PUBLIC RESEARCH PREVIEW Research in progress · uncertainties and source access are recorded throughout.

SITE-001 · 2026-10-28

White Sands footprints

Human presence during the Last Glacial Maximum

footprintsradiocarbonluminescenceNorth America
Working research. Assessments and source-access limitations are retained from the research record. This entry has not completed its public-release review.

Supported interpretation

Current assessment

Human presence during the Last Glacial Maximum is supported by several dating approaches.

Main limitation: The particular 2026 modeled sequence retains unresolved Table S8/model-input discrepancies and source-access limits. Locality 3 does not inherit Locality 2 dates.

Why this conclusion?

Original source and context

Locality 2 tracked surfaces and associated samples: compare the 2021 study, 2023 pollen/quartz work and 2026 Table S8 corrections with model inputs. S1 · Bennett et al. (2021)S2 · Pigati et al. (2023)S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026)

From evidence to conclusion

Different dating materials and the regional sediment study strengthen the broad chronology, while sharing stratigraphic assumptions. Precise refinement depends on resolving the correction audit. S2 · Pigati et al. (2023)S4 · Holliday et al. (2025)S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026)

Strongest substantive alternative

Old aquatic carbon, redeposited pollen or inappropriate luminescence assumptions could weaken individual age assignments. The published critique and response must be compared alongside later studies. S21 · Rhode et al. (2024)S3 · Pigati et al. (2024)S4 · Holliday et al. (2025)

What could change this assessment?

A verified correction-to-model-input crosswalk and independent, securely linked track-surface dates could revise the sequence or its uncertainty. S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026)

Observed evidence

Excavated tracks, aquatic seeds, terrestrial pollen and quartz measurements provide different records of the studied deposits. S1 · Bennett et al. (2021)S2 · Pigati et al. (2023)S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026)

Supported interpretation

Their stratigraphic relationships and corroborating methods support LGM presence; a modeled package age is not a direct age for every footprint. S2 · Pigati et al. (2023)S4 · Holliday et al. (2025)S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026)

Disputed proposal

Rhode and colleagues question reservoir effects, redeposition and OSL assumptions; Pigati and colleagues defend the chronology. The original critique has wider access than the rebuttal, whose abstract alone was available in the recorded review. S21 · Rhode et al. (2024)S3 · Pigati et al. (2024)

Illustrative reconstruction

A scene of people crossing a lake margin can convey the setting. Clothing, dialogue, precise weather and relationships between walkers would be illustrative additions, not findings. S1 · Bennett et al. (2021)S22 · Bennett et al. (2020)

Unknown

These records do not identify the first arrival in the Americas, every walker’s identity, or a precise absolute date for Locality 3. S22 · Bennett et al. (2020)

Statement types are not confidence scores. A supported interpretation can also be disputed. Editorial review, publication or retraction status, source access and scientific assessment remain separate. How to read these labels

Record: SITE-001. Tags: Americas; North America; New Mexico; Late Pleistocene; Last Glacial Maximum; footprints; radiocarbon; luminescence; human dispersal.

White Sands preserves human tracks in ancient lake-margin deposits. The central finding is that people were present in what is now New Mexico during the Last Glacial Maximum. The original study reported approximately 23,000–21,000 years; a 2026 study reports a refined age for the studied sequence to approximately 23,500–21,700 years. These ranges belong to the studied deposits, not automatically every footprint in the park. The precise 2026 model has an unresolved correction/input inconsistency, documented in the research review; the broader LGM inference rests on more than that one model. [S1 · Bennett et al. (2021); S2 · Pigati et al. (2023); S4 · Holliday et al. (2025); S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026)]

Location reference: White Sands National Park, Tularosa Basin, southern New Mexico, along the former margins of Lake Otero. Figure 1 of the 2025 study provides a published regional map. No exact excavation coordinates have been entered. [S4 · Holliday et al. (2025)]

Evidence and dating

PublicationEvidence or methodContribution and limitation
2021Radiocarbon dating of aquatic plant seeds in layers bracketing footprints.Reported approximately 23,000–21,000 years. Dates associated material rather than the act of making a footprint. [S1 · Bennett et al. (2021)]
2023Radiocarbon dating of terrestrial conifer pollen; quartz optically stimulated luminescence, which estimates time since light exposure.Pollen supported the seed chronology; quartz supplied an independent physical dating method. The reported quartz minimum was about 21,500 years for the sampled sediment, not every track. [S2 · Pigati et al. (2023)]
2024Published methodological exchange.Disagreement included old carbon in aquatic plants, potentially redeposited pollen, and luminescence assumptions. The original critique and researchers’ rebuttal are indexed separately. [S21 · Rhode et al. (2024); S3 · Pigati et al. (2024)]
2025Independent stratigraphic study with 26 new accepted radiocarbon determinations: 21 on palustrine mud and 5 on seeds.Supported a Last Glacial Maximum age through deposits linked to the footprint sequence. The wider sediment record is not itself the age range of every track. [S4 · Holliday et al. (2025)]
2026Expanded excavation, conifer pollen and seed chronology.Reported 20 track horizons or packages; pollen-based corrections for variable hard-water effects refine the sequence to approximately 23,500–21,700 years. [S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026)]

The initial concern about aquatic seeds was substantive: plants can incorporate dissolved old carbon and appear too old. Later dating addressed that concern with different materials and methods. Corroboration strengthens the chronology; shared samples or stratigraphic assumptions still need to be recorded when assessing independence. [S2 · Pigati et al. (2023)]

Claims and interpretations

IDClaimWorking assessment
WS-C01Humans left the studied footprints at White Sands.Well supported: excavated footprints occur in stratigraphic context. [S1 · Bennett et al. (2021)]
WS-C02Humans were present here during the Last Glacial Maximum.Well supported: successive studies support this age through several dating approaches and linked sediment records. [S1 · Bennett et al. (2021); S2 · Pigati et al. (2023); S4 · Holliday et al. (2025); S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026)]
WS-C03Associated grooves record people pulling wooden transport devices called travois.Provisional interpretation: a 2025 study favors this explanation after considering alternatives. The evidence is traces, not a recovered wooden vehicle. [S6 · Bennett et al. (2025)]
WS-C04White Sands identifies the first arrival date or the migration route into the Americas.Not established by these finds: local presence sets a latest possible arrival boundary for those people, not the continent’s first arrival date or route. This is a logical limit on the inference.
WS-C05The dated footprints establish cities, agriculture, or an advanced lost civilization.Unsupported by the evidence cited here: these are different claims requiring their own material evidence.
WS-C06All White Sands tracks share the Locality 2 age.Not established: locality and surface correlations must be demonstrated. The Locality 3 study supplies a different kind of chronological constraint. [S22 · Bennett et al. (2020)]
WS-C07The Locality 3 trackway records child carrying.Supported interpretation: see behavioral evidence and limitations below. [S22 · Bennett et al. (2020)]
WS-C08Human–sloth tracks demonstrate a successful hunt.Not established: interaction and possible hunting behavior do not demonstrate a kill. [S23 · Bustos et al. (2018)]
WS-C09Footprint morphology identifies a particular present-day community.Not established by the cited measurements: cultural relationships and community accounts are recorded with their own attribution and context.

Disagreement worth preserving

Rhode and colleagues’ 2024 critique questions aquatic-seed reservoir effects, pollen redeposition, luminescence assumptions, and the placement of dated samples relative to tracks. Pigati and colleagues’ rebuttal rejects those objections. Both original publications are indexed. The critique’s OSL placement and water-content sections have now been checked in author-posted full text; only the rebuttal abstract was accessible. A full paired methodological audit remains pending. Subsequent 2025 and 2026 studies must be considered alongside this earlier exchange. [S21 · Rhode et al. (2024); S3 · Pigati et al. (2024); S4 · Holliday et al. (2025); S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026)]

The present working assessment favors a Last Glacial Maximum age because of the accumulated evidence. The repository should retain the objections and responses rather than replacing the entire history with a single “confirmed” label.

White Sands: findings from the five research questions

Research update: October 28, 2026. Scope: published evidence and publicly shared community accounts. This is a synthesis, not an independent reanalysis of raw dates or track models. The distinctions below are part of the index: locality, track surface, dated sample, inferred activity, and attributed community account.

1. How do the footprint localities relate chronologically?

White Sands is a landscape containing multiple records, not one uniformly dated surface. Use the locality names in each publication; matching numbers in different maps do not establish that two exposures are the same place or layer.

RecordChronological evidenceWhat we can currently correlate
Locality 2: excavated sequenceOriginal seed chronology, subsequent pollen and luminescence work, and expanded excavation. [S1 · Bennett et al. (2021); S2 · Pigati et al. (2023); S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026)]Successive layers establish relative order and a modeled calendar chronology. The latest study distinguishes discrete track horizons from upper track packages, which contain multiple thin tracked layers. [S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026)]
Locality 3: long out-and-back trackwayHuman tracks are overprinted by mammoth/sloth tracks; the returning human trail overprints those animal tracks. The 2020 paper establishes a late Pleistocene association, without a precise absolute date. [S22 · Bennett et al. (2020)]Strong event order within this trackway. Its age must not be copied from Locality 2.
Western Alkali Flat: human–sloth interaction studyThe 2018 authors explicitly leave the exact age unresolved. They propose an indirect 15.56–10 thousand radiocarbon-year interval using landscape and extinction evidence. Those are principally uncalibrated ages. [S23 · Bustos et al. (2018)]Keep the published estimate as historical interpretation, not a calibrated bracket or a demonstrated match to Locality 2.
Linear traces interpreted as transportThe 2025 study reports that some associated traces date to approximately 22,000 years ago. [S6 · Bennett et al. (2025)]Assign an age to the documented feature and its stratigraphic connection; do not date all grooves from this statement.
Regional lake/wetland sectionsThe 2025 geological study links deposits to the footprint sequence using stratigraphy and 26 additional radiocarbon measurements. [S4 · Holliday et al. (2025)]Supports the regional chronological framework. A correlated sediment unit is not automatically the same walking event.

Indexing decision: retain SITE-001 as the parent and distinguish locality/feature records underneath it. Keep a publication’s original locality label plus its source. No exact footprint coordinates are needed for this public research index.

2. Which measurements bracket tracks, and which describe the landscape?

A footprint is not itself radiocarbon dated. The important chain is sample → dated material → depositional layer → track surface → age inference. In an undisturbed sequence, material below a surface limits how old the track can be; overlying material limits how young it can be. Reworking, erosion, penetration into underlying sediment, and delayed burial can weaken that connection.

Measurement or constraintRelationship to the tracksAppropriate use and main check
Aquatic Ruppia seeds, original Locality 2 studySeed-bearing layers bracket tracked surfaces. [S1 · Bennett et al. (2021)]Surface-associated chronology, conditional on stratigraphy and whether plant carbon reflects the contemporary atmosphere. Replicating a biased material alone would not remove that bias.
Terrestrial conifer pollen, 2023Samples from dated stratigraphic levels provide a carbon source independent of aquatic uptake. [S2 · Pigati et al. (2023)]Tests the seed chronology; requires controls on contamination and redeposition. “Independent material” still shares the site’s stratigraphic interpretation.
Quartz luminescence, 2023Measures burial/light-exposure history of sampled sediment; reported minimum approximately 21.5 ± 1.9 ka. [S2 · Pigati et al. (2023)]A separate physical clock, not a date stamped onto every overlying print. Bleaching, water-content assumptions, and sample position matter; their interpretation is contested. [S21 · Rhode et al. (2024)]
Paired pollen and seeds, 2026Improved pollen measurements reveal older seed ages in lower layers.The preferred model corrects variable hard-water effects; the authors find these become negligible by TH1. Climate-record correspondence helps evaluate the model, rather than constituting another direct footprint date. [S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026)]
Wetland mud, 2025Dates deposits connected through regional stratigraphy. [S4 · Holliday et al. (2025)]Landscape support. Mixed organic sources and the demonstrated link to a track-bearing unit belong in the record.
Cross-cutting footprintsOne print deforms or overlies another. [S22 · Bennett et al. (2020); S23 · Bustos et al. (2018)]Relative event order and possible close succession. Calendar age still needs a separate constraint.

Important refinement: the 2026 result is not a finding that reservoir effects never occurred. The published corrected sequence is approximately 23.5–21.7 ka, with its precise refinement subject to the correction audit below. It contains 20 horizons or packages, not 20 securely simultaneous groups. [S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026)]

Sample-level ledger added, October 28, 2026. The linked workbook now records laboratory and field IDs, material, published elevation/depth, layer and footprint relationship, measured and calibrated ages, uncertainty conventions, correction/model role, exclusions, replicate status, source locations, and unresolved fields. Coverage and verification limits are stated below; missing laboratory metadata have not been invented.

Sample-to-horizon ledger — version 1

Open the complete White Sands sample-to-horizon ledger (Excel; seven indexed worksheets).

Coverage: all 28 Locality-2 radiocarbon determinations compiled in the 2026 supplement’s Table S4, 20 track horizons/packages, 42 regional radiocarbon determinations from the 2025 paper (40 Table 1 assay rows plus two supplementary Table S4 rows), and three individually indexed OSL samples. The three published regional averages are not additional assays. This is a defined Locality-2 and regional-comparison set, not a census of every White Sands date. [S2 · Pigati et al. (2023); S4 · Holliday et al. (2025); S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026)]

How to read it: start with Horizons, then follow the laboratory IDs into Locality 2. A sample below a surface and one above it provide a stratigraphic bracket, subject to deposition and dating assumptions. The workbook’s neighboring groups follow the published model code; its modeled ages come from Table S9d, model 4. They are published outputs, not an independent model rerun or direct footprint measurements. Package ages refer to mean elevations within intervals. Numeric model elevations are preserved for reproducibility, without implying better field precision than the published centimeter-scale survey. [S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026)]

Track recordNearby dated material / modeled orderingWhat the relationship supports
TH(-3), 1196.26 mSeed USGS-2076 immediately below; pollen USGS-2332 at the corresponding reported level.A local lower-sequence constraint using a hard-water correction; model-4 surface estimate 23.49 ± 0.32 cal ka BP (2σ).
TH1, 1197.08 mSeed USGS-2073 below; seed group USGS-1808.1 / 1808 / 1830 / 1810 above.Interpolation across local dated levels. The upper group is positioned just above TH2 in the model code, despite rounded elevations and schematic ordering.
TH5, 1197.27 mUSGS-1807 is ordered immediately below; USGS-1805 / 1829 / 2071 above.Close surface association. Numerical model offsets must not be mistaken for submillimeter field measurements.
TP8–TP10USGS-2068, -2067, -2066 and -2065 lie within these packages by the published means and thicknesses.Constraints within track-bearing intervals; a package is not one simultaneous walking surface.
TP11–TP16All lie above the highest dated seed, USGS-2065 at 1197.76 m.Extrapolated model ages, not surfaces independently bracketed by dates above and below.
2023 OSL levelThe authors’ Figure 2 places the shared quartz-sampling level between TH1 and TH2, below the lowest original seed level; the 2024 critique disputes that placement using a reconstructed photographic scale.A sediment burial constraint. The reported shared minimum, >21.5 ± 1.9 ka, is not assigned separately to every OSL sample or track.
2025 regional datesDepths and facies retained for each trench/profile; no individual Locality-2 TH assigned.Broader landscape chronology. Similar elevations alone do not establish the same track surface.

Counting and dependence: the 28 radiocarbon determinations include replicate aliquots and six pollen dates. Model 4 uses 20 retained seed determinations at 13 modeled levels/groups. USGS-1803 and USGS-1804 are retained in the ledger but excluded from the published models as outliers. New pollen dates inform the hard-water corrections and therefore are not additional independent inputs to model 4. [S5, supplementary text §1.2]

Source-table issues preserved for review: in 2026 Table S8, the printed corrected F14C for USGS-2074, -2075 and -2076 does not equal measured F14C plus the printed correction factor, as specified in its footnote. For example, 0.0813 + 0.0146 = 0.0959, whereas USGS-2074’s printed corrected value is 0.0911. The workbook preserves both the published figures and a formula check. This is an internal table discrepancy requiring clarification; it does not establish a revised chronology. Sample-name aliases and several 2025 depth/range anomalies are also flagged rather than silently repaired. [S4 · Holliday et al. (2025); S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026)]

Verification limits: the 2026 S4, S8 and S9d tables were checked against rendered supplementary PDF pages. Earlier calibrated values are explicitly attributed to that 2026 compilation. The 2023 main paper’s stratigraphic figure was inspected, but the original OSL supplementary Table S2 and exact sample elevations remain unverified. Individual OSL values reprinted in the 2024 critique are included only as provisional transcriptions, with provenance and missing fields. Rhode et al. §4.5 describes the original age errors as 2σ, while its recalculated scenarios use 1σ; this is secondary attribution, not original-table verification. Full paired critique/rebuttal review remains open. [S1 · Bennett et al. (2021); S2 · Pigati et al. (2023); S3 · Pigati et al. (2024); S4 · Holliday et al. (2025); S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026); S21 · Rhode et al. (2024)]

Horizon context and movement comparison — October 28, 2026

Open the horizon-by-horizon comparison.

The comparison now joins all 20 chronological units to Table S1’s 19 counting records and Table S15’s 15 aquatic-microfossil samples. TP10 and TP11 share one count/area record, and TH(-2)‘s count and area are unreported. Reported animal taxa are presence observations, not abundance estimates or evidence of absence elsewhere. [S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026)]

Accounting for area reverses a raw-count ranking: TH4 has 37 human prints in 6.70 m² (5.52/m²), while TH(-3) has seven in 0.26 m² (26.92/m²). This is a calculated exposure comparison, not a preservation-adjusted behavioral trend. Several published individuals/m² values also fail to reproduce MNI/area; both printed inputs and outputs remain preserved for review. The new research queue prioritizes mapped trackway direction, turning and overprinting on comparable surfaces, beginning with a feasibility assessment of TH2 and TH3. [S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026)]

TH2–TH3 assessment completed. Read the focused follow-up. The original 2021 archive now supplies a keyed inventory of 13 TH2/TH3 prints and eight unique referenced models. Numerical image registration now strongly supports the same photographic base: the central patch is labeled TH3 in the 2025 Fig. 13A and TH2 in the 2026 Fig. S12. All 1,281 withheld feature matches align within two image pixels. Both source assignments are preserved pending stratigraphic reconciliation; photographic identity does not decide which label is correct. Step 2 traces LF-5 into the detailed section, supporting a provisional TH3 interpretation while exposing an apparent conflict with the overview plans already in 2025. Step 3 audits the consequences: TH4 also requires label review; source counts and age outputs are retained while physical-surface joins remain blocked. Local alignment and trace-order questions can advance; a cross-horizon movement trend cannot yet be isolated from identity, exposure and preservation uncertainty. [S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026); S6 · Bennett et al. (2025); S320 · Bennett, M. (2021)]

Current disposition: LF-5 — horizon assignment unresolved.1 The focused public-record check did not recover the LF-5-to-seed connection or a correction defining its scope; separate ScienceBase release files were inaccessible. The label issue is parked pending new primary evidence. The next local task is to inspect source-keyed TH3-6 and TH3-7 in shared model T038S, without assigning an age or assuming simultaneous travel.

3. What can the tracks support about people and activities?

Interpretation becomes stronger when several independent features agree. A single footprint shape can reflect the walker, mud consistency, slipping, preservation, and excavation.

Observed evidenceSupported interpretationLimit to preserve
Long, continuous directional trails; repeated steps; overprinting in the Locality 3 double trackwayMovement across the landscape and an outward/return sequence. [S22 · Bennett et al. (2020)]Purpose and destination remain unknown.
Small child prints intermittently beside the larger trail; changes in larger-footprint morphologyChild carrying is a plausible explanation favored by the authors. [S22 · Bennett et al. (2020)]“Mother carrying her baby” adds unverified sex, kinship, and exact age. Even the same-person outward/return identification is an inference.
Different footprint sizesMore than one size class can be present; some are consistent with children. [S1 · Bennett et al. (2021); S23 · Bustos et al. (2018)]Foot size is an imperfect age proxy. Many prints can belong to one person; pooled prints from different layers are not a group census or family reconstruction.
Human prints placed inside sloth tracks, changes in sloth direction, and claw/pivot tracesClose interaction; the authors favor stalking or harassment consistent with hunting. [S23 · Bustos et al. (2018)]No demonstrated kill follows from these traces. Deliberate following is better supported than a complete hunting narrative.
Long single or paired grooves associated with human tracksA human-drawn dragging device, interpreted as a travois, is favored in the 2025 study. [S6 · Bennett et al. (2025)]The wood and cargo were not recovered. Association, geometry, experimental analogy, and alternative causes must be assessed together.

Working assessment: movement is directly recorded; carrying and dragging are reasoned behavioral interpretations; sex, kinship, specific occupations, settlement organization, and a successful hunt require additional evidence. A trace can be highly informative about one event while revealing little about the population as a whole.

4. How does White Sands compare under the same evidence standards?

Apply the same questions to every claim: Is the evidence human-made? Is it in primary context? What exactly was dated? How tightly is the date connected to activity? What independent checks and alternative explanations exist? Avoid a single numerical “certainty score,” which would hide differences among these questions.

RecordHuman activity and associationChronology and checksWhat the comparison supports
White Sands, Locality 2Excavated anatomical footprints in a sediment sequence.Multiple dating materials/methods, revised age modeling, and regional stratigraphy; reservoir effects and sample context must be assessed explicitly. [S1 · Bennett et al. (2021); S2 · Pigati et al. (2023); S3 · Pigati et al. (2024); S4 · Holliday et al. (2025); S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026); S21 · Rhode et al. (2024)]Strong evidence of local LGM presence. It does not by itself establish ancestry, entry route, or first arrival.
Monte Verde IIDiverse archaeological and organic materials in a documented occupation context.Approximately 14,500 years is the excavators’ interpretation; the 2026 younger-age challenge and published rebuttal dispute the deposit–occupation relationship. [S7 · Meltzer et al. (1997); S8 · Chile National Monuments Council (2004); S9 · Dillehay et al. (2008); S10 · Dillehay et al. (2015); S11 · Surovell et al. (March 19, 2026); S12 · Dillehay et al. (August 19, 2026)]Apply the same association test used at White Sands. Keep the dispute visible; neither prestige nor one new paper settles it automatically.
Clovis / Blackwater DrawDiagnostic manufactured artifacts and documented animal associations; Clovis is a tradition represented at multiple sites.The 2020 screened synthesis gives approximately 13,050–12,750 cal BP for the included Clovis record. Individual sites and samples still need their own context checks. [S15 · Eastern New Mexico University / Blackwater Draw National Historic Landmark and Museum, …; S16 · Waters, Stafford, and Carlson (2020)]Strong evidence of a widespread later tradition. Its existence cannot establish that no earlier people were present.
Page-Ladson, Florida — comparison referenceStone tools and mastodon remains in a buried sinkhole context.Halligan and colleagues report approximately 14,550 cal BP from a sequence supported by 71 radiocarbon ages. Those are dates across the study, not 71 direct dates on one tool. [S27 · Halligan et al. (2016)]A useful additional pre-Clovis comparator with a different depositional setting. Butchery/scavenging evidence does not distinguish a hunt from scavenging by itself.

Timeline rule: plot calibrated age distributions or explicitly labeled published estimates. Do not place the 2018 uncalibrated sloth interval on the same numerical axis as cal BP without calibration. A regional tradition’s duration, a site’s occupation, and an individual walking event are different kinds of time spans.

Page-Ladson is included here as a sourced comparison reference; its full site dossier remains future work.

5. What do Indigenous communities’ published accounts contribute?

These accounts contribute homeland geography, historical continuity, ancestral relationships, and priorities for interpreting and caring for places. Record the community and speaker or publisher, the genre, and the context. Do not convert an account into an archaeological date or treat one speaker as representing all Indigenous peoples.

Community / sourcePublicly shared contributionContext and attribution
Mescalero Apache Tribe — official “Our Culture” historySituates homeland around Sierra Blanca, the Guadalupe Mountains, Three Sisters Mountain, and Oscura Mountain Peak; identifies White Mountain with creation and teachings transmitted by grandparents. It also explains the Mescalero, Lipan, and Chiricahua composition of today’s tribe. [S24 · Mescalero Apache Tribe, Our Culture.]A community-published account of homeland and living cultural relationships in the wider region. Preserve its sacred and historical setting; do not reinterpret its narrative figures as a dated fossil inventory.
Pueblo of Acoma — official public history and Tribal Historic Preservation OfficeThe Pueblo’s historical account addresses Spanish encounters, coercion, violence, and survival. Its preservation office describes responsibility for cultural history, language, archives, and archaeological places on and off tribal lands. [S25 · Pueblo of Acoma, Tribal Historic Preservation Office.; S28 · Pueblo of Acoma, Archaeology and Legend: How Old is Acoma?]These establish community-authored historical and stewardship context. Neither publication supplies a calendar age or a specific identity for the White Sands trackmakers.
Kim Charlie, identified as from the Pueblo of Acoma — PBS NOVA interviewReferring to the footprints, she says: “Footprints, footprints of our ancestors.” [S26 · PBS NOVA (May 25, 2022)]A named person’s public response within a documentary about the discoveries. This is a primary recorded perspective mediated by a broadcaster, distinct from an official Pueblo statement or a community-published history.
Joe Watkins, Choctaw Nation of Oklahoma archaeologist — same interviewDiscusses how the new archaeological dates extend the time depth recognized in public accounts of Indigenous history. [S26 · PBS NOVA (May 25, 2022)]Attribute his professional and personal perspective to him; his participation alone does not establish a Choctaw-specific ancestral claim to this locality.

Repository interpretation: “discovery” here describes archaeological documentation and dating. It should not imply that Indigenous relationships with this landscape began when researchers recognized the footprints. Archaeological evidence and attributed community histories answer overlapping but different questions; neither should be flattened into the other’s vocabulary.

This is a first public-source selection, not a complete inventory of affiliated communities or consultation with them. Public summaries do not authorize access to restricted knowledge. A future expansion should prioritize additional publications chosen or issued by the relevant communities themselves.

Ledger follow-up: what changed

Open the research review for the correction-to-model comparison, feature links, measurement counts and remaining verification work. The original version-1 workbook stays frozen; the live ledger and this review record subsequent checks.

The S8 problem reaches the printed model inputs. Tables S7–S8 and the model-4 P_Sequence page were visually checked against the original 2026 supplement. Both published model-4 code blocks use the S8 corrected radiocarbon ages: 18,820, 19,240, 19,100 and 19,620 BP for USGS-2073 through -2076. Thus the discrepancy is not demonstrated to be display-only. Our arithmetic diagnostics are not replacement measurements, calibrations or a rerun of the model. The USGS data release is identified, but its files could not be retrieved for comparison. [S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026); S142 · U.S. Geological Survey. Date release for Humans experienced abrupt environmental changes at White Sands during the Last Glacial Maximum (2026)]

2021 metadata recovered provisionally. Public reproductions of supplementary Table S5 provide all 11 field/laboratory pairs, elevations, seed counts and four replicate labels. The field IDs, elevations, measured ages/errors and replicate flags agree with the 2026-compilation ledger. These are seven field IDs, not eleven independently dated surfaces. The reproduced methods specify acid-base-acid pretreatment and OxCal 4.4.2 / IntCal20. Publisher-file integrity and the original USGS data files remain unverified; the access-copy register is explicitly provisional. [S1 · Bennett et al. (2021); S140 · U.S. Geological Survey. Data release for Evidence of humans in North America during the Last Glacial Maximum (2021); S144 · Bennett et al. (2021)]

Rounding does not explain the S8 discrepancies. With three values rounded to four decimal places, the largest residual compatible with rounding is 0.00015 F14C. The observed absolute residuals are 0.0048, 0.0024 and 0.0011. This is our arithmetic diagnostic, not an author-issued correction. Table S7 distinguishes paired pollen measurements for 2074 and 2076 from interpolated controls for 2073 and 2075. The intended corrected values and their uncertainties still need documented resolution. [S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026); S142 · U.S. Geological Survey. Date release for Humans experienced abrupt environmental changes at White Sands during the Last Glacial Maximum (2026)]

A documented feature link, with limits. Bennett et al. explicitly correlate Areas A–D with TH2 through lithostratigraphy and lateral tracing (§2; Figs.2–3). We record this as an author-reported correlation. It does not transfer TH2’s age to all linear traces in the park. Locality 3 remains unlinked, as does an automatic mapping from the 2025 TH8–TH16 labels to 2026 TP8–TP16. Matching numbers alone do not establish matching package boundaries. Dragging firewood remains an alternative to a constructed transport device for some traces. [S5 · Springer et al. (October 14, 2026); S6 · Bennett et al. (2025); S22 · Bennett et al. (2020)]

Counts now distinguish tracks, observations and people. Locality 3’s speed analysis uses 427 step/stride measurements from an 800 m mosaic: northbound N=233, mean estimated speed 1.7 m/s; southbound N=194, mean 1.6 m/s. These are repeated measurements along journeys, not 427 individuals. The 2021 Locality 2 study’s 61 documented human tracks are pooled across surfaces, not a simultaneous group census. [S1 · Bennett et al. (2021); S22 · Bennett et al. (2020)]

Community source added. The Mescalero Apache Tribe’s March 2018 Apache Scout (p.14) publishes a Prevention Program account of an herb-collection outing. It names Arden Comanche and James Kunetsis sharing plant history and uses at White Sands National Monument. This is a community program report for community readers, including youth activities. The passage calls the outing “October” without explicitly stating its year. It documents living cultural relationships with the landscape; it does not date the footprints or identify their makers. [S143 · Mescalero Apache Tribe (March 2018)]

Atlas/globe coverage checked: the provisional metadata and rounding check add no dating event or replacement chronology. The existing Locality 2 marker retains the published 23,500–21,700 BP range and now explicitly flags the unresolved S8/model-input problem. Locality 3 remains unplotted because this review does not establish a compatible absolute date. Correlated TH2 surfaces are not added as independent dating events, and the newsletter is indexed as community context.

Focused research queue — current status

Compare everyday life

Life before the Younger Dryas compares White Sands and Monte Verde through shelter, food, children, movement and skills. Dated activity, uncertain behavioral episodes and broader population histories remain distinct.

Footnotes

  1. The 2025 detailed account calls the LF-5 patch TH3; the same photographed patch is TH2 in the 2026 figure. No verified connection to the dated seed level or clarification of annotation versus inventory/sample effects was recovered. Its canonical horizon and feature age remain unassigned. See the final field/sample check for sources and access limits. ↩