PUBLIC RESEARCH PREVIEW Research in progress · uncertainties and source access are recorded throughout.

SITE-026 · 2026-10-28

Latnija

About 8,500–7,500 cal BP · occupation overview

MaltaGozoFirst peoplearchaeologysea level
Working research. Assessments and source-access limitations are retained from the research record. This entry has not completed its public-release review.

What has been found

Limestone flakes, hearths, ash deposits, wild fauna and collected marine shells occur in archaeological Phases V–III. Phase VI is the underlying natural deposit. A Phase III pit cuts Phase IV and truncates the top of V; the sequence is not a simple stack of undisturbed layers. Basal hearth evidence includes ash over thermally altered substrate supported by micromorphology; FTIR results vary across analytical sampling zones. [S80 · Scerri et al. (2025)] [S106 · Scerri et al. (2025)]

How the date connects

The sample-to-layer ledger records 32 charcoal dates, one successful bone date, 49 marine-shell dates and five failed bone attempts. Fourteen charcoal specimens repeated in Table S5 remain single records. Squares and numbered contexts are retained; the tables do not give every sample’s precise position or its relationship to an individual hearth. [S106 · Scerri et al. (2025)]

Shell ages use phase-specific marine reservoir corrections estimated from charcoal comparisons. They provide additional evidence with a shared calibration dependency. Raw radiocarbon ages, calibrated BCE envelopes and modelled calendar BP remain separate. [S106 · Scerri et al. (2025)]

Two input differences require resolution: bone specimen 71688 is 6,100 ± 30 radiocarbon BP in Table S2 but 8,100 ± 30 in the model; charcoal 65865 is 7,367 ± 19 in Table S2 but 7,376 ± 19 in the model. Neither value is silently corrected. Published S3 outputs and the pinned repository outputs are retained as separate versions. The model has not been independently rerun. [S106 · Scerri et al. (2025)] [S110 · Carleton and collaborators. Latnija analysis repository, pinned revision 09412a80ec4a1e…]

The January 2026 correction concerns the regional Mesolithic–Neolithic comparison. The authors report no material change to their pre-Neolithic interpretation. It does not resolve these site-input discrepancies. [S81 · Scerri et al. (2026)]

Reasonable inference

The authors interpret the assemblage as a pre-farming presence beginning around 8,500 years ago. Both indexed land-bridge reconstructions put Malta’s separation from Sicily several millennia earlier, supporting a sea-crossing inference. They do not identify a vessel or establish a particular route. [S80 · Scerri et al. (2025)] [S109 · Blinkhorn et al. (2026)]

What remains uncertain

The approximately 8,500–7,500 cal BP overview is not one model confidence interval. The ending is poorly constrained. Older underlying charcoal is not automatically an older occupation. Continuous residence, number of voyages, boat construction and ancestry of the occupants remain separate questions. [S80 · Scerri et al. (2025)] [S106 · Scerri et al. (2025)] [S109 · Blinkhorn et al. (2026)] [S110 · Carleton and collaborators. Latnija analysis repository, pinned revision 09412a80ec4a1e…]

Field-record follow-up

The field-records audit indexes seven context correlations from the published Harris matrix, 24 mineral-analysis samples from the basal hearth and wood identifications for ten dated charcoal specimens. Analytical sample numbers remain distinct from radiocarbon laboratory IDs. The original supplement and both archived model releases retain the disputed inputs; neither supplies the original certificates. [S80 · Scerri et al. (2025)] [S106 · Scerri et al. (2025)] [S111 · Scerri et al. (2025)] [S113 · Carleton, mesoneomalta archived releases: v0.2.0 and v1.0.0.]

The reporting form and investigator account document the creation of context sheets, plans, photographs and sample databases. A 2026 faunal preprint supplies a partial spatial archive, but the inspected CSVs do not provide the laboratory-ID crosswalk needed to locate dated fragments within individual hearths. That archive remains labelled as preprint evidence. A specific records request is prepared and has not been sent. [S112 · Scerri et al. (2025)] [S115 · Mata-González et al. (2026)] [S116 · Scerri (9 April 2025)]

Next evidence check

Obtain the original laboratory documentation for 71688 and 65865 and the field sample/context register. Establish which dated specimens directly belong to individual hearths, pit fills or redeposited ash. Reproduce the published model before testing explicitly labelled alternatives. [S106 · Scerri et al. (2025)] [S110 · Carleton and collaborators. Latnija analysis repository, pinned revision 09412a80ec4a1e…]

Published-record audit completed: Read the occupation audit and sample ledger. It preserves 82 distinct dated samples, five failed bone attempts, shared charcoal/shell dependencies and two unresolved table-to-model input disagreements. Repeated activity remains distinguishable from continuous residence; no occupation season or voyage frequency is assigned.

Origins and motives comparison completed: Read the paired investigation. Resource use offers the strongest working explanation for visits; source-region pressure, original motive and homeland remain unresolved. The next tests are context-linked seasonality and sourcing of the Phase III chert core. Sicily is a research priority, not an assigned origin. [S323 · Mata-González et al. (2026); S324 · Yu et al. (2022); S326 · Di Maida et al. (2019); S328 · Lipson et al. (2025)]

Deer comparison completed: Compare Latnija with Sicily. Deer food use is supported at both places; relative hunting returns remain unresolved. Older metric comparators, preservation and a source-model input discrepancy prevent a simple claim of superior Maltese hunting. Next: context-linked deer and seasonal evidence. [S323 · Mata-González et al. (2026); S330 · Mata-González et al. (2026); S331 · Mannino et al. (2015); S332 · Tagliacozzo (2005)]

The published 8,500–7,500 cal BP overview remains attributed to the authors; it has not been independently recalculated or used to date every sample.

Explore the dated samples and open review notes · Return to Malta · Sea level and past coastlines · Locate this record