PUBLIC RESEARCH PREVIEW Research in progress · uncertainties and source access are recorded throughout.

Ohalo II · Page-Ladson · Paisley Caves

A date needs
a context.

53 selected measurements, with the links to floors, tools and dietary specimens made explicit.

Publication checks · laboratory audit incomplete.

Page-Ladson Tables S3/S4/S10 and Figure S12 inspected in the original PDF; Ohalo II and Paisley rows remain provisional indexed-text transcriptions. Original laboratory certificates have not been inspected. Missing joins remain open; no new calibration or occupation model is introduced.

Original Figure S12 checked · 2026-10-30

Eight marked. Nine reported.

Original supplement ↗

Eight question-marked samples can be matched to the table: seven bald-cypress wood samples and one bark sample. The figure accounts for all 37 samples from 50N/23E: eight marked excluded and 29 retained individually or in combinations. Section 2.4 instead says nine were removed. This is a publication-level mismatch; no ninth ID is invented.

Marked excludedMaterial / layerDepth below datumRadiocarbon BP ±
UCIAMS-141947Bald cypress woodUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.70 m below datum13,440 ± 40
UCIAMS-127305Unknown periderm barkUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.84 m below datum13,015 ± 30
UCIAMS-141950Bald cypress woodUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.85 m below datum13,830 ± 35
UCIAMS-141953Bald cypress woodUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.95 m below datum14,510 ± 40
UCIAMS-141954Bald cypress woodUnit 3c · 50N/23E11.00 m below datum13,005 ± 35
UCIAMS-141955Bald cypress woodUnit 3c · 50N/23E11.05 m below datum13,585 ± 35
UCIAMS-141960Bald cypress woodUnit 3a · 50N/23E11.35 m below datum13,945 ± 50
UCIAMS-141961Bald cypress woodUnit 3a · 50N/23E11.48 m below datum13,080 ± 40

Of the seven biface-related assays, five enter the displayed model: 141949 individually, 127302/127304 combined, and 127303/141951 combined. Bark 127305 and cypress 141950 are marked excluded. These are associated plant remains, not seven independent direct dates on a human action.

What this changes

The visual audit clarifies the published approximately 14,550 cal BP interpretation; it does not independently reproduce it or supply a replacement age. Larger, older wood may predate deposition or have been redeposited. Several bald-cypress twigs remain in the model, so exclusion was not simply a rule against that species.

The retained pair and reproducibility check

UCIAMS-141934 (12,365 ± 30) and 141935 (12,250 ± 35 radiocarbon BP) remain combined. The authors report a failed chi-square test but retain the combination with agreement 89.6. Their reported model/overall agreement values are 123.3/126.1; these are not percentages of certainty.

Recover the original OxCal command file and output to reconcile eight marked exclusions versus nine reported, then test the retained 141934/141935 combination and exclusion choices. Any sensitivity result must specify its assumptions and be kept separate from the published chronology.

§2.4, PDF pp. 31–34; Table S3, pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, p. 34

Archive PDF: 1600375_SM.pdf. File fingerprint is preserved in the downloadable register.

Selected original records · provisional text transcription

Ohalo II · charcoal and hut floors

Site dossier →

The 1995 paper reports 26 determinations. Eight selected rows begin the context register; they are not the complete series. The authors infer brief repeated occupations from archaeology, not from the spread of radiocarbon values.

Conventional radiocarbon BP only. This paper did not calibrate the dates; the published ± values are retained without introducing new calendar intervals. Floor-to-sample joins remain incomplete.

Laboratory / specimenMaterial & collectionRadiocarbon BP ±Published calendar BPRelationship / limit
RT-1625CharcoalLocus 1 · D81c212.35 / 212.33 m below sea level21,050 ± 330Not supplied hereElevation differs in indexed Tables 2/3; hold for image check.S194 · Tables 2–3, pp. 818–819; Figs. 9–10, p. 816
RT-1616Pistacia atlantica charcoalLocus 1 · E80b212.40–212.45 m below sea level19,590 ± 150Not supplied hereFig. 9 locates the square, not an individual floor assignment.S194 · Tables 2–3, pp. 818–819; Figs. 9–10, p. 816
RT-1617Populus euphratica charcoalLocus 1 · E80b212.50–212.55 m below sea level18,700 ± 180Not supplied hereSame square as RT-1616; lower collection is radiocarbon-younger.S194 · Tables 2–3, pp. 818–819; Figs. 9–10, p. 816
RT-1623Tamarix charcoalLocus 1 · G80c212.41–212.43 m below sea level18,210 ± 240Not supplied hereHut context; precise floor unlinked.S194 · Tables 2–3, pp. 818–819; Figs. 9–10, p. 816
RT-1619Tamarix charcoalLocus 2 · E85d212.25–212.32 m below sea level19,860 ± 190Not supplied hereFig. 10: middle of the exposed section.S194 · Tables 2–3, pp. 818–819; Figs. 9–10, p. 816
RT-1297CharcoalLocus 2 · E86b212.38–212.43 m below sea level17,500 ± 200Not supplied hereAuthors question pretreatment; omitted from their 24-date mean.S194 · Tables 2–3, pp. 818–819; Figs. 9–10, p. 816
RT-1618Tamarix charcoalLocus 2 · F86b212.32–212.36 m below sea level19,220 ± 180Not supplied hereHut context; precise floor unlinked.S194 · Tables 2–3, pp. 818–819; Figs. 9–10, p. 816
RT-1246CharcoalLocus 4 · AB87Surface15,550 ± 130Not supplied hereAuthors discuss later material, contamination or pretreatment; omitted from mean.S194 · Tables 2–3, pp. 818–819; Figs. 9–10, p. 816

Original publication images checked · model not reproduced

Page-Ladson · wood beside stone

Site dossier →

Biface 12080-1 was found in situ at 10.84 m below datum, but its northing differs: §1.3 gives N50.23, Table S10 N50.32 (both E23.22). Flake 12242-1 was screen-recovered; its Table S10 position N49.03/E23.05, depth 10.78 is an inferred collection context, not an observed in-situ point. Wood dates constrain these contexts, not stone manufacture.

Tables S3/S4 are now image-checked: 42 measurements, including all 37 inputs named by the 50N/23E figure. Their 1σ calendar intervals are separate from the OxCal 4.2.4 / IntCal13 model. Figure S12 marks eight exclusions, while §2.4 reports nine. The model has not been rerun.

Laboratory / specimenMaterial & collectionRadiocarbon BP ±Published calendar BPRelationship / limit
UCIAMS-153343Unidentified hardwood twigUnit 4b/4c interface · 50N/22E9.75 m below datum12,260 ± 3514,220–14,0881σ, as reportedOrganic lamina; separate unit. Absence from Fig. S12 does not identify a ninth excluded outlier.Outside this model · Different excavation unit; not in Fig. S12S195 · Table S3, PDF p. 27
UCIAMS-141928Unidentified diffuse-porous hardwood twigUnit 4b · 50N/23E9.80 m below datum12,335 ± 3514,399–14,1511σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained in combination · Combine UCIAMS-141928/141929S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141929Unidentified ring-porous hardwood twigUnit 4b · 50N/23E9.80 m below datum12,270 ± 3014,228–14,1001σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained in combination · Combine UCIAMS-141928/141929S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141930Water hickory (Carya cf. aquatic, as printed) woodUnit 4b · 50N/23E9.90 m below datum12,370 ± 3014,499–14,2091σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained · UCIAMS-141930S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141931American beech woodUnit 4b · 50N/23E10.00 m below datum12,275 ± 3014,236–14,1041σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained · UCIAMS-141931S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141932Hickory twigUnit 4b · 50N/23E10.10 m below datum12,310 ± 3014,303–14,1271σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained · UCIAMS-141932S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141933Bald cypress woodUnit 4b · 50N/23E10.20 m below datum12,295 ± 3514,279–14,1131σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained · UCIAMS-141933S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141934American beech woodUnit 4b · 50N/23E10.30 m below datum12,365 ± 3014,482–14,1991σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained in combination · Combine UCIAMS-141934/141935S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141935Unidentified hardwood twigUnit 4b · 50N/23E10.30 m below datum12,250 ± 3514,206–14,0791σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained in combination · Combine UCIAMS-141934/141935S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141937Red mulberry woodUnit 4b · 50N/23E10.40 m below datum12,380 ± 3514,544–14,2261σ, as reportedTable S3: below shell; broader sequence above the biface.Retained · UCIAMS-141937S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141938Unidentified hardwoodUnit 4a · 50N/23E10.50 m below datum12,440 ± 3014,720–14,3851σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained · UCIAMS-141938S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141939Unidentified hardwood twigUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.55 m below datum12,430 ± 3514,693–14,3501σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained in combination · Combine UCIAMS-141939/141940/141941S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141940Ash twigUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.55 m below datum12,430 ± 3014,690–14,3601σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained in combination · Combine UCIAMS-141939/141940/141941S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141941Unidentified hardwood, mostly central pith twigUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.55 m below datum12,365 ± 3014,482–14,1991σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained in combination · Combine UCIAMS-141939/141940/141941S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141942Unidentified hardwood twigUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.60 m below datum12,440 ± 3014,720–14,3851σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained in combination · Combine UCIAMS-141942/141943S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141943Oak twigUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.60 m below datum12,410 ± 3014,641–14,3171σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained in combination · Combine UCIAMS-141942/141943S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141944Bald cypress twigUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.65 m below datum12,410 ± 3514,646–14,3121σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained in combination · Combine UCIAMS-141944/141945S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141945Bald cypress twigUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.65 m below datum12,400 ± 3514,615–14,2831σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained in combination · Combine UCIAMS-141944/141945S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141946Ash twigUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.70 m below datum12,400 ± 3514,615–14,2831σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained · UCIAMS-141946S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141947Bald cypress woodUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.70 m below datum13,440 ± 4016,254–16,0921σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Marked excluded · UCIAMS-141947?S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141948Ash woodUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.75 m below datum12,430 ± 3014,690–14,3601σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained · UCIAMS-141948S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141949Oak twigUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.80 m below datum12,385 ± 3514,560–14,2381σ, as reportedAt biface levelRetained · UCIAMS-141949S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-127302Maple / box elder woodUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.84 m below datum12,425 ± 3014,676–14,3481σ, as reportedWall above bifaceRetained in combination · Combine UCIAMS-127302/127304S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-127304Fir woodUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.84 m below datum12,420 ± 3014,664–14,3381σ, as reportedBeside bifaceRetained in combination · Combine UCIAMS-127302/127304S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-127305Unknown periderm barkUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.84 m below datum13,015 ± 3015,699–15,4831σ, as reportedBeside biface; older result preserved in this ledger; marked excluded in Fig. S12Marked excluded · UCIAMS-127305?S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-127303Ash woodUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.85 m below datum12,495 ± 3014,929–14,5861σ, as reportedBelow bifaceRetained in combination · Combine UCIAMS-127303/141951S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141950Bald cypress woodUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.85 m below datum13,830 ± 3516,861–16,6231σ, as reportedAt biface level; older result preserved in this ledger; marked excluded in Fig. S12Marked excluded · UCIAMS-141950?S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141951White-oak group woodUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.85 m below datum12,415 ± 3014,652–14,3281σ, as reportedAt biface levelRetained in combination · Combine UCIAMS-127303/141951S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141952White-oak group woodUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.90 m below datum12,385 ± 3514,560–14,2381σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained · UCIAMS-141952S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141953Bald cypress woodUnit 3c · 50N/23E10.95 m below datum14,510 ± 4017,776–17,5891σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Marked excluded · UCIAMS-141953?S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141954Bald cypress woodUnit 3c · 50N/23E11.00 m below datum13,005 ± 3515,683–15,4551σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Marked excluded · UCIAMS-141954?S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141955Bald cypress woodUnit 3c · 50N/23E11.05 m below datum13,585 ± 3516,450–16,2641σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Marked excluded · UCIAMS-141955?S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141956Bald cypress twigUnit 3c · 50N/23E11.10 m below datum12,395 ± 3014,585–14,2661σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained · UCIAMS-141956S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141957Oak twigUnit 3c · 50N/23E11.15 m below datum12,420 ± 3014,664–14,3381σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained · UCIAMS-141957S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141958Bald cypress twigUnit 3a · 50N/23E11.20 m below datum12,495 ± 3514,931–14,5691σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained · UCIAMS-141958S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141959Bald cypress twigUnit 3a · 50N/23E11.25 m below datum12,615 ± 3515,120–14,9101σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Retained · UCIAMS-141959S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141960Bald cypress woodUnit 3a · 50N/23E11.35 m below datum13,945 ± 5017,040–16,8061σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Marked excluded · UCIAMS-141960?S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-141961Bald cypress woodUnit 3a · 50N/23E11.48 m below datum13,080 ± 4015,792–15,5981σ, as reportedStratigraphic column; not an individually demonstrated contact with a tool.Marked excluded · UCIAMS-141961?S195 · Table S3, PDF pp. 27–29; Fig. S12, PDF p. 34
UCIAMS-143535Unidentified hardwoodUnit 4b · 49N/24E10.13 m below datum12,420 ± 3014,664–14,3381σ, as reportedTable S4: near flake; relates to later Unit 4 finds, not the Unit 3c biface. Section 1.4 inconsistently calls these flakes 4b and 4a.Outside this model · Different excavation unit; not in Fig. S12S195 · Table S4, PDF p. 30; §1.4
UCIAMS-143536Unidentified hardwood rootUnit 4b · 49N/24E10.17 m below datum12,360 ± 3514,477–14,1881σ, as reportedTable S4: near flake; relates to later Unit 4 finds, not the Unit 3c biface. Section 1.4 inconsistently calls these flakes 4b and 4a.Outside this model · Different excavation unit; not in Fig. S12S195 · Table S4, PDF p. 30; §1.4
UCIAMS-143537Unidentified woodUnit 3c · 49N/23E10.78 m below datum12,560 ± 3515,038–14,7871σ, as reportedAssigned to the flake collection context through unit/depth and Table S10. Section 1.4 describes samples from the top/bottom of the excavated corner, not direct contact with a piece-plotted flake.Outside this model · Different excavation unit; not in Fig. S12S195 · Table S4, PDF p. 30; Table S10, p. 63; §1.4, pp. 12–13
UCIAMS-143538Unidentified hardwood rootUnit 3c · 49N/23E10.78 m below datum12,430 ± 3514,693–14,3501σ, as reportedAssigned to the flake collection context through unit/depth and Table S10. Section 1.4 describes samples from the top/bottom of the excavated corner, not direct contact with a piece-plotted flake.Outside this model · Different excavation unit; not in Fig. S12S195 · Table S4, PDF p. 30; Table S10, p. 63; §1.4, pp. 12–13

Selected original records · provisional text transcription

Paisley Caves · three later dietary specimens

Site dossier →

These three measurements date specimens in the later dietary study. They do not inherit the early weft age. Human origin is the authors’ interpretation from multiple observations; these three are not individually confirmed by the early lipid study.

Published conventional radiocarbon BP and 2σ calibrated intervals remain separate. Table 2 specifies IntCal13 and OxCal 4.3. No recalibration was performed.

Laboratory / specimenMaterial & collectionRadiocarbon BP ±Published calendar BPRelationship / limit
OxA-38445Specimen 981896-PC-2/6D-51-12Uncharred unidentified plant fiberCave 2 · unit 6 · D · LU 31365.75 m above sea level10,407 ± 3712,515–12,0872σ, as reportedBulk plant material recovered from this coprolite; direct specimen association, not an assay on every dietary constituent.S191 · Tables 1–2, article pp. 7–10
OxA-38674Specimen 551961-PC-2/7C-16-136Charcoal and uncharred unidentified plant fiberCave 2 · unit 7 · C · LU 31365.85 m above sea level10,262 ± 5712,376–11,7672σ, as reportedBulk plant material recovered from this coprolite; direct specimen association, not an assay on every dietary constituent.S191 · Tables 1–2, article pp. 7–10
OxA-38415Specimen 2421895-PC-5/16A-21-1Charcoal and uncharred unidentified plant fiberCave 5 · unit 16 · A · LU 21366.11 m above sea level9,663 ± 2911,196–10,8232σ, as reportedBulk plant material recovered from this coprolite; direct specimen association, not an assay on every dietary constituent.S191 · Tables 1–2, article pp. 7–10

Keep the uncertainty visible

The next links to verify.

Ohalo: resolve a table discrepancy

RT-1625 has indexed elevations −212.35 and −212.33 in Tables 2 and 3. Neither is silently preferred; OCR versus a printed discrepancy remains unresolved.

Page-Ladson: eight marked, nine reported

The original Figure S12 is now inspected and all 37 50N/23E inputs joined. Eight IDs bear exclusion marks; §2.4 says nine. UCIAMS-141936 appears in neither Table S3 nor the figure and cannot be invented as the missing date. UCIAMS-153343 is from another unit, not an identified ninth outlier. Original model code/output remains needed.

Page-Ladson: field precision and printed discrepancies

Biface northing is N50.23 in §1.3 but N50.32 in Table S10. Flake 12242-1 was screen-recovered from a restricted excavated corner; its coordinates are inferred context. Section 1.4 describes top/bottom samples but Table S4 gives both near-flake rows depth 10.78, leaving individual upper/lower assignments unlinked. Section 2.4 also prints a 41,100 cal BP endpoint inconsistent with the figure; retain it as a flagged publication error, not an early human date.

Paisley: retain both discordant measurements

Specimen 195 is listed as Beta-213423: 10,050 ± 50 and OxA-16376: 10,965 ± 50 radiocarbon BP. The published combined age is held from plotting until its inputs and agreement test are checked. Mixed human/carnivore signals are a separate identity issue.

Paisley: early weft and coprolite identity

Original supplementary Tables S1/S3 and weft calibration remain unread. Specimen 194’s shared catalog number still prevents a secure DNA-to-lipid subsample join.

Monte Verde: original algae documentation

The 2008 Dillehay.som.pdf endpoint was located but could not be retrieved. Beta-238355 and Beta-239650 retain their existing values and unresolved calibration/reservoir metadata. Certificates and original feature records remain open targets.

Source-access record · 2026-10-30

What was actually inspected.

S194 · Indexed author-uploaded article read

Tables 2/3 and figure captions accessible as text; PDF retrieval failed. No image verification or original certificate inspection.

Source record ↗
S195 · Original PDF and figure images inspected

Europe PMC supplementary archive retrieved. Figure S12, Tables S3/S4/S10, §2.4 and field text checked. All 42 S3/S4 measurements transcribed; core Table S2 is outside this register. Publication images do not replace original lab certificates, field sheets or OxCal output.

Source record ↗
S191 · Indexed primary article tables read

Tables 1/2 available in author and institutional copies; PDF screenshot retrieval failed. Three new assay rows transcribed provisionally.

Source record ↗
S188 · Supplement located, not read

Publisher and PMC supplement routes did not deliver a readable PDF in this pass. No missing fields inferred.

Source record ↗
S9 · 2008 supplement located, not read

Publisher endpoint returned 403. Later papers are not substitutes for the original calibration output.

Source record ↗

Atlas/globe coverage checked. Page-Ladson retains the approximately 14,550 cal BP contextual estimate with the model discrepancy and screen-recovery caveat attached. Older excluded wood does not create earlier human markers. Later Unit 4 context samples do not inherit the Unit 3c date. Other sites and chronology remain unchanged.

A failed retrieval does not establish that a document is lost. No records request has been sent. Editorial status: draft.