,020–14,080No dated occupation featureMalformed depth endpoint retained verbatim; original clarification needed

Review trail · 2026-10-29 · America/Chicago

What has been checked.

First paired contextual audit; published-text transcription, with original certificates and several figure/table checks still pending. Selected arguments have been compared; this is not a replication of either team's full dating or site-formation model.

2008 algae paper · Author-posted main text read

Sample passages transcribed. Original supplement and certificates not retrieved.

2023 core study · Original main PDF and original supplement text recovered

Table S1 text checked; coloured core key and original table layout still await visual verification.

2026 challenge and August responses · Author-posted full texts, selected methods and tables read

Paired argument audit, not a full replication. Main Tables 1–2 remain text-verified provisional transcriptions pending original-page inspection.

June author replies · Public author-posted eLetter texts read

Distinguished from the August journal Perspectives; not independent new excavations or datasets.

June defense archive · Original DOCX recovered · Figshare version 1

Selected sections and DI Figure 14 inspected. File name says version 5; that is not five Figshare versions. Not assumed identical to the August journal supplement.

2023 correction · Indexed publisher abstract and acknowledgement only

Misattribution is flagged; full correction and original certificate remain needed.

Next research pass

Recover the links that could change the assessment.

  1. Recover original algae laboratory reports and the 2008 supplement; establish the field-to-specimen chain for MV-II-7-9 and the reservoir/calibration treatment.
  2. Build a surveyed section-to-excavation crosswalk with original drawings, coordinates and contact photographs; resolve VLL-0676-L’s conflicting depths.
  3. Compare the actual glass geochemistry and alternative tephra identifications, then audit the IR50 dose distributions and fading/bleaching model.
  4. Reconcile the full Beta-7824 correction trail and core-table inconsistencies; extend the occupation register to the historical wood, charcoal and bone collection.

Atlas/globe coverage checked: Both disputed chronology records retained separately. Algae sample span unchanged; wider-area claims remain separate and MV-I remains unplotted. Natural deposits and non-cultural cores create no new human-activity markers.

No records request has been sent. Editorial status: draft. Neither source transcription nor software validation is an independent archaeological review.