PUBLIC RESEARCH PREVIEW Research in progress · uncertainties and source access are recorded throughout.

Vale da Pedra Furada · Evidence ledger

The object.
The layer. The date.

Object 255660, six published C7 charcoal entries, four C7 luminescence samples and two underlying C8 charcoal entries. This is a focused C7 ledger, not a complete transcription of the deeper sequence.

Working transcription · no new dating model

Primary-source transcription; independent review and model reproduction pending. Conventional radiocarbon BP, calibrated calendar BP and luminescence ka remain separate. A dated deposit does not by itself establish human manufacture.

01 · Identifiable finds

Start with the object.

255660 · shaped sandstone

Silty/silicified sandstone plate, 21.0 × 18.5 × 2.9 cm maximum dimensions, found flat in C7γ-a at about 2.5 m depth. The authors reconstruct five shaping stages from overlapping removals, bevels and notches. Edge wear differs between stages. Their proposed hafting and hoe/shovel comparisons do not establish a recovered handle, exact function or agriculture. In the proposed sequence, earlier worked edges are blunted, later adjacent notches are fresher, and a final asymmetric projection carries grooves. Those contrasts underpin the inferred order and reuse; their functional meaning remains uncertain.

02 · Relative position

Read down the sequence.

A schematic order, from higher to lower contexts. Band heights do not represent thickness, duration or excavated distances. No continuous occupation is implied.

  1. C7α · above C7β

    Three multi-grain OSL samples and three charcoal samples are assigned here in the supplementary tables. Single-grain analyses of two of those OSL samples are alternative analyses of the same sediment samples.

  2. C7β · above C7γ

    One charcoal entry. The main text’s OSL layer description conflicts with Table S2; see the review register.

  3. C7γ-a · object-bearing horizon

    Object 255660 is assigned to C7γ-a. Table S1 prints the two charcoal layer labels as C7γα; Table S2 assigns BR2012-13 only to C7γ. These labels do not provide exact sample-to-object distances.

  4. Current C8 · below C7

    Two charcoal dates constrain the underlying sequence. The older publication’s layer called C8 is not the present C8; it must not be joined by name alone. C10′ is from a separate sector without stratigraphic contact and is not a direct bracket for object 255660.

03 · Sample to context

What was actually measured?

12 focused sample records. Each calibrated segment retains its printed probability; gaps between segments are not filled. Alternative analyses under an OSL sample are not additional independent samples.

Sample / sourceMaterial & layerMeasurementPublished calibration / alternativesRelationship to the object
SacA28290FUMDHAM 192452
Gif-12837
S1 Table
charcoalC7α19,970 ± 100 14C BP14C · 1σ; calibration is published 2σ
24,201–23,790 cal BP (95.4%)
SHCal20 / ChronoModel; segment probabilities as printed
Published C7 association; not a date on the stone or proof of human burning.
SacA28289FUMDHAM 192455
Gif-12836
S1 Table
charcoalC7α20,070 ± 100 14C BP14C · 1σ; calibration is published 2σ
24,265–23,824 cal BP (95.4%)
SHCal20 / ChronoModel; segment probabilities as printed
Published C7 association; not a date on the stone or proof of human burning.
SacA25554FUMDHAM 192448
Gif-12706
S1 Table
charcoalC7α20,090 ± 120 14C BP14C · 1σ; calibration is published 2σ
24,406–24,396 cal BP (0.2%)
24,375–23,802 cal BP (95.2%)
SHCal20 / ChronoModel; segment probabilities as printed
Published C7 association; not a date on the stone or proof of human burning.
SacA37773FUMDHAM 236687
Gif-13100
S1 Table
charcoalC7β19,990 ± 110 14C BP14C · 1σ; calibration is published 2σ
24,226–23,792 cal BP (95.4%)
SHCal20 / ChronoModel; segment probabilities as printed
Published C7 association; not a date on the stone or proof of human burning.
SacA30852FUMDHAM 232097
Gif-12923
S1 Table
charcoalC7γα19,700 ± 100 14C BP14C · 1σ; calibration is published 2σ
23,870–23,662 cal BP (41.5%)
23,642–23,337 cal BP (53.9%)
SHCal20 / ChronoModel; segment probabilities as printed
Published C7 association; not a date on the stone or proof of human burning.
ECHo 2241FUMDHAM 258120
GifA-18152
S1 Table
charcoalC7γα19,180 ± 120 14C BP14C · 1σ; calibration is published 2σ
23,710–23,580 cal BP (5.6%)
23,386–22,872 cal BP (89.9%)
SHCal20 / ChronoModel; segment probabilities as printed
Published C7 association; not a date on the stone or proof of human burning.
SacA37774FUMDHAM 237199
Gif-13101
S1 Table
charcoalC829,820 ± 310 14C BP14C · 1σ; calibration is published 2σ
35,036–35,004 cal BP (0.3%)
34,920–33,639 cal BP (95.1%)
SHCal20 / ChronoModel; segment probabilities as printed
Underlying C8 sequence constraint.
ECHo 2243FUMDHAM 258202
GifA-18154
S1 Table
charcoalC829,880 ± 350 14C BP14C · 1σ; calibration is published 2σ
35,166–33,692 cal BP (95.4%)
SHCal20 / ChronoModel; segment probabilities as printed
Underlying C8 sequence constraint.
BR2011-14S2–S3 Tablesquartz sedimentC7α27.6 ± 2.8 kaMG-OSL CAM · σ as publishedNo separate calendar calibration transcribed for this entry.Sediment luminescence age; not manufacture. Layer label follows S2 Table.
BR2011-15S2–S3 Tablesquartz sedimentC7α23.7 ± 2.6 kaMG-OSL CAM · σ as published
SG-OSL CAM: 20.8 ± 2.4 kaSame sediment sample; not independent evidence
SG-OSL BaSAR: 21 ± 1.9 kaSame sediment sample; not independent evidence
Sediment luminescence age; not manufacture. Layer label follows S2 Table.
BR2011-32S2–S3 Tablesquartz sedimentC7α23.4 ± 2.8 kaMG-OSL CAM · σ as published
SG-OSL CAM: 24.7 ± 2 kaSame sediment sample; not independent evidence
SG-OSL BaSAR: 23 ± 1.9 kaSame sediment sample; not independent evidence
Sediment luminescence age; not manufacture. Layer label follows S2 Table.
BR2012-13S2–S3 Tablesquartz sedimentC7γ26.5 ± 2.8 kaMG-OSL CAM · σ as publishedNo separate calendar calibration transcribed for this entry.Sediment luminescence age; not manufacture. Layer label follows S2 Table.

04 · Conditional chronology

Keep the model separate.

C7γ · 27,615–24,071 cal BP · 80%

S5 Table’s phase time range. Begin/end maximum-a-posteriori summaries are 25.0 and 24.5 ka cal BP. These are distinct model summaries, not direct dates on the stone. The main-text rounded 27,600–24,000 range is retained as reporting history; the atlas now identifies the exact supplementary interval and its 80% convention.

05 · An open audit

Unresolved does not mean erased.

These notes distinguish reporting discrepancies from objections to the archaeological interpretation. None is silently repaired, and none alone decides whether people made the objects.

Layer and sample-count discrepancies

The main text describes four C7 OSL samples as three in α and one in β; Table S2 instead puts BR2012-13 in γ. The narrative mentions seven C7 charcoal samples, but Table S1 contains six C7 rows, including two labelled C7γα. Do not invent a seventh result or silently relabel the OSL sample.

Calibration versus phase model

The unmodelled C7γα calibrated ranges extend younger than the modelled C7γ phase range. They are shown separately. Reproducing the model and checking event assignments is necessary to explain the relationship; the phase cannot simply replace each sample’s measurement.

Other input-table inconsistencies

Outside the focused ledger, Table S1 gives sample 209523 / SacA37775 a median of 5,512 cal BP but ranges 7,536–7,398 and 7,333–7,278; sample 192047 / SacA25552 has median 8,623 but all listed ranges fall between 10,922 and 10,409. Both medians lie outside their printed ranges. These are unresolved publication discrepancies, not corrected dates. Check author/laboratory records before reproducing the full model.

Test the specific object

Independent inspection should test the scar sequence, fracture surfaces and wear against local rockfall and percussion controls. Regional critiques discuss geological context, selection criteria and capuchin activity; they are not a demonstrated reconstruction of how object 255660 formed. Matching production flakes and securely diagnostic use-wear would strengthen the case.

Continue the comparison

Examine the modified bone at Santa Elina →