PUBLIC RESEARCH PREVIEW Research in progress · uncertainties and source access are recorded throughout.

SITE-050 · 2026-10-30

Page-Ladson

Animal-resource use · approximately 14,550 cal BP

mastodonstone toolsunderwater archaeologyradiocarbon
Working research. Assessments and source-access limitations are retained from the research record. This entry has not completed its public-release review.

Dating and context

Halligan et al. date Unit 3c tools to approximately 14,550 cal BP using associated wood, not the stone itself. [S27 · Halligan et al. (2016)]

FindPublished relationship
Biface 12080-1Main paper reports seven adjacent dates; register distinguishes above/below/beside/level relationships, including older material
Flake 12242-1Two associated wood dates; screen-recovered find with inferred collection context
Modified tusk, recovered 1993Attributed to Unit 3c; not one of the newly excavated tools

The paper’s 71 wood dates concern the broader stratigraphy, not 71 independent dates on one human action. All 42 excavation measurements in Tables S3/S4 are now image-checked and indexed; the 29 core dates are outside this register. [S27 · Halligan et al. (2016)]

A resource-use episode

Tusk grooves are interpreted as working during extraction. Butchery or scavenging is supported; a kill, typical menu and permanent settlement are not demonstrated. The pond-edge setting differs from today’s submerged site. [S27 · Halligan et al. (2016)]

Next checks and atlas coverage

Next obtain the original OxCal commands and output to resolve the exclusion-count discrepancy and test sensitivity to the retained discordant pair. The atlas uses a rounded contextual point, not zero uncertainty. Later Unit 4 artifacts remain distinct. Compare daily life.

Original sample relationships

The original excavation register preserves Tables S3/S4, including older wood and bark. Its Figure S12 audit joins all 37 samples from 50N/23E: eight are marked excluded and 29 appear as retained, individually or combined. Section 2.4 says nine were removed. No ninth laboratory ID is inferred. The extra Table S3 row, UCIAMS-153343, is from 50N/22E and is not evidence of an additional outlier. [S195 · Halligan et al. (2016)]

Among seven biface-related results, 127305 (bark) and 141950 (bald-cypress wood) are marked excluded. The other five appear as 141949, combined 127302/127304 and combined 127303/141951. Several cypress twigs remain in the model; the exclusions are not a blanket rejection of that species. Older plant material can predate deposition and does not independently demonstrate earlier tool use. [S195 · Halligan et al. (2016)]

UCIAMS-141934 and 141935 remain combined despite the authors’ reported failed chi-square test. Published model agreement is not a probability that the chronology is correct. We have inspected the publication, not rerun the model or inspected original certificates. The approximately 14,550 cal BP assessment remains attributed to the authors; this audit supplies no replacement date. [S195 · Halligan et al. (2016)]

Field-context precision

The biface was recovered in situ, but §1.3 gives its northing as 50.23 while Table S10 gives 50.32; both give E23.22 and 10.84 m below datum. Preserve both until the original records resolve the difference. [S195 · Halligan et al. (2016)]

Flake 12242-1 was found in the screen while a roughly 10 × 15 cm corner was excavated. The authors describe cleaning, unchanged diver/hose positions and a restricted excavation area as reasons to trust its context. Its tabulated coordinates represent that inferred context, not a directly observed in-situ artifact point. Samples were taken at the top/bottom of the excavated level, but Table S4 lists both near-flake measurements at depth 10.78; a lab-ID-to-upper/lower assignment remains unlinked. [S195 · Halligan et al. (2016)]

Atlas/globe coverage checked: AT-PL-3C retains its contextual estimate with these limitations. Excluded older wood and later Unit 4 samples do not receive the Unit 3c human-activity date. No new traditions evidence arose in this check.