PUBLIC RESEARCH PREVIEW Research in progress · uncertainties and source access are recorded throughout.

Chronological comparison · October 28, 2026

Changing places
and gathering places

Did people move their homes, change activities within a settlement, or gather at different communal places? Compare the evidence for each.

Reorganization is visible; a migration sequence is not yet established

People changed how they used places before and during Malta’s monumental tradition. The available evidence does not establish a general sequence in which households relocated first and monument or burial activity concentrated afterwards. Taċ-Ċawla adds a substantial domestic sequence that overlaps the monument tradition. Santa Verna supplies an ordered change of use at one place. The Gozo survey suggests changing concentrations of activity across the landscape, but these are not independently dated movements of households.

Review MT-REORG-001, October 28, 2026; follow-up to MT-SEQ-001. Focus: Taċ-Ċawla, Santa Verna, Ġgantija and Xagħra Circle. Dates are calibrated BCE unless explicitly described otherwise. The companion JSON keeps conventional assays, shared model outputs, ceramic phases and interpretations separate.

Three different things that could have moved

QuestionEvidence neededCurrent assessment
Did households change residence?Dated loss of domestic occupation at an origin and gain at a destination, with comparable recovery and preservation.Unresolved between the named sites. No household origin–destination connection is established.
Did activity move within a settlement?Spatially distinct domestic deposits or structures, ordered through stratigraphy and dates.Supported as an interpretation at Taċ-Ċawla, but its exact timing and household scale remain uncertain.
Did communal or mortuary activity concentrate at fewer places?Changes in use, construction and deposition at monuments, alongside a comparable landscape survey.Plausible on Gozo during the Temple Period. This could involve people gathering from continuing settlements rather than moving their homes.

More pottery, more burials and larger buildings measure different activities. None is, by itself, a residential population count.

What Taċ-Ċawla contributes

The excavation report describes a probable shift from activity in the north and east during the Żebbuġ phase towards the south and west, around the later stone house, during the Tarxien phase. It attributes much dated material to approximately 3600–3100 BCE, while surviving intact deposits predominantly represent later Tarxien and Thermi activity. This is a proposed reorganization within the site, not evidence that its inhabitants departed for Ġgantija or Xagħra. [S83, pp. 119–120, Figs. 3.85–3.89]

The chronology contains useful checks against an overly simple story:

Taċ-Ċawla evidencePublished date and associationImplication
Charred cereals in the probable fire pit, Context (268)UBA-31713 and UBA-31714 share a modeled later-phase interval of 3350–3100 BCE, 95.4%. A basal grain, UBA-33028, has an older, disjoint modeled result retained in the ledger.1These dates support domestic activity before the modeled beginning of Xagħra’s large complex at 2975–2900 BCE. They do not place it before all monument building or all burial at Xagħra.
Pig tooth from the basal structural sequence, described with Context (256)UBA-29836: 2890–2685 BCE.The domestic structural sequence belongs within the period of large-scale monument and mortuary use. The tooth is not a direct wall-construction date.
Lentil and cattle tooth in Context (276)UBA-30423: 2465–2210 BCE; UBA-29835: 2830–2470 BCE. The authors reject their combination as one contemporaneous event.The deposit contains material of different ages. It cannot provide a single floor date or an uninterrupted residence interval.
Crops redeposited in midden Context (206)UBA-30419 and UBA-30418 give a combined published interval of 3350–3120 BCE, yet Tarxien pottery occurs in and below the midden.Older domestic refuse was reused later. A date on that refuse cannot date the later rearrangement.

[S83, pp. 56, 70, 88–91, Table 3.4; S93, Table 5]

This last case is especially important: apparently early dates can occur within later landscape or building changes. Much of Taċ-Ċawla was affected by midden dumping, trampling, cut-and-fill, bioturbation, Roman agricultural trenches and earlier excavations. The higher eastern ground lost much of its soil cover. The report cannot securely date many postholes or reconstruct the density of the settlement’s buildings. [S83, pp. 117–120]

The 22 m² opened to depth beside the 1995 trench is a specifically described excavation area, not the entire settlement or total 2014 exposure. Likewise, the reported 169 ten-litre flotation samples characterize a recovery programme; they do not make all phases equally observable. The density-map legends also differ: the Żebbuġ and Ġgantija panels reach 100 sherds/m², while the Tarxien panel reaches 20. Similar colours are not equal counts. No new density or demographic estimate has been calculated. [S83, pp. 49, 117–118]

Does the wider landscape show a shift before monuments?

Grima and colleagues’ landscape chapter describes repeated changes in the relative importance of the same places. Its early survey interpretation places activity around Santa Verna and Ta’ Kuljat during the Skorba phases, with little corresponding activity around Ġgantija. In the Żebbuġ phase, concentrations appear again around Santa Verna and Ġgantija; the authors place this renewed activity broadly alongside the emergence of megalithic building. Later, the relative prominence of these places fluctuates, with stronger concentration around Ġgantija in the Tarxien phase. [S335, pp. 228–235, Figs. 6.3–6.5]

The chapter reports 11 known locations for Għar Dalam, nine for Skorba, 11 for Żebbuġ, 15 for Ġgantija and 12 for Tarxien. These are retained as published phase-level location counts, not village totals or a population series. The full underlying survey database, site classification rules and Boyle’s original spatial analysis were not recovered for independent reanalysis. The survey concentrated on the Xagħra plateau, covered Għajnsielem less completely and never completed its planned cross-island transects. Its methods recorded terrace area, ground cover, survey effort and revisits, but those variables have not been normalized anew here. [S335, pp. 223–225, 228, 231]

Low-density scatters can reflect manure containing household refuse, erosion or other land use, as well as residence. The disappearance of such scatters need not mean households moved. The published maps also use different density scales between phases. Ceramic-phase durations and identification differ, and the newest pottery study cautions against treating early facies as a perfectly resolved succession. [S335, p. 235; S334]

Consequently, the survey is evidence for a changing distribution of activity, with earlier shifts before the temple tradition and further changes during it. It cannot yet provide a measured lead time between household relocation and monumental concentration.

Two source tensions constrain the interpretation

Taċ-Ċawla’s early hiatus is not independently established by its surviving sequence. The regional chronology chapter includes the site among settlements said to have been abandoned in the fifth millennium. Its own site chapter, however, states that it lacks a dateable sequence capable of demonstrating that early hiatus. The earlier comparison now carries this qualification; the regional model must not be counted as a separate, securely dated local abandonment. [S83, pp. 31–32 versus Table 3.8, p. 122; review MT-REORG-REVIEW-001]

Santa Verna did have Tarxien-period activity. The landscape synthesis says the site apparently did not continue into the Tarxien period. The excavation chapter instead documents Phase V floors attributed to Tarxien through pottery in their foundations, notes extensive Tarxien material recovered in 1911, and considers abandonment during the latter part of that phase possible. Earlier excavators removed much of the relevant upper sequence. We therefore retain Tarxien use with an uncertain ending, not an absence of Tarxien occupation.2 [S83, pp. 162–164; S335, p. 235; review MT-REORG-REVIEW-002]

The Santa Verna excavators also propose that some worked stones at Xagħra might have come from Santa Verna. This remains a source hypothesis: no demonstrated refit, specimen-level provenance connection or dated removal event was recovered in this review. Some installations at Xagħra are late in its history, so such a transfer could concern alterations to an already functioning burial complex. It cannot automatically explain the complex’s initial establishment centuries earlier. [S83, p. 164; S93]

Water offers a testable explanation, not a demonstrated cause

Ground-penetrating radar and observed seeps support a fault-related water source near Ġgantija. That makes reliable water a plausible reason why agricultural and communal activity persisted there. Ruffell and colleagues also explicitly caution that spring place-names are much later than the monuments and that groundwater pathways may have changed. Their evidence does not date a prehistoric reduction in discharge at Santa Verna, measure a migration, or establish who controlled water. [S336, sections 5–9]

At Taċ-Ċawla, laminated deposits and drying cracks indicate intermittent standing water; subsequent deposits contain settlement refuse. The local waterhole-to-filled-space sequence can be examined independently of a claim that drought displaced an entire community. Its context dates and formation history need to be linked before making it a regional climatic event. [S83, pp. 50, 56, 70]

Our working inference is that continued residence, changing agricultural use and selective investment in communal places could have developed together. Reliable water is one plausible influence, alongside preservation differences, changing deposition practices, social choices and the reuse of established places. The archaeological order alone does not establish environmental causation.

The next discriminating test

The most useful next question is narrower: Did Santa Verna lose particular communal functions while Ġgantija and Xagħra, already in use, gained them?

  1. Establish Santa Verna’s last original floors and associated use deposits, separating their ceramic dates from later removal and destruction. Its 1911 archive and surviving Phase V deposits matter more than an assumed phase-wide absence.
  2. Match any proposed transferred stone to an individual Xagħra installation, construction context and material/provenance assessment. Similar limestone or decorative treatment alone is insufficient.
  3. Compare domestic activity and agricultural indicators around the sites using the same survey units, visibility controls and ceramic-phase alternatives. Require domestic evidence before calling a concentration residential.

A demonstrable loss of a function at one site followed by its gain at another would advance this hypothesis. If the final-use and expansion intervals overlap, concurrent specialization remains possible. If apparent contraction disappears after recovery and preservation controls, the redistribution claim weakens. No further date audit is needed merely to preserve the present unresolved labels.

Sources and access

Footnotes

  1. S83 Table 3.4 prints 84% and 12% for the basal Taċ-Ċawla grain’s two modeled ranges; both values are preserved without renormalizing their 96% sum. ↩

  2. S335 p. 235’s apparent cessation conflicts with the more detailed S83 pp. 162–164. Relative decline remains a possible landscape interpretation, but complete absence does not. No absolute abandonment date, stone transfer, water-failure date or household relocation is assigned. ↩

Malta research collection → · Settlement and monument sequence →