PUBLIC RESEARCH PREVIEW Research in progress · uncertainties and source access are recorded throughout.

Ledger follow-up · 2026-10-28

Check the links.
Keep the uncertainty.

The correction audit now reaches the published model inputs. Other links remain open—and visible.

Return to the sample-to-horizon ledger →
Working review. Targeted follow-up to ledger version 1; original records and frozen workbook retained. No author contact or revised age model. The broad evidence for Last Glacial Maximum presence and the precise 2026 model refinement are different questions.

New · Original-study metadata

Eleven determinations.
Seven field IDs.

Provisional transcription. Recovered from public reproductions of the 2021 supplement, Table S5. The original publisher PDF and USGS files remain unverified. Access copies and limitations →

All 11 laboratory-to-field ID pairs, elevations, conventional ages/errors and replicate flags agree with the existing 2026-compilation ledger. Eleven determinations represent seven field IDs; neither count is a count of track horizons or people.

Laboratory IDField IDElevation
m asl
SeedsReplicate flag
Table S5
Measured age
14C ka ±1σ
USGS-180320WHSA1-18.1a1197.3660Not flagged17.47 ± 0.09
USGS-182820WHSA1-18.1a1197.3640Replicate (footnote 3)17.93 ± 0.09
USGS-180620WHSA1-18.1e1197.3645Not flagged18.20 ± 0.11
USGS-180420WHSA1-18.1b1197.3040Not flagged17.83 ± 0.09
USGS-180520WHSA1-18.1d1197.2855Not flagged18.55 ± 0.10
USGS-182920WHSA1-18.1d1197.2840Replicate (footnote 3)18.66 ± 0.10
USGS-180720WHSA1-18.1f1197.2760Not flagged18.68 ± 0.11
USGS-1808.120WHSA1-18.2a1197.1480Replicate (footnote 3)18.95 ± 0.11
USGS-180820WHSA1-18.2a1197.1460Not flagged19.02 ± 0.11
USGS-183020WHSA1-18.3a1197.1440Replicate (footnote 3)18.81 ± 0.10
USGS-181020WHSA1-18.3a1197.1460Not flagged19.01 ± 0.12
Material, preparation and calibration

Material: Ruppia cirrhosa seeds.

Pretreatment: USGS Denver acid-base-acid: 1N HCl, 60°C, 30 min; 1N NaOH, 60°C, 30 min, repeated until clear; 1N HCl, 60°C, at least 10 min. Then Type-1 water rinse and drying.

Calibration: OxCal 4.4.2 / IntCal20, as stated in 2021 Table S5; distinct from the 2026 compilation’s 4.4.4 attribution.

Conventional 14C ages: 1σ (68%); calibrated ranges: stated 2σ (95%). The printed calibrated ± describes the distance to range endpoints, not a Gaussian standard deviation.

Third-party reproductions of one work, not independent evidence. Publisher PDF and USGS release files remain unretrieved. Footnote 3 denotes replication, not a field-ID suffix. Elevation alone adds no footprint correlation. Table S5 is not a complete laboratory certificate or field notebook.

Reproduced 2021 supplement, Table S5 p.19 and §1.3.1 pp.6–7; public HTML text, not a visually verified original PDF · S1 S144

01 · Table → calculation → model

The discrepancy is not confirmed to be display-only.

Table S8 says to add the hard-water correction to measured F14C. Three rows do not reconcile. Both printed model-4 code blocks use the corrected radiocarbon ages in that table. The original numbers are preserved below. Source S5 · supplement Tables S7–S8, PDF p.51; model inputs, pp.5 and 11.

SampleMeasured + correctionPrinted corrected F14CAge from sum
14C ka · diagnostic
S8 corrected age
14C ka ±1σ
Model-4 input
14C BP ±1σ
Review
USGS-20730.0875 + 0.0085= 0.09600.096018.82518.82 ± 0.2218,820 ± 220Sum matches
USGS-20740.0813 + 0.0146= 0.09590.091118.83319.24 ± 0.2419,240 ± 240Unresolved
USGS-20750.0780 + 0.0124= 0.09040.092819.30719.10 ± 0.2619,100 ± 260Unresolved
USGS-20760.0766 + 0.0115= 0.08810.087019.51419.62 ± 0.2819,620 ± 280Unresolved
What the arithmetic can—and cannot—show

The diagnostic column uses the conventional radiocarbon relationship age (ka) = −8.033 × ln(F14C) on the displayed sum. These are calculations from rounded published values, not new laboratory results or calibrated calendar ages. No uncertainty interval or replacement model is implied.

For USGS-2074, the stated addition yields 0.0959, also the pollen-control fraction in Table S7. Table S8 instead prints 0.0911, corresponding approximately to its 19.24 ka age; the model uses 19,240 BP. USGS-2075 and -2076 also diverge. The direction is not uniform, so a single offset cannot repair the chronology.

The intended correction and uncertainty treatment require clarification. Because the correction is itself calculated from pollen and seed values, those quantities should not automatically be treated as independent errors. The USGS release has been identified but its files were not retrieved. Data-release access record.

Can rounding explain the mismatch?

No, under ordinary rounding to four decimal places. Each of the three entries can differ from its unrounded value by at most 0.00005; their combined residual is therefore at most 0.00015. All three mismatches exceed that bound. This checks internal arithmetic, not laboratory uncertainty or the correct chronology.

SamplePollen basis · S7Printed minus sum
F14C
Beyond rounding?Factor implied by printed result
Diagnostic only
USGS-2073Interpolated pollen age; brackets USGS-2330 / USGS-23310.0000No0.0085
USGS-2074Paired pollen USGS-2331-0.0048Yes0.0098
USGS-2075Interpolated pollen age; brackets USGS-2331 / USGS-23320.0024Yes0.0148
USGS-2076Paired pollen USGS-2332-0.0011Yes0.0104

The implied factor is the printed corrected fraction minus the measured fraction. It is not a recommended replacement for Table S7. A documented resolution must identify the intended fractions, their uncertainties and the values actually used to produce the model outputs.

02 · Surface relationships

A shared name is not a demonstrated connection.

FeatureStatus / targetPublished basisLimit and source
2025 Area A linear tracesWS-X-01Author-correlatedTH2Authors correlate the surface lithostratigraphically with TH2; Figs.2–3 and §2 identify the relation.Published correlation, not an independent survey. No new laboratory date on the grooves.§2 pp.3–4; Figs.2–3 · S6
2025 Areas B, C and DWS-X-02Author-correlatedTH2Authors report surfaces traceable into the main trench and laterally into the slope.Indurated surfaces were not excavated in the same way as Area A. Do not equate every park linear feature with TH2.§2 p.4; Fig.2 inset · S6
Locality 3 out-and-back trackwayWS-X-03UnlinkedNo assigned horizonHuman/megafaunal overprinting supplies relative order; 2020 study says precise geochronology is uncertain.No demonstrated tie to a named Locality 2 horizon; no Locality 2 age inherited.§2 pp.3–4; §4.4 · S22
2025 regional sediment sectionsWS-X-04UnlinkedNo assigned horizonRegional stratigraphic support is indexed separately in the 42-row date ledger.No new individual TH equivalence established in this pass. Sediment-unit correlation is not a same-event claim.Main Table 1; supplementary Tables S2–S4 · S4
2025 TH8–TH16 labels versus 2026 TP8–TP16WS-X-05UnlinkedNo assigned horizonThe papers use different horizon/package terminology in an expanded excavation. Matching numerals alone are insufficient.Feature-by-feature crosswalk awaits explicit continuity and package-boundary checks; no automatic alias assigned.S6 Fig.2; S5 Table S1 and S9d · S5 S6

03 · The unit being counted

427 measurements do not mean 427 people.

RecordObservationsReported estimateMethod and limit
Locality 3Northbound journey233step/stride measurements1.7 m/s mean; 1.6–1.8 m/s range800 m orthorectified mosaic; stride/step measurements and anthropometric speed formula. Estimated speed, not a stopwatch observation or count of people.§4.3, accepted manuscript p.10 · S22
Locality 3Southbound journey194step/stride measurements1.6 m/s mean; 1.49–1.8 m/s rangeSame mosaic and method as northbound sample; 427 measurements in total across six sections. Repeated observations along a trackway are not independent individuals; the same-person return remains an interpretation.§4.3, accepted manuscript p.10 · S22
Locality 22021 pooled footprint sample61documented human tracks across surfacesNo population count assignedOriginal paper reports tracks from multiple surfaces. Not 61 people or a simultaneous group; age/stature estimates depend on anthropometric reference samples and preservation.Accepted manuscript pp.2–3; Fig.2B · S1

Carrying a child remains a reasoned interpretation of the Locality 3 traces. Footprint shape also depends on substrate and slipping. Sex and kinship are not demonstrated. For some linear traces, the transport paper also leaves dragging firewood as an alternative to a constructed device. Behavioral evidence and alternatives →

04 · Community-published context

A living relationship with this landscape.

Mescalero Apache Tribe

Reports a White Sands National Monument stop during an herb-collection outing, with Arden Comanche and James Kunetsis explaining plant history and uses.

Publication and author
Mescalero Apache Tribe / Apache Scout, March 2018, p.14. Mescalero Prevention Program; no individual byline in this item.
Audience and purpose
Tribal community readers; a program update that includes youth activities. Report community education and program activities.
Event date
October; year not explicit in the passage.
What it supports
A community-authored record of living landscape relationships; no numerical footprint chronology or identification of ancient trackmakers.
Read the attributed source record →

05 · Verification queue

What is checked, and what still needs evidence.

inconsistency confirmed

Correction table to model input

Three printed S8 corrected fractions fail the stated addition. The published corrected radiocarbon ages are consistent with those printed fractions to rounding precision and are the inputs in both model-4 code blocks. An impact on model results cannot be excluded. A rounding-bound check rules out ordinary four-decimal rounding for all three residuals. The implied added factors are 0.0098, 0.0148 and 0.0104 for 2074–2076, not the printed factors; these are diagnostics, not proposed corrections.

Next: Compare the USGS release with the PDF, obtain a documented resolution of the intended fractions and uncertainties, then evaluate any revised model. Do not substitute arithmetic sums as corrected dates.

S5 supplement §1.1 pp.2, 5, 11, Tables S7–S8 p.51 · S5 S142

original file pending

Original 2023 OSL Table S2

Main Fig.2 checked. Critique §4.5 calls original errors 2σ and its recalculated scenarios 1σ; those conventions must not be merged. The shared >21.5 ±1.9 ka minimum remains distinct from three reprinted sample ages.

Next: Retrieve original Table S2 and dose-rate metadata; verify uncertainty convention and measured sample positions before closing.

S2 Fig.2; S21 §4.5/Table 3; USGS release metadata only · S2 S21 S141

provisional metadata recovered

Original 2021 sample metadata

All 11 laboratory-to-field ID pairs, elevations, conventional ages/errors and replicate flags agree with the existing 2026-compilation ledger. Eleven determinations represent seven field IDs; neither count is a count of track horizons or people. Seed counts, pretreatment and original calibration software are now provisionally indexed from reproduced Table S5/§1.3.1.

Next: Verify against publisher or author-held PDF / USGS release; retain provisional status until then. Laboratory certificates and field-context drawings remain separate requirements.

Reproduced 2021 supplement, Table S5 p.19 and §1.3.1 pp.6–7; public HTML text, not a visually verified original PDF · S1 S140 S144

partial

2024 critique and rebuttal audit

Critique sections on OSL placement and water content checked in author-posted text. Main 2023 Figure 2 and critique Figure 3 caption disagree about placement; the latter reconstructs elevations from a photograph. The full rebuttal remains unavailable in this pass.

Next: Obtain and read the full rebuttal alongside critique §§3–6, then pair each claim with its response and later tests. Later regional dates do not by themselves settle bleaching or lifetime water content.

S2 Fig.2; S21 §§4.1, 4.5 and Fig.3 caption; S3 abstract only · S2 S3 S4 S5 S21

Atlas/globe coverage checked. Retain AT-WS-L2 and its existing unresolved S8/model-input warning; no date or marker change. The provisional 2021 metadata adds no new dating event. The rounding diagnostic does not establish replacement dates. Locality 3 remains unplotted. Explore the globe →
Source retrieval record · 2026-10-28

2021 sample metadata

Partial: provisional copy recovered

Public copies expose Table S5 and methods. Publisher supplement returned 403; USGS metadata download also returned 403. A catalogue record is not the laboratory dataset.

S1 S140 S144

2023 OSL Table S2

Original table still pending

The article identifies a 4.85 MB supplement and the USGS release. ScienceBase and metadata routes did not supply the files. Main-paper and critique checks remain the available evidence; dose-rate details and exact sampling positions are not promoted to verified.

S2 S21 S141

2024 full rebuttal

Full text still pending

USGS and Bournemouth provide bibliographic/abstract records; publisher access is restricted. ResearchGate explicitly reports no full text available. Abstracts and later authors’ summaries cannot complete a paired methodological audit. No author request sent.

S3

2026 correction discrepancy

Cause and intended values unresolved

Original PDF and model inputs available; release files not retrieved. Targeted DOI/erratum searches found no authoritative resolution. Crossmark could not be retrieved, so no claim of a complete correction-notice check. Need intended fractions, errors and model-input provenance before revising any chronology.

S5 S142