PUBLIC RESEARCH PREVIEW Research in progress · uncertainties and source access are recorded throughout.

Cholula · Sample to construction context

Which building?
Which carbon?

Twelve determinations from Plunket and Uruñuela’s report. The material measured, its position and its relation to construction remain separate.

Working transcription · not a new chronology

Published values retained. Calibrated ranges are the report’s 2σ results, not newly recalibrated ages; calibration settings have not yet been audited. Conventional radiocarbon BP and calendar dates are separate fields. Tables 1–2 use Beta IDs; the narrative uses B- prefixes.

Read the relationship before the number

Pit contents beneath a structure, material inside its fill, and material covering it answer different questions. None directly measures the day the building was made. Reused older carbon can make construction fill appear early.

The report tentatively places Sub-I-A in the second century CE. It reports no dates from inside I-A itself. INAH’s second-century-BCE assessment remains a separate source claim, not an alternate calibration of these samples. S42 · S43

Published determinations

Conventional radiocarbon BP is relative to 1950. The quoted ± values are measurement errors; the final column contains the report’s calibrated 2σ calendar ranges. Disjoint ranges stay disjoint.

Laboratory IDMaterial & methodConstruction contextRadiocarbon BP · ±1σPublished calibrated 2σ
Beta-188342BeanAMSPit 1 below I-ACarbon age does not directly date construction.1790 ± 50115 CE–385 CE
Beta-188343Bean fragmentAMSPit 1 below I-ACarbon age does not directly date construction.1870 ± 5045 CE–250 CE
Beta-188344SeedAMSPit 2 below I-ACarbon age does not directly date construction.1920 ± 5030 BCE–225 CE
Beta-188345BeanAMSSub-I-A cell fillCarbon age does not directly date construction.1910 ± 505 BCE–230 CE
Beta-188346MaizeAMSSub-I-A stepped-body lensCarbon age does not directly date construction.1850 ± 5060 CE–260 CE
Beta-188347MaizeAMSFill above west I-ACarbon age does not directly date construction.1820 ± 4095 CE–265 CE
and 290 CE–325 CE
Beta-188348Charred materialAMSI-B plaster/tablero interfaceCarbon age does not directly date construction.1930 ± 5040 BCE–215 CE
Beta-188349Charred materialAMSFill above north I-BCarbon age does not directly date construction.1760 ± 40155 CE–390 CE
Beta-188350Charred materialAMSFill above north I-BNarrative prints B-198350; table prints 188350. Table ID retained; authors flag older material reused in fill.1980 ± 5080 BCE–120 CE
Beta-188351Charred materialAMSFill above I-B¹Authors suspect older material reused in fill.1930 ± 5040 BCE–215 CE
Beta-162997Charred materialAMSSub-A fill (table label)Carbon age does not directly date construction.1810 ± 40110 CE–330 CE
Beta-162998Charred materialRadiocarbon; AMS not specified in tableFill above west I-ACarbon age does not directly date construction.1700 ± 60220 CE–450 CE

Review still needed

Check original laboratory certificates and calibration settings, reconcile phase labels with plans, and incorporate later excavation reports. The narrative’s B-198350 / table’s Beta-188350 discrepancy is retained in the affected row. This ledger does not collapse twelve measurements into twelve independent building events.