Start with the layers
INAH describes an immense base, approximately 450 metres on a side. The complex preserves murals, and the church of Nuestra Señora de los Remedios stands above the pyramid. Modern appearance, ancient construction stages and the wider city need separate histories. [S41 · INAH, Zona Arqueológica de Cholula.]
The Great Pyramid is a succession of enlarged buildings, not a single construction event. INAH places Cholula’s broader archaeological history at 650 BCE–1521 CE, with a principal Classic period of 200–800 CE. Its account connects the city with Teotihuacan and southeastern exchange networks. Those city dates are not measurements of the pyramid. [S41 · INAH, Zona Arqueológica de Cholula.]
Two published assessments of the beginning
INAH’s detailed overview places the first large pyramid in the second century BCE. [S42 · INAH, Cholula · Lugares INAH.] Plunket and Uruñuela instead tentatively place the earliest platform they identify, Sub-I-A, in the second century CE, using carbon in fill and underlying pits. The two assessments remain separate atlas records; we do not average them. [S43 · Plunket & Uruñuela (report submitted 2004)]
Open the twelve-sample construction ledger. Carbon can predate the fill into which it was incorporated. Excavation context and structural interpretation therefore matter as much as the laboratory result.
A longer building history
McCafferty’s 1996 reinterpretation assigns the last major construction stage to the Early Postclassic. This reinforces the need to identify which stage a proposed age describes. It does not resolve every disagreement about the earliest platform. [S44 · McCafferty (1996)]
Questions to pursue
- Reconcile the structural plans and phase names behind the BCE and CE assessments.
- Audit later excavations before treating the 2004 report as a final chronology.
- Add community-authored accounts of Cholula’s continuing sacred landscape, with named authors, communities and publication contexts. Institutional summaries are not substitutes for those accounts.