PUBLIC RESEARCH PREVIEW Research in progress · uncertainties and source access are recorded throughout.

Malta · Latnija evidence ledger

A hearth.
A layer. A sea crossing.

Trace the earliest reported human occupation of Malta from excavated material to measured dates—and from those dates to the landscape beyond the cave.

33charcoal & bone dates
49marine shell dates
5failed bone attempts retained
A source audit, with unresolved differences

The published interpretation places the beginning of occupation around 8,500 years ago. This ledger preserves that assessment while identifying conflicting sample values and model summaries. No new calibration or dating model has been run. Read the bone-date discrepancy →

01 · The archaeological association

Later cuts complicate a simple stack.

Phases V–III contain the archaeological assemblage. Phase VI is the underlying natural deposit. The schematic shows the main relationships described in the paper; it is not an excavation plan, a measured profile or a scale drawing.

Schematic of Latnija’s phase relationshipsLater Phase I and II deposits overlie the sequence. A Phase III pit cuts Phase IV and the top of Phase V. Phase V’s hearth and ash deposits overlie natural Phase VI sediment. Shapes and thicknesses are illustrative.I–II · Later cover and mixed depositsIV · Clast-rich sedimentV · Hearths, ash, tools and faunaVI · Natural cave-floor sedimentIII · Pit fillShell tips & ashCuts IV and upper V

On narrow screens, scroll the diagram sideways to see the Phase III pit.

Phase I–II

Later cover

Modern and later prehistoric/historic deposits; Phase II contains a mixture of ages. It does not provide a sharp, securely dated end to the Mesolithic here.

Beds 4–1 for Phase II in the main account; Phase I modern cover.

Phase III

Pit and discrete dumping episodes

A pit cuts through Phase IV and truncates the top of V. Shell tips, ash and tools occur in the fill. Contexts 019 and 029 contain conspicuous shell dumps.

Beds 9–5; Units and phases are different classification systems.

Phase IV

Clast-rich deposition

Roof-fall/clast-rich sediment near the shelter grades to finer deposits away from the dripline. Later cut by the Phase III pit.

Bed 3b in the main section.

Phase V

Earliest archaeological horizon

Hearths, ash-rich deposits, tools and fauna. In-situ burning and reworked combustion residues both occur; not every ash-rich context is an intact hearth.

Beds 12–10. The lowest described hearth is in square N2; no one-to-one laboratory assignment to that feature is invented.

Phase VI

Underlying natural cave sediment

Mineral-rich cave-floor deposits above sloping boulders. Sparse charcoal recovered by flotation constrains the background sequence, not a demonstrated human occupation.

Beds 15–13 in the main account; Unit 4 in the supplement.

The N2 basal hearth has ash over thermally altered substrate, supported by micromorphology. FTIR results vary by sampling zone and preserve subtler thermal interpretations. Tables S2 and S5 do not provide a complete mapping from every sample’s numbered context to a specific hearth or bed. The ledger preserves square, context and phase without inventing those links. Follow the published field relationships and 24 hearth-analysis samples → S80 · S106

02 · Each specimen, its context and its date

What was actually measured?

82 reported numerical dates and five failed attempts. Fourteen charcoal specimens reappear in the marine comparison table; they remain single sample records here. Conventional radiocarbon BP, calibrated BCE and modelled calendar BP are separate fields.

Showing 87 sample records

Identifier & contextMeasurementPublished calibrated envelopesRelationship & model use
MAMS 61861charcoal
Square N3 · context 019
Phase III · model IIIB
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
6,929 ± 27conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

5,836–5,756 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

5,886–5,731 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

5,886–5,732 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 6929 ± 27 ¹⁴C BP; model phase IIIB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 7,829.5–7,684.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 7,829.5–7,684.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R05: Repeated charcoal calibrations are not identical
MAMS 61857charcoal
Square N3 · context 025
Phase III · model IIIB
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
6,956 ± 27conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

5,886–5,785 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

5,967–5,741 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

5,967–5,741 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 6956 ± 27 ¹⁴C BP; model phase IIIB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 7,909.5–7,689.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 7,909.5–7,689.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

MAMS 54779charcoal
Square N2 · context 025
Phase III · model IIIB
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
5,510 ± 30conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

4,440–4,332 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

4,446–4,268 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 5510 ± 30 ¹⁴C BP; model phase IIIB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 6,389.5–6,219.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 6,389.5–6,219.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R04: Intraphase age spread needs an association audit
MAMS 61851charcoal
Square N3 · context 029
Phase III · model IIIA
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
6,918 ± 22conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

5,830–5,744 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

5,877–5,731 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

5,877–5,731 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 6918 ± 22 ¹⁴C BP; model phase IIIA.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 7,789.5–7,689.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 7,789.5–7,689.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

MAMS 54774charcoal
Square N2 · context 029
Phase III · model IIIA
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
7,041 ± 32conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

5,983–5,892 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

5,993–5,841 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

5,994–5,841 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 7041 ± 32 ¹⁴C BP; model phase IIIA.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 7,899.5–7,719.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 7,899.5–7,719.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R03: Outlier probabilities and model agreement are different diagnosticsLAT-R05: Repeated charcoal calibrations are not identical
MAMS 61854charcoal
Square N3 · context 031
Phase III · model IIIA
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
6,984 ± 26conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

5,969–5,833 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

5,979–5,776 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

5,979–5,779 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 6984 ± 26 ¹⁴C BP; model phase IIIA.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 7,839.5–7,704.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 7,839.5–7,704.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R05: Repeated charcoal calibrations are not identical
MAMS 54781charcoal
Square N2 · context 037
Phase III · model IIIA
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
6,871 ± 35conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

5,794–5,718 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

5,839–5,669 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

5,841–5,672 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 6871 ± 35 ¹⁴C BP; model phase IIIA.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 7,789.5–7,659.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 7,789.5–7,659.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R05: Repeated charcoal calibrations are not identical
MAMS 61846charcoal
Square L3 · context 104
Phase IV · model IV
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
6,908 ± 21conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

5,802–5,736 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

5,842–5,727 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 6908 ± 21 ¹⁴C BP; model phase IV.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 7,834.5–7,719.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 7,834.5–7,719.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R03: Outlier probabilities and model agreement are different diagnostics
MAMS 54768charcoal
Square L2 · context 028
Phase IV · model IV
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
6,997 ± 32conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

5,971–5,842 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

5,983–5,787 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

5,983–5,790 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 6997 ± 32 ¹⁴C BP; model phase IV.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 7,904.5–7,744.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 7,904.5–7,744.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R05: Repeated charcoal calibrations are not identical
MAMS 54765charcoal
Square L2 · context 034
Phase V · model VB
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
7,096 ± 34conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

6,015–5,921 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

6,059–5,893 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

6,058–5,894 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 7096 ± 34 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 8,004.5–7,849.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 8,004.5–7,849.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R05: Repeated charcoal calibrations are not identical
MAMS 54771charcoal
Square L2 · context 038
Phase V · model VB
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
7,058 ± 33conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

5,987–5,899 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

6,015–5,846 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 7058 ± 33 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 7,959.5–7,799.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 7,959.5–7,799.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

MAMS 62546charcoal
Square N2 · context 039
Phase V · model VA
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
7,078 ± 27conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

6,007–5,915 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

6,018–5,894 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

6,017–5,895 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 7078 ± 27 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VA.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 7,964.5–7,849.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 7,964.5–7,849.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R05: Repeated charcoal calibrations are not identical
MAMS 62547charcoal
Square N2 · context 040
Phase V · model VA
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
7,081 ± 26conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

6,007–5,917 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

6,019–5,895 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

6,019–5,896 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 7081 ± 26 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VA.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 7,964.5–7,849.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 7,964.5–7,849.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R05: Repeated charcoal calibrations are not identical
MAMS 62553charcoal
Square L2 · context 041
Phase V · model VB
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
7,008 ± 26conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

5,974–5,846 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

5,984–5,804 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

5,985–5,806 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 7008 ± 26 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 7,929.5–7,784.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 7,929.5–7,784.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R05: Repeated charcoal calibrations are not identical
MAMS 54769charcoal
Square N2 · context 043
Phase V · model VA
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
7,229 ± 33conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

6,211–6,024 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

6,220–6,016 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 7229 ± 33 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VA.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 8,159.5–7,964.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 8,159.5–7,964.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

MAMS 62552charcoal
Square L2 · context 044
Phase V · model VB
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
6,970 ± 26conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

5,891–5,799 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

5,971–5,755 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 6970 ± 26 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 7,919.5–7,719.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 7,919.5–7,719.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

MAMS 62548charcoal
Square N2 · context 046
Phase V · model VA
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
7,375 ± 27conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

6,351–6,097 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

6,372–6,086 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

6,367–6,084 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 7375 ± 27 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VA.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 8,284.5–8,029.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 8,284.5–8,029.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R05: Repeated charcoal calibrations are not identical
MAMS 62549charcoal
Square N2 · context 047
Phase V · model VA
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
7,112 ± 26conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

6,019–5,927 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

6,061–5,916 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

6,060–5,916 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 7112 ± 26 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VA.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 8,004.5–7,869.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 8,004.5–7,869.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R05: Repeated charcoal calibrations are not identical
MAMS 54780charcoal
Square L2 · context 048
Phase V · model VB
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
6,998 ± 35conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

5,973–5,841 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

5,985–5,781 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

5,985–5,789 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 6998 ± 35 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 7,929.5–7,744.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 7,929.5–7,744.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R05: Repeated charcoal calibrations are not identical
MAMS 65878charcoal · Pistacia sp.
Square LM3 · context 143
Phase V · model VB
Table S2, printed p.52; PDF p.53
Link to this sample
6,903 ± 19conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

5,796–5,736 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

5,837–5,728 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 6903 ± 19 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 7,784.5–7,679.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 7,784.5–7,679.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

MAMS 65862charcoal · Pistacia sp.
Square M3 · context 167
Phase V · model VB
Table S2, printed p.53; PDF p.54
Link to this sample
7,231 ± 19conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

6,087–6,029 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

6,218–6,022 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 7231 ± 19 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 8,164.5–7,974.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 8,164.5–7,974.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

MAMS 65877charcoal
Square M3 · context 168
Phase V · model VB
Table S2, printed p.53; PDF p.54
Link to this sample
7,504 ± 20conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

6,423–6,277 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

6,433–6,260 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

Within the Mesolithic archaeological phase. Context association dates carbon deposition/burning history; no individual stone tool is directly dated.

Published model output & input

Input: 7504 ± 20 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 8,379.5–8,209.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 8,379.5–8,209.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

MAMS 62551charcoal
Square N2 · context 051
Phase VI · model VIA
Table S2, printed p.53; PDF p.54
Link to this sample
9,917 ± 31conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

9,441–9,305 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

9,511–9,288 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

Underlying natural cave sediment. Its charcoal constrains the sequence; it is not automatically evidence of human occupation.

Published model output & input

Input: 9917 ± 31 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VIA.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 11,454.5–11,239.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 11,454.5–11,239.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

MAMS 65864charcoal · Pistacia sp.
Square L3 · context 172
Phase VI · model VIB
Table S2, printed p.53; PDF p.54
Link to this sample
9,018 ± 21conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

8,276–8,246 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

8,286–8,231 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

Underlying natural cave sediment. Its charcoal constrains the sequence; it is not automatically evidence of human occupation.

Published model output & input

Input: 9018 ± 21 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VIB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 10,229.5–10,184.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 10,229.5–10,184.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

MAMS 65863charcoal · angiosperm
Square M3 · context 175
Phase VI · model VIB
Table S2, printed p.53; PDF p.54
Link to this sample
7,653 ± 20conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

6,500–6,455 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

6,570–6,437 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

Underlying natural cave sediment. Its charcoal constrains the sequence; it is not automatically evidence of human occupation.

Published model output & input

Input: 7653 ± 20 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VIB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 8,514.5–8,389.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 8,514.5–8,389.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R04: Intraphase age spread needs an association audit
MAMS 65865charcoal · Juniperus/Tetraclinis
Square L3 · context 177
Phase VI · model VIB
Table S2, printed p.53; PDF p.54
Link to this sample
7,367 ± 19conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2
Model input: 7,376 ± 19 ¹⁴C BP
Unresolved source difference

6,329–6,099 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

6,357–6,086 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

Underlying natural cave sediment. Its charcoal constrains the sequence; it is not automatically evidence of human occupation.

Published model output & input

Input: 7376 ± 19 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VIB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 8,314.5–8,039.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 8,314.5–8,039.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R02: Charcoal 65865: 7367 versus 7376LAT-R04: Intraphase age spread needs an association audit
MAMS 65866charcoal · Juniperus/Tetraclinis
Square L3 · context 182
Phase VI · model VIB
Table S2, printed p.53; PDF p.54
Link to this sample
5,160 ± 17conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

3,982–3,959 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

4,039–3,951 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

Underlying natural cave sediment. Its charcoal constrains the sequence; it is not automatically evidence of human occupation.

Published model output & input

Input: 5160 ± 17 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VIB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 5,984.5–5,899.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 5,984.5–5,899.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R04: Intraphase age spread needs an association audit
MAMS 65867charcoal · angiosperm
Square L3 · context 183
Phase VI · model VIB
Table S2, printed p.53; PDF p.54
Link to this sample
7,740 ± 20conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

6,598–6,508 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

6,641–6,481 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

Underlying natural cave sediment. Its charcoal constrains the sequence; it is not automatically evidence of human occupation.

Published model output & input

Input: 7740 ± 20 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VIB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 8,584.5–8,449.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 8,584.5–8,449.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R04: Intraphase age spread needs an association audit
MAMS 65868charcoal · Juniperus/Tetraclinis
Square M3 · context 184
Phase VI · model VIB
Table S2, printed p.53; PDF p.54
Link to this sample
7,715 ± 20conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

6,588–6,503 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

6,596–6,473 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

Underlying natural cave sediment. Its charcoal constrains the sequence; it is not automatically evidence of human occupation.

Published model output & input

Input: 7715 ± 20 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VIB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 8,539.5–8,424.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 8,539.5–8,424.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R04: Intraphase age spread needs an association audit
MAMS 65869charcoal
Square M3 · context 186
Phase VI · model VIB
Table S2, printed p.53; PDF p.54
Link to this sample
9,238 ± 22conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

8,544–8,356 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

8,554–8,340 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

Underlying natural cave sediment. Its charcoal constrains the sequence; it is not automatically evidence of human occupation.

Published model output & input

Input: 9238 ± 22 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VIB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 10,499.5–10,294.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 10,499.5–10,294.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

MAMS 65879charcoal · cf. Pistacia
Square N3 · context 190
Phase VI · model VIB
Table S2, printed p.53; PDF p.54
Link to this sample
6,932 ± 19conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

5,837–5,764 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

5,883–5,737 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

Underlying natural cave sediment. Its charcoal constrains the sequence; it is not automatically evidence of human occupation.

Published model output & input

Input: 6932 ± 19 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VIB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 7,829.5–7,689.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 7,829.5–7,689.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R04: Intraphase age spread needs an association audit
MAMS 65874charcoal · angiosperm
Square MN3 · context 198
Phase VI · model VIB
Table S2, printed p.53; PDF p.54
Link to this sample
7,068 ± 20conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2

5,989–5,914 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

6,010–5,894 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

Underlying natural cave sediment. Its charcoal constrains the sequence; it is not automatically evidence of human occupation.

Published model output & input

Input: 7068 ± 20 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VIB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 7,954.5–7,844.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 7,954.5–7,844.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements.

LAT-R04: Intraphase age spread needs an association audit
71684 · published IDbone
Square N3 · context 171
Phase V
Table S2, printed p.53; PDF p.54
Link to this sample
No age obtainedNo calibrated result. Failed collagen recovery is not an age or evidence of absence.

Bone from Phase V; species and human modification of this specimen are not established by Table S2. Failed attempts have no numerical age.

71685 · published IDbone
Square N3 · context 166
Phase V
Table S2, printed p.53; PDF p.54
Link to this sample
No age obtainedNo calibrated result. Failed collagen recovery is not an age or evidence of absence.

Bone from Phase V; species and human modification of this specimen are not established by Table S2. Failed attempts have no numerical age.

71686 · published IDbone
Square M3 · context 162
Phase V
Table S2, printed p.53; PDF p.54
Link to this sample
No age obtainedNo calibrated result. Failed collagen recovery is not an age or evidence of absence.

Bone from Phase V; species and human modification of this specimen are not established by Table S2. Failed attempts have no numerical age.

71687 · published IDbone
Square L3 · context 161
Phase V
Table S2, printed p.53; PDF p.54
Link to this sample
No age obtainedNo calibrated result. Failed collagen recovery is not an age or evidence of absence.

Bone from Phase V; species and human modification of this specimen are not established by Table S2. Failed attempts have no numerical age.

71688 · published IDbone
Square L3 · context 143
Phase V · model VB
Table S2, printed p.53; PDF p.54
Link to this sample
6,100 ± 30conventional ¹⁴C BP · S2
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S2
Model input: 8,100 ± 30 ¹⁴C BP
Unresolved source difference

5,195–4,955 cal BCES2 · 68% (printed)

5,205–4,910 cal BCES2 · 95% (printed)

Bone from Phase V, context 143. The table and model input disagree; neither version is adopted here as a resolved direct age.

Published model output & input

Input: 8100 ± 30 ¹⁴C BP; model phase VB.

S3 modelled 95% envelope: 9,119.5–8,784.5 cal BP.

Pinned repository 95% envelope: 9,119.5–8,784.5 cal BP.

Separate source versions; these are conditional model outputs, not extra measurements. Table S2 lists this in its MAMS column, while Methods attributes bone analysis to CAIS, University of Georgia. The original laboratory certificate has not been checked.

LAT-R01: Bone 71688: table and model differ by 2,000 radiocarbon yearsLAT-R03: Outlier probabilities and model agreement are different diagnostics
71689 · published IDbone
Square M3 · context 143
Phase V
Table S2, printed p.53; PDF p.54
Link to this sample
No age obtainedNo calibrated result. Failed collagen recovery is not an age or evidence of absence.

Bone from Phase V; species and human modification of this specimen are not established by Table S2. Failed attempts have no numerical age.

MAMS 61745marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 019
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,811 ± 24conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

6,219–5,877 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61754marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 019
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,531 ± 24conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

5,974–5,628 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61755marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 019
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,790 ± 24conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

6,211–5,860 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 59275marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 019
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,563 ± 27conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

6,001–5,646 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61729marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 019
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,517 ± 25conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

5,966–5,621 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61772marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 019
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,861 ± 22conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

6,236–5,906 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61724marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 025
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,380 ± 25conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

5,851–5,559 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61770marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 025
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,348 ± 22conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

5,834–5,557 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61695marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 029
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,932 ± 25conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

6,257–5,932 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61735marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 029
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,625 ± 24conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

6,062–5,703 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61737marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 029
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,511 ± 23conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

5,961–5,618 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61740marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 029
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,776 ± 24conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

6,201–5,843 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61752marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 029
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,479 ± 25conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

5,929–5,591 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 59273marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 029
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,801 ± 28conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

6,215–5,865 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61713marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 029
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,600 ± 22conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

6,036–5,676 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61719marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 029
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,450 ± 25conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

5,901–5,581 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61769marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 029
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,454 ± 21conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

5,903–5,581 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61773marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 029
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,477 ± 21conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

5,925–5,591 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61807marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 029
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,539 ± 19conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

5,977–5,633 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61809marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 029
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,681 ± 20conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

6,118–5,741 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61810marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 029
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,765 ± 20conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

6,197–5,837 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61811marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 029
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,865 ± 21conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

6,240–5,909 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61813marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 031
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.58; PDF p.59
Link to this sample
7,655 ± 20conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

6,082–5,721 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61808marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 037
Phase III
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,591 ± 19conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase III marine correction ↓

6,025–5,669 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61764marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 028
Phase IV
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,905 ± 26conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase IV marine correction ↓

6,466–5,956 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61781marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 028
Phase IV
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,647 ± 25conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase IV marine correction ↓

6,218–5,722 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61784marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 028
Phase IV
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,404 ± 21conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase IV marine correction ↓

5,979–5,526 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61751marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 034
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,592 ± 25conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

6,236–5,671 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61760marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 034
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,467 ± 23conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

6,099–5,555 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61708marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 034
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,790 ± 23conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

6,442–5,884 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61790marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 034
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,245 ± 24conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

5,951–5,462 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61792marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 034
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,419 ± 23conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

6,056–5,536 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61806marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 034
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
8,091 ± 20conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

6,609–6,080 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61734marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 039
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,750 ± 24conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

6,410–5,843 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61714marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 039
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,685 ± 22conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

6,356–5,775 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61780marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 039
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,708 ± 26conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

6,376–5,801 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61736marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 040
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,406 ± 23conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

6,043–5,528 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61690marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 041
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,345 ± 23conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

5,991–5,495 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61696marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 041
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,971 ± 25conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

6,580–6,041 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61747marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 041
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,602 ± 25conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

6,248–5,680 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61749marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 041
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,420 ± 27conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

6,056–5,536 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61797marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 041
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,339 ± 19conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

5,985–5,492 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61785marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 046
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,403 ± 21conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

6,038–5,526 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61793marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 046
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,776 ± 19conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

6,431–5,871 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61801marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 046
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.59; PDF p.60
Link to this sample
7,906 ± 22conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

6,544–5,993 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61783marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 047
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.60; PDF p.61
Link to this sample
7,564 ± 22conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

6,216–5,657 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61802marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 047
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.60; PDF p.61
Link to this sample
7,586 ± 19conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

6,230–5,672 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61777marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 048
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.60; PDF p.61
Link to this sample
7,544 ± 21conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

6,200–5,641 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

MAMS 61743marine shell · Phorcus turbinatus
Square not reported · context 048
Phase V
Table S5, printed p.60; PDF p.61
Link to this sample
7,449 ± 25conventional ¹⁴C BP · S5
Published ±; confidence convention not stated in Table S5
Phase V marine correction ↓

6,081–5,546 cal BCES5 · 95% (printed)

Shell interpreted as brought to the cave by people; phase-specific marine reservoir correction is estimated using charcoal. This is additional material evidence but not a wholly independent calendar clock. Square not given in Table S5.

BCE is used here for the tables’ “cal BC.” Their printed 68% and 95% labels are retained. These endpoint summaries do not reproduce every gap or peak in the underlying calibrated probability distribution.

03 · A second material, a shared calibration dependency

Marine shells need their own clock correction.

Marine carbon can have a different apparent radiocarbon age from atmospheric carbon. The study estimates a local ΔR for each phase using charcoal with IntCal20 and shells with Marine20. A negative ΔR is a correction relative to the marine model, not a negative sample age.

Phase III

64.2 ± 64.8 years

6 charcoal comparisons · 24 shells

Table S4 · published ± convention unspecified. Source S106.

Phase IV

9.5 ± 111.5 years

1 charcoal comparison · 3 shells

Table S4 · published ± convention unspecified. Source S106.

Phase V

-57.3 ± 128.6 years

7 charcoal comparisons · 22 shells

Table S4 · published ± convention unspecified. Source S106.

These 49 shells support the authors’ interpretation of the dumping deposits and their chronology. Their adjusted calendar ages are partly dependent on the charcoal comparisons, so “independent” must be qualified. Table S5 does not provide per-shell square coordinates or a full per-sample exclusion history for estimating ΔR. Read the dependency note →

04 · Measurement is not a phase boundary

The sequence constrains the model.

VIA → VA

One underlying charcoal date followed by five archaeological charcoal dates.

VIB → VB

Nine underlying charcoal dates followed by eight archaeological charcoal dates and the disputed bone input.

These are parallel branches in the published model, both ending at the shared start of IV; they are followed by IV → IIIA → IIIB. “A” and “B” do not mean one branch necessarily preceded the other. The mapping file labels 62551 as VIc, while the model code places it in the VIA sequence.

Sigma boundaries allow tails of adjacent phase distributions to overlap. A start boundary describes the model’s phase distribution; it is not the directly measured date of the first person, earliest hearth or last visit.

BoundaryPublished S3 · 95% envelopePinned repository · 95% envelope
Natural sequence VIA · startVIA_st16,999.5–10,524.5 cal BP17,004.5–10,539.5 cal BP
Archaeological phase VA · startVA_st8,344.5–7,959.5 cal BP8,339.5–7,954.5 cal BP
Natural sequence VIB · startVIB_st13,479.5–10,019.5 cal BP13,424.5–10,004.5 cal BP
Archaeological phase VB · startVB_st8,714.5–8,249.5 cal BP8,709.5–8,244.5 cal BP
Phase IV · startIV_st7,919.5–7,764.5 cal BP7,919.5–7,764.5 cal BP
Phase IIIA · startIIIA_st7,829.5–7,734.5 cal BP7,829.5–7,734.5 cal BP
Phase IIIB · startIIIB_st7,789.5–7,499.5 cal BP7,789.5–7,499.5 cal BP
Phase IIIB · endIIIB_en7,039.5–3,469.5 cal BP7,044.5–3,449.5 cal BP

Table S3 negative values are retained. The repository analysis subtracts 1950 from the calendar-coordinate outputs. Positive calendar BP display reverses the signs and endpoint order; no recalibration is performed. Published 95% HDI endpoints are an outer envelope, not the full posterior shape. The approximately 8.5–7.5 ka occupation overview is not a single interval produced by joining the earliest and latest cells of this table. The very broad IIIB end boundary and mixed Phase II deposits leave the ending poorly constrained.

05 · Which landscape did people encounter?

Compare the coastlines before tracing a voyage.

The atlas still draws modern shores. The comparisons below describe published reconstructions, not a new bathymetric calculation or a measured route.

About 14,200 years ago · 2026 model

A modelled disconnection

Blinkhorn and colleagues combine GEBCO 2019 bathymetry with the Lambeck et al. sea-level reconstruction and place disconnection after about 14.2 ka.

This is model-dependent. It differs from the c.13 ka overview in the Latnija study; the two estimates are not bounds of one confidence interval.

About 13,000 years ago · 2025 overview

An alternative bridge chronology

The Latnija study describes submergence of the connection around 13 ka, well before its reported human occupation.

Retain this estimate separately from the 2026 model. Neither estimate directly dates a human journey.

Both estimates predate the reported occupation by several millennia. The 2026 reconstruction combines modern GEBCO bathymetry with a global sea-level curve; its geographical outputs are conditional on those inputs. Local uplift/subsidence, erosion and sediment accumulation need an explicit assessment before treating a reconstructed contour as a measured ancient shore.

06 · The steps in the argument

Arrival, travel and residence are different claims.

Archaeological observation and interpretation

People used the cave

Hearth structure, thermal alteration, knapped stone, animal remains and transported marine shells occur together in Phases V–III.

Limit: Burning alone is insufficient; the combined assemblage and sedimentary context carry the argument.

Published chronological interpretation

Use began around 8.5 ka

The paper combines charcoal, one bone result, stratigraphy and modelled boundaries to infer a pre-farming occupation.

Limit: The approximate overview is retained as the authors’ assessment. The ledger identifies unreconciled inputs; no independently reproduced or revised onset is claimed.

Geographical inference

People crossed open water

Both indexed bridge chronologies put separation well before the reported occupation. Sea travel follows from human presence on the separated island.

Limit: Sicily is the nearest plausible origin, but the precise departure place and route are not recovered. A land connection earlier in the Ice Age does not establish arrival at that earlier time.

Route estimate

A crossing around 100 km

The excavation study distinguishes today’s minimum straight-line separation (~85 km) from a plausible voyage of around 100 km influenced by currents, wind and navigation.

Limit: This is not a measured track or a fixed distance for every possible ancient route. Boat remains were not recovered; dugout canoes are proposed.

Conditional demographic model

Repeated contact may have sustained the occupation

The 2026 study uses reconstructed land area, productivity and ethnographic relationships to argue that continued contacts were required for long-term population viability.

Limit: Dependence on occupation duration, dietary models and viability thresholds must be tested. The record does not count voyages or prove uninterrupted residence.

07 · An open audit

Retain the disagreement with the evidence.

These are documented source differences and unresolved associations. They identify what needs checking; they are not a new rejection or independent confirmation of the published occupation chronology.

LAT-R01

Bone 71688: table and model differ by 2,000 radiocarbon years

Table S2 (printed p.53) reports 6100 ± 30 14C BP, with 5205–4910 cal BCE at printed 95%. The supplied code (printed p.76) and pinned repository both use 8100 ± 30. Table S3’s unmodelled calendar output is consistent with the older model input, not the S2 measurement. Preserve both; the laboratory certificate is needed to decide which is correct. No corrected result or sensitivity rerun is claimed. The April 2025 Cambridge supplement and Zenodo v0.2.0 archive retain the same discrepancy; the original certificate is still required.

LAT-R02

Charcoal 65865: 7367 versus 7376

Table S2 prints 7367 ± 19 14C BP; the supplied code and repository use 7376 ± 19. This smaller discrepancy also remains unresolved rather than being silently transposed. The April 2025 Cambridge supplement and Zenodo v0.2.0 archive retain the same discrepancy; the original certificate is still required.

LAT-R03

Outlier probabilities and model agreement are different diagnostics

The Table S3 caption says all posterior outlier probabilities are ≤0.05. Table S6 and the repository outlier file report 7% for 71688, 6% for 61846 and 8% for 54774. The latter two samples also have individual agreement indices below 60 in Table S3. These diagnostics do not automatically invalidate a sample, and an agreement index is not a probability that the history is true.

LAT-R04

Intraphase age spread needs an association audit

Phase VI includes widely separated charcoal ages; Phase III includes the relatively young 54779 (5510 ± 30 14C BP). These rows remain visible. The model uses flexible sigma boundaries and an outlier model; such flexibility does not establish that each dated fragment is primary deposition. Examine burrows, reworking and original sample positions before assigning individual dates to human actions.

LAT-R05

Repeated charcoal calibrations are not identical

Several charcoal specimens appear in both S2 and S5 with slightly different printed calendar endpoints. Both versions are retained under the same sample identifier. They are not additional measurements, and this ledger does not replace either with a new calibration.

LAT-R06

Model version, counts and calendar labels

S3 reports overall/model agreement 76.9/79.1; the pinned repository table gives 77.1/79.7 with small boundary differences. These are separate outputs, not a replication by this project. The inventory confirms 32 charcoal dates plus one bone date, although one Methods paragraph says 31 charcoal. The supplement also equates 6100–5700 cal BCE with ~7.7–7.1 ka; those labels do not agree arithmetically. Preserve printed calendar ranges rather than propagating that shorthand.

LAT-R07

The 2026 correction has a specific scope

The correction addresses uncertainties and boundary choices in the regional Mesolithic–Neolithic comparison, plus alternative classification of three Sicilian samples. It does not resolve the site-specific table/code discrepancies flagged here. The authors report that the regional correction does not materially change their pre-farming interpretation.

LAT-R08

Marine cross-checks share part of their calibration basis

The 49 shells are separate dated specimens. Their phase-specific ΔR values were estimated by comparison with charcoal using IntCal20 and Marine20, so the corrected calendar ages are partly dependent on the terrestrial chronology. Table S5 provides contexts but no excavation squares; no square is inferred from a neighbouring charcoal sample.

Scope and next evidence

What would strengthen this ledger?

Obtain original laboratory documentation for 71688 and 65865, the field sample register and full context-to-feature mapping. The field-records follow-up documents what is available and includes a prepared, unsent records request. Then reproduce the published model and compare explicitly labelled alternative inputs.

Table S2 (38 attempts: 33 numeric, five failed), Table S5 (49 shells and 14 repeated charcoal comparisons), S3/S4/S6/S13 and site model input/output. Earlier unsuccessful 2019 bone attempts are mentioned but not individually tabulated in these records.

Primary-source transcription with page-image checks; source conflicts retained; no independent dating-model rerun. The reviewed model revision is 09412a80ec4a. Source and access record ↗

Return to the Latnija dossier → · Next: early farming at Santa Verna →