Deep dates, disputed agency
Santos and colleagues re-dated charcoal using ABOX-SC pretreatment. Five samples yielded results greater than 56,000 radiocarbon years BP, beyond the method’s effective measurement limit in that study. These are lower limits on charcoal ages, not finite calendar dates for people or tools. [S67 · Santos et al. (2003)]
Parenti’s 2023 reappraisal defends the archaeological interpretation while addressing alternatives including rockfall, monkey percussion, wildfire and water movement. A reliable charcoal age does not itself identify who—or what—started a fire. [S68 · Parenti (2023)]
Repository treatment
The deep charcoal claim remains unplotted on the calendar-oriented atlas. Assigning it a point at 56,000 would erase both its lower-limit character and its radiocarbon convention. This is an evidence-assessment decision, not exclusion of an inconvenient date.
This rock shelter is distinct from Vale da Pedra Furada. Its later imagery must not inherit a date from basal charcoal.
Next audit
Pair each putative hearth with its plan, photographs, sediment observations and dated charcoal; compare the claimed tools with locally generated natural fractures. Establish formation processes before treating the oldest carbon as occupation.