PUBLIC RESEARCH PREVIEW Research in progress · uncertainties and source access are recorded throughout.

Santa Elina · Evidence ledger

The object.
The layer. The date.

Three proposed bone ornaments, the Unit III dating context and the 35 published model-input measurements. No ornament was directly dated in the studies reviewed here.

Working transcription · no new dating model

Primary-source transcription; independent review and model reproduction pending. Conventional radiocarbon BP, calibrated calendar BP and luminescence ka remain separate. A dated deposit does not by itself establish human manufacture.

01 · Identifiable finds

Start with the object.

SEI6059 · modified osteoderm

Flattened and polished, with two broken perforations at opposite margins. Rodent marks also occur. The combination of traces, rather than a hole alone, supports the authors’ human-working interpretation. Main paper Fig. 3; supplement Fig. S13.

SEI6557 · modified osteoderm

A perforation with an elongated groove and wear interpreted as repeated contact with a fastening. Attachment and ornament use are interpretations, not recovered string. Main paper Fig. 4; supplement Fig. S12.

SEI6386 · modified osteoderm

Perforation and localized V-shaped wear interpreted as suspension. Main paper Fig. 5; supplement Fig. S11.

02 · Relative position

Read down the sequence.

A schematic order, from higher to lower contexts. Band heights do not represent thickness, duration or excavated distances. No continuous occupation is implied.

  1. Unit II · above the early context

    Later occupation and dating contexts. These do not directly date the three Unit III objects.

  2. Unit III(2) · wood-bearing deposit

    Waterlogged wood samples Gif-9365 and Gif-9366, reported at 2.70 m in squares 21–22B. Depositional constraints; wood is not automatically a human-made object.

  3. Unit III(4) · object-bearing context

    All three proposed ornaments are attributed to this unit. Published find positions: 23A, z = 323 cm; 27A, z = 319 cm; 28A, z = 306 cm. The reviewed material does not securely map each position to an individual artifact ID; no one-to-one assignment is invented here. The supplement lists 338 stone objects for Unit III; its precise spatial comparison uses 85 stone tools and 309 non-osteoderm bones. These are different datasets, not interchangeable counts.

  4. Unit IV · below the archaeological context

    UW609 dates sediment beneath Unit III. It constrains the sequence and is not evidence of human activity in Unit IV.

03 · Sample to context

What was actually measured?

7 focused sample records. Each calibrated segment retains its printed probability; gaps between segments are not filled. Alternative analyses under an OSL sample are not additional independent samples.

Sample / sourceMaterial & layerMeasurementPublished calibration / alternativesRelationship to the object
UW609Table S1quartzIV27,800 ± 2,700 years (published)OSL · Published lab error; not a calibrated intervalNo separate calendar calibration transcribed for this entry.Below the archaeological context; sediment constraint only.
Th/U SE9402Table S1bone(osteoderm)III (4)27,000 ± 2,000 years (published)U/Th · Published lab error; not a calibrated intervalNo separate calendar calibration transcribed for this entry.Same published unit as the ornaments; not an assay of an identified ornament. Osteoderms at about 3 m, square 26C (2017); this ID is not one of the three ornament IDs.
UW465Table S1quartzIII (4)25,100 ± 2,500 years (published)OSL · Published lab error; not a calibrated intervalNo separate calendar calibration transcribed for this entry.Same published unit as the ornaments; not an assay of an identified ornament. Quartz at 296–300 cm in the eastern section (2017).
Gif-9365Table S1woodIII (2)23,320 ± 1,000 14C BPC14 · Published lab error; not a calibrated intervalNo separate calendar calibration transcribed for this entry.Wood above III(4); growth/deposition may differ from human activity.
GIFA 99177Table S1microcharcoalIII (4)23,120 ± 260 14C BPC14 · Published lab error; not a calibrated interval
27,818–26,887 cal BP (95.4%)
2017: OxCal 4.3 / IntCal13; separate from the 2023 SHCal20 model
Same published unit as the ornaments; not an assay of an identified ornament. Microcharcoal at 3.03 m in a thin ash deposit (2017); burning need not have been human-caused.Published aliases: Gif-99177 / GIFA-99177
Gif-9366Table S1woodIII (2)22,500 ± 500 14C BPC14 · Published lab error; not a calibrated intervalNo separate calendar calibration transcribed for this entry.Wood above III(4); growth/deposition may differ from human activity.
UW4622017 dating sectionquartzIII (4)22,500 ± 1,500 years (published)OSL · Published ±No separate calendar calibration transcribed for this entry.Reported with the III(4) sediment sampling in 2017; not included in 2023 Table S1. Do not add it to the published 35-input model without rerunning that model.
29 later-context inputs from Table S1

The published model uses the entire sequence. These rows preserve its later inputs; they do not independently date the Unit III ornaments. Together with the first six focused S77 entries, these comprise the 35-row Table S1. UW462 is a separate 2017 entry.

LabMaterialUnitRaw measurementMethod
UW464quartzII (3)18,700 ± 900 years (published)OSL · S77, Table S1
Th/U SE 9404bone(osteoderm)II (2)13,000 ± 1,000 years (published)U/Th · S77, Table S1
Gif-8954charcoalII (2)10,120 ± 60 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif/LSM-11121charcoalII (2)9,790 ± 20 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif/LSM-10683charcoalII (2)9,340 ± 20 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-9368charcoalII (1)7,050 ± 55 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-9369charcoalII7,010 ± 70 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-7880charcoalI6,060 ± 80 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-7054charcoalI6,040 ± 70 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-7881charcoalI5,920 ± 70 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-7882charcoalI5,890 ± 70 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-8679charcoalI5,890 ± 70 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-9370charcoalI5,860 ± 60 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-7085charcoalI5,660 ± 60 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-7983charcoalI5,110 ± 230 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-7883charcoalI5,080 ± 230 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
GIF-7379charcoalI3,970 ± 60 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-8822charcoalI3,600 ± 60 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif11124charcoalI3,560 ± 50 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-9693charcoalI3,530 ± 50 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-7086charcoalI2,990 ± 60 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-10356charcoalI2,660 ± 50 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-7758charcoalI2,600 ± 60 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-7380charcoalI2,350 ± 60 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-7879charcoalI2,310 ± 70 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-10537charcoalI1,890 ± 20 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-9692charcoalI1,770 ± 60 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-8955corn cobI400 ± 50 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1
Gif-8890stakeI275 ± 40 14C BPC14 · S77, Table S1

04 · Conditional chronology

Keep the model separate.

Unit III begins · 28,743–26,536 cal BP · 95.4%

Published OxCal 4.4 / SHCal20 boundary, based on the sequence and 35 measurements. The 68.3% interval is 27,942–27,185 cal BP. This is a modelled boundary, not the manufacture interval of each ornament. The reported agreement index of 101.9% is not a probability that the interpretation is true.

05 · An open audit

Unresolved does not mean erased.

These notes distinguish reporting discrepancies from objections to the archaeological interpretation. None is silently repaired, and none alone decides whether people made the objects.

Conflicting model summaries

Table S2 prints Unit III end as 27,225–25,225 cal BP (95.4%) and 26,230–26,230 (68.3%); supplementary narrative instead gives 27,574–25,225 and 27,253–26,230. Unit II start ends at 16,880 in Table S2 and the main text, versus 16,850 in the supplement narrative. Preserve both versions; do not plot these disputed boundaries as settled results.

Input list and outline need reconciliation

Table S1 assigns the wood to III(2), whereas the supplied OxCal outline names a III(3) phase. The outline contains placeholders rather than the full numerical model. A complete executable input and output are needed for reproduction. UW462 appears in the 2017 report but is absent from the 35-row Table S1.

Published uncertainty and calibration history

UW465 is 25,100 ± 2,500 years in 2017 and Table S1, but the 2023 main narrative abbreviates its error to ±2 ka. The 2017 text repeats 27,818–26,887 cal BP for Gif-9365 and GIFA-99177 despite different raw measurements. This ledger retains the raw ages; no replacement calibration has been calculated.

What would strengthen the association?

Check original field registers for object-ID-to-position mapping and dating-sample coordinates. Osteoderms with imprecise positions were excluded from the precise tool–bone spatial analysis. Spatial proximity does not identify the tool that made a particular mark.

Human manufacture versus natural damage

Costopoulos (2023, scholarly blog commentary) asks whether rare natural lesions could account for three selected objects in a large assemblage, and calls for stronger perforation-wall comparisons. S77 already supplies FR3A/FR6 images and an 80-osteoderm survey; the open question is their diagnostic adequacy. This critique does not demonstrate a natural origin.

Do not conflate the experimental controls

S77 Text S6, PDF p.7: modern dry armadillo UFCAT-MAM 1/6 was polished without drilling; fossil sloth SEI8004 was drilled and polished. The commentary describes drilling modern osteoderms. Preserve the primary protocol. Experimental similarity establishes plausibility, not exclusive human causation.

Tooth bioapatite and converted estimates are different results

S186 publisher abstract: Unit III4 tooth bioapatite gives a reported minimum of 22,339–22,534 cal a BP; the authors’ conversion yields 22,042 ± 40 conventional 14C BP, calibrated to 25,994–26,396 cal a BP. Unit II2 gives 14,944–15,239 cal a BP minimum and a converted 14,547 ± 40 conventional 14C BP / 17,450–17,906 cal a BP. These are not four independent assays or extracted-collagen measurements. Full methods, IDs and confidence conventions remain unverified; neither tooth dates ornament manufacture.

Possible burning: later Unit II, preliminary report

The October 2026 PB-86 conference abstract reports heat indicators in a Unit II osteoderm and rib, concluding possible burning that could be human-caused at approximately 13 kya BP. No precise calibrated range or specimen-to-hearth ledger is provided there. Do not assign this to the Unit III ornaments or infer cooking, hunting or deliberate fire from dark colour alone.

Continue the comparison

Examine the worked stone at Vale da Pedra Furada →