What this round establishes
Latnija records repeated human activity, while year-round residence and voyage frequency remain unresolved. The published approximate occupation overview of 8,500–7,500 cal BP is retained as an attributed interpretation. This audit does not recalculate the first arrival, identify one continuous population, or count visits from dates.
Review LAT-OCC-001, October 28, 2026. The ledger connects 33 dated charcoal/bone records and five failed bone attempts to their published contexts and model inputs. It separately records 49 shell dates. Fourteen charcoal rows reused in the shell comparison are references to existing samples, not additional dates. The result is 82 distinct dated samples, not 82 occupation events. [S80 · Scerri et al. (2025); S106 · Scerri et al. (2025); S321 · Carleton et al. Latnija and regional Mesolithic–Neolithic chronology: code, sample map …]
From sediment to activity
| Published phase | Dated charcoal/bone records | Shell dates | What the association supports |
|---|---|---|---|
| VI | 10 | 0 in this table | Underlying cave-floor deposits with sparse charcoal. Old charcoal here does not independently establish older human occupation. |
| V | 14 | 22 | Combustion-rich archaeological deposits. In-situ burning is supported at the N2 feature; other parts include locally reworked ash. Phase membership alone is not a unique hearth assignment. |
| IV | 2 | 3 | Archaeological material within deposits associated with cave-wall collapse. |
| III | 7 | 24 | A cut-and-fill feature with shell and ash dumps. The date of burning or organism death need not equal the time material entered the pit. |
These are formation contexts, not four uniform blocks of continuous residence. The lower model also separates two stratigraphic branches, VIA–VA and VIB–VB; they are not two independently demonstrated colonizations. [S80; S106, sections 2 and 4; S321]
Two input disagreements remain explicit
| Sample number as printed | Table S2: conventional radiocarbon BP | Published model code: radiocarbon BP | Treatment |
|---|---|---|---|
| 71688, bone, context 143 | 6,100 ± 30 | 8,100 ± 30 | LAT-DATE-001: retain both; no corrected value selected. |
| 65865, charcoal, context 177 | 7,367 ± 19 | 7,376 ± 19 | LAT-DATE-002: retain both; no corrected value selected. |
The table and script values were checked against the rendered supplement and the authors’ repository. The first disagreement is 2,000 radiocarbon years; the second is nine. These are differences between published inputs, not estimates of how far the occupation chronology would move. Laboratory documentation and a controlled model rerun would be needed to establish the correct inputs and their consequences. No new arrival date follows from this audit.1
The January 2026 correction addresses uncertainties and boundary choices in the regional Mesolithic–Neolithic comparison. It does not settle these two site-input disagreements. The authors report that the regional correction leaves their pre-Neolithic interpretation intact. [S81 · Scerri et al. (2026)]
The original table’s laboratory heading is retained literally. The main methods attribute bone analysis to CAIS, so a number under the table’s “MAMS” heading is not independent verification of the originating laboratory. [S80 · Scerri et al. (2025); S106 · Scerri et al. (2025)]
Shells support the sequence, with shared dependencies
The shell analysis offers a different material and a useful check on the deposits. Its reservoir adjustments are estimated using charcoal from associated contexts, so the resulting shell chronology is not wholly independent of that charcoal. Published phase adjustments are retained: III, 64.2 ± 64.8 years; IV, 9.5 ± 111.5; V, −57.3 ± 128.6. These are reservoir-model quantities, not occupation dates. [S80 methods; S106 Tables S4–S5]
The ledger preserves individual shell measurements and the printed 95% calibrated BC ranges. It does not turn those ranges into continuous probability distributions or reconstruct unreported sample-exclusion decisions. Likewise, many shells within one dumping context do not demonstrate many separate visits.
Residence, seasonality and overseas contact
Residence: the late boundary remains difficult to constrain, particularly because the overlying Phase II deposits contain mixed material. The published model’s terminal boundary is broad. The evidence does not decide between seasonal use, separate extended stays, and sustained residence with outside contact. [S106, section 4; S321]
Seasonality: the original supplement explicitly leaves seasonal versus year-round exploitation open. A newly indexed 2024 dissertation abstract reports seasonal marine-resource exploitation, but its full text is restricted and was not inspected. That is a specific lead for further evidence; it does not yet let this repository assign an occupation season. Seasonal harvesting of one species would also not, by itself, prove the site was abandoned during the rest of the year. [S106, section 1.5; S322]
The 2026 population argument: the study combines terrestrial environmental productivity, exposed land area and ethnographic population-density relationships. It explores coastal distance and fishing-diet subsets as indirect marine-resource proxies; it does not directly model marine productivity. Its supported census population estimates must also be distinguished from genetic effective-population thresholds. The authors allow seasonal exploitation or separate extended occupations. These model comparisons support a case for repeated contact under their assumptions; they do not identify the travelers’ homeland or recover a voyage schedule. Published alternatives were examined here; no demographic or climate model was rerun. [S109 · Blinkhorn et al. (2026)]
Follow-up: where might the travelers have come from?
The initial origins and motives comparison is now complete. It follows the research order below, conditional on the contact interpretation. It will distinguish immediate departure coast, wider contact network, and biological ancestry.
| Candidate or lead | Why investigate it | Evidence needed before assigning an origin |
|---|---|---|
| Sicily first | The original study treats Sicily as the most parsimonious source. Southern coasts are departure candidates. | Contemporary communities, dated technological or material links, and feasible routes; proximity alone is insufficient. |
| The single Phase III chert core | Its geological source is reported as unknown. | A defensible source identification could establish movement of material; it would not alone identify the ancestry of its carrier. |
| Sardinian comparisons | The authors note similarities in expedient lithic technology. | Test shared practice against convergence caused by raw-material properties; resemblance alone does not demonstrate migration. |
| North Africa and the wider central Mediterranean | A possible broader network merits comparison. | Securely dated contact or mobility evidence, while keeping indirect connections distinct from direct voyages to Malta. |
This is a research order, not a ranked probability estimate or a reconstructed migration route. No source population is assigned. The follow-up comparison retains those limits and prioritizes context-linked seasonality and material sourcing. [S80 · Scerri et al. (2025); S106 · Scerri et al. (2025); S109 · Blinkhorn et al. (2026)]
Sources, versions and limits
- S80: Scerri et al. 2025, main article, updated version; occupation, excavation and dating methods.
- S106: Published supplement, sections 1.5, 2, 4 and 5; Tables S2–S5 and site model script. PDF pages 53–54, 58–61 and 77 visually checked. PDF page numbers are one higher than printed pages.
- S81: January 2026 author correction, regional chronology scope preserved.
- S321: Authors’ code and model outputs, pinned commit. Current output values differ slightly from printed Table S3 and are stored as a separate version. Signed exported age coordinates are retained with their units, not relabeled as conventional radiocarbon BP.
- S109: Blinkhorn et al. 2026, model methods and discussion, including its seasonal/discontinuous alternatives.
- S322: Mifsud 2024 dissertation record, abstract only; full dissertation restricted.
Canonical observations, source-file hashes and unresolved fields are in research/data/latnija/occupation-audit.json. No laboratory certificates, author clarification, newly calibrated ages or new site measurements were obtained. This completes the defined published-record audit; numerical sensitivity to corrected inputs remains future work, and the origins investigation proceeds conditionally.
Footnotes
-
Table S2 and model-code disagreement, checked October 28, 2026. Neither alternative is adopted as correct. The published approximate occupation overview is retained as a source attribution, not independently revalidated by this audit. These flags remain open while other research proceeds. ↩